4 ms·
This sounds very much like another instance of unintended consequences triggered by good intentions. We're seeing this more and more on many topics linked to h
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
This sounds very much like another instance of unintended consequences triggered by good intentions.
We're seeing this more and more on many topics linked to human rights where things stemmed from a good intention but resulted in sweeping and far-ranging consequences.
Here for example I don't see how anything good in practice can result from this decision. I'm sure that the BND already has procedures to decide who to spy on, both because of operational and political concerns. Adding more restrictions based on "human rights" really only impede operations when they should be nimble and might push them more underground, i.e. with less oversight. My guess is that they'll find a way to have a procedure and paperwork in order to follow the letter of this decision but that in practice nothing will change at all because that would harm national interests.
- ketzu 7y agoIf I get your last point correctly, it implies that state spy agencies should not be restricted by laws, because it will make them ignore those laws and undermine oversight. But oversight is worthless with that premise anyways, because there aren't any laws restricting the agency.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoYou are not getting my point correctly. Spy agencies are restricted by laws and should be restricted by laws. But it should be sensible taking into account the reality of what these agencies are and do, and not based on idealism. Their purpose and what they do has not changed and will not change because of this decision because there is a need to protect national interests and that is not achieved by being a boy scout. Therefore they will try to find a way to get around it as much as possible, be it in the drafting of the new law or in practice.
- jacobr1 7y agoIt is the classic tradeoff: regulation vs. banning for "unsavory" practices. This is perhaps easier to see with drugs, gambling, and sex-work. And of course, it gets more complicated because, within broad categories, specific practices maybe be banned even within a regulatory framework.
- fit2rule 7y agoThe way they get around it: the CIA bases in Germany are allowed to spy, since they are not sovereign German territory. And, since the BND answers to the CIA, sharing of information will be up to the CIA, according to the national interest of the USA first, and Germany second.
- ginko 7y agoSurely the problem isn't the German constitution, it's that other governments don't have similar protections in their constitutions.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe laws of foreign countries are immaterial to intelligence agencies. In fact breaking the laws of foreign countries is pretty much part of the job of intelligence agencies.
- ginko 7y agoIf intelligence agencies want to play silly Spy vs. Spy games that's their problem, but they shouldn't bother civilians.
- fit2rule 7y agoThe only way to ensure that happens is for the civilians to bother the spy agencies - i.e. civilian journalism with reveals the criminal activities of the spy agencies. And we all know how well that approach is doing lately.