5 ms·
UNICEF is now predicting 6,000 child deaths per day due to food and medical supply issues. It turns out you need an economy to fight the virus. All these knoc
by mensetmanusman 7y ago
UNICEF is now predicting 6,000 child deaths per day due to food and medical supply issues.
It turns out you need an economy to fight the virus.
All these knock on effects will be great learnings. Probably will turn out that future policy will be a local function of population density, public transportation usage, etc.
- syshum 7y agoHopefully this will shutdown all the "if you want to talk about the economy you want people to die" rhetoric i keep seeing all over the place. The economy is how people survive, it is not wall street like many people seem to believe, no economy == no food. No amount of government money printing will solve that
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt's not as simple as that either. There was no option for COVID-19 to not cause problems like these, unless every nation cooperated to pretend the virus doesn't exist and sweep the deaths under the rug. As it is HoReCa sector was going to have very tough times with or without a lockdown, most of the demand for eating out would've evaporated anyway, and to the extent they didn't, you'd have that many more temporary closures as infected people were traced back to various venues. Consider also that meat processing plants weren't going through shutdowns due to being non-essential, but because they had actual outbreaks on-site. Economics isn't Wall Street, and we've learned it's impossible to do a clean split between essential and non-essential businesses, as the connections upstream in the supply chain are convoluted and non-obvious (and often enough, companies themselves don't have visibility into their own chains). But that doesn't mean we would be better off pretending the pandemic isn't happening, and just enduring the cost in lives.
- syshum 7y ago>> Consider also that meat processing plants weren't going through shutdowns due to being non-essential, but because they had actual outbreaks on-site. Yes but much of this could have been mitigated by an actual mitigation plan not this failed policy of "stay at home" and attempting to arbitrarily define essential and non-essential. You know things like Mask wearing that was advised against by the government and "The Experts"™ we are all suppose to surrender our lives to >>we've learned it's impossible to do a clean split between essential and non-essential businesses That is because every business is essential to the people that own, work, and consume goods / sevices from those business. The idea that the government is the best entity to to choose what is and is not essential is just asinine on its face >>But that doesn't mean we would be better off pretending the pandemic isn't happening the number of people saying that is statically 0, sure you have some nut cases that CNN and MSNBC love to parade out on the nightly news as an example of the "average person" that is agaist the lock down orders, but in reality there are more people like me that are using logic and reason to see through the emotional panic and fear that is at the core of the lock down orders to see how irrational and ineffective they really are. We are also advocating for actual mitigation that is proportional to the risk that this virus poses based on actual data, and revision of those plans as new data comes in In Feb and march based on the data at that time the lockdowns made sense. As we have learned more about how it spreads, who is at risk, what can be done to mitigate the spread and about 100 other things complete shutdowns make less and less sense outside of a few high dense area's of population.
- carapace 7y agoIt's like an invisible fire. If you can't see the fire the best you can do is isolate the flammable materials from each other. Once we can see the fire we can be more sophisticated in how we fight it.
- carapace 7y agoThe problem is that our economy is not as resilient to a pandemic as we would hope. Centralization of meat supply was economically desirable in a perfect world that doesn't contain e.g. Covid-19. However, since the world does contain that virus (and many others!) it behooves us to arrange our economic systems is ways that are resilient to viral pandemics. Unless and until we can develop rapid identification and mediation technology mass international travel is a thing of the past. Covid-19 isn't the only virus in the world. In computer terms, our "attack surface" is too large. I'm a proponent of applied ecology (Permaculture, et. al.) but not a virologist or epidemiologist, I like to think that a biomemetic agriculture would be both more humane and safer. (FWIW) I think we will have to create a kind of "cellular" society.
- carapace 7y agoOn the "new" list today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23251734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23251734 https://www.hcn.org/articles/covid-19-will-covid-19-help-save-small-slaughterhouses https://www.hcn.org/articles/covid-19-will-covid-19-help-sav... "Will COVID-19 help save small slaughterhouses?" > As laborers for the Big Four meatpackers fall ill, small slaughterhouses see unprecedented demand. > From 1990 to 2016, the U.S. lost more than 1800 livestock slaughterhouses, 40% of the industry. As small slaughterhouses closed, the so-called “Big Four” meatpacking companies — Tyson, Cargill, JBS and National Beef — came to dominate the industry. Today, these four companies process more than 80% of beef in the U.S. There it is: optimization of one metric to the detriment of others, resulting in overfitting, and exposed during a pandemic to rare-but-predictable crisis, it falls over.