3 ms·

Introducing MAUI, the .NET Multi-Platform App UI

52 points by LyalinDotCom 6y ago

lucas_membrane 6y ago
Multi-platform, but nothing for linux!?!?!
- alkonaut 6y ago
  Microsoft officielly maintains the Android/iOS/Windows plattforms in Xamarin.Forms. There are other platforms too, e.g MacOS, Tizen and GTK# which are community supported. It’s not clear whether those will continue to work in the same way as community supported platforms. https://github.com/xamarin/Xamarin.Forms/wiki/Platform-Support https://github.com/xamarin/Xamarin.Forms/wiki/Platform-Suppo...
- Kipters 6y ago
  I can see Gtk stuff in the repo. Anyway, Scott Hanselman just told live that they'll look into Linux support after getting macOS and Windows running
- pjmlp 6y ago
  I guess they would need to be multi-distribution as well.
sansnomme 6y ago
There goes Flutter's lunch. Now if only they can add GUI builder support, right now Swift UI is the only new generation UI framework with proper GUI builder support (through Xcode).
- pjmlp 6y ago
  Flutter doomed itself trying to be Dart's rescue board. If Fuchsia follows the path of other Google's side projects, I expect Flutter to follow quickly afterwards. Being at the enterprise most of my career, I bet they just got a budget and a set of targets to prove themselves. You won't find much love for Flutter from PWA or native Android forums.
- jagannathtech 6y ago
  correct me if I'm wrong but isn't this just xamarin under the hood? it's flutter which ate xamarin's lunch.
  - Mertax 6y ago
    Trying to understand this too. Looks like an “evolution” (rebrand?) of Xamarin.Forms. Although potentially (hopefully?) a way to support rendering engines other than native control/widget binding like Xamarin.Forms does today? More likely an attempt to extend the Xamarin.Forms native rendering concept to more desktop UI frameworks (GTK, WPF, MacOS, Tizen) rather than just mobile?
    - memsom 6y ago
      Xamarin Forms already supports those platforms and you can use them today. The main stumbling block is that the tooling doesn't have project templates for those platforms yet. So you need to manually create the MacOS or WPF projects. Also, this new System.Maui looks like it will make everything in one unified project with platform specific code conditionally compiled in - at the moment Xamarin Forms is a bit more messy than that, requiring a project for each platform that share a common library to make the UI work on all platforms. The new stuff looks nice, so hopefully it'll be here on the schedule they mentioned (circa 2021)

52 points by LyalinDotCom 6y ago

lucas_membrane 6y ago

Multi-platform, but nothing for linux!?!?!

alkonaut 6y ago
Microsoft officielly maintains the Android/iOS/Windows plattforms in Xamarin.Forms. There are other platforms too, e.g MacOS, Tizen and GTK# which are community supported. It’s not clear whether those will continue to work in the same way as community supported platforms. https://github.com/xamarin/Xamarin.Forms/wiki/Platform-Support https://github.com/xamarin/Xamarin.Forms/wiki/Platform-Suppo...
Kipters 6y ago
I can see Gtk stuff in the repo. Anyway, Scott Hanselman just told live that they'll look into Linux support after getting macOS and Windows running
pjmlp 6y ago
I guess they would need to be multi-distribution as well.

sansnomme 6y ago

There goes Flutter's lunch. Now if only they can add GUI builder support, right now Swift UI is the only new generation UI framework with proper GUI builder support (through Xcode).

pjmlp 6y ago
Flutter doomed itself trying to be Dart's rescue board. If Fuchsia follows the path of other Google's side projects, I expect Flutter to follow quickly afterwards. Being at the enterprise most of my career, I bet they just got a budget and a set of targets to prove themselves. You won't find much love for Flutter from PWA or native Android forums.
jagannathtech 6y ago
correct me if I'm wrong but isn't this just xamarin under the hood? it's flutter which ate xamarin's lunch.
- Mertax 6y ago
  Trying to understand this too. Looks like an “evolution” (rebrand?) of Xamarin.Forms. Although potentially (hopefully?) a way to support rendering engines other than native control/widget binding like Xamarin.Forms does today? More likely an attempt to extend the Xamarin.Forms native rendering concept to more desktop UI frameworks (GTK, WPF, MacOS, Tizen) rather than just mobile?
  - memsom 6y ago
    Xamarin Forms already supports those platforms and you can use them today. The main stumbling block is that the tooling doesn't have project templates for those platforms yet. So you need to manually create the MacOS or WPF projects. Also, this new System.Maui looks like it will make everything in one unified project with platform specific code conditionally compiled in - at the moment Xamarin Forms is a bit more messy than that, requiring a project for each platform that share a common library to make the UI work on all platforms. The new stuff looks nice, so hopefully it'll be here on the schedule they mentioned (circa 2021)