6 ms·
German intelligence can't spy on foreigners outside Germany
- AaronFriel 7y agoSoon: Six Eyes
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mc32 7y agoWhen will it be eight so they can have an arachnid mission patch with eight eyes on it? (Though some species have six).
- aey 7y agoAfaik Germany is not part of 5 eyes or 9 eyes. There seems to be a tiny bit of ww2 era resentment there.
- jkaplowitz 7y agoThey're not, but there is lots of collaboration between BND and agencies who are.
- johannes1234321 7y agoEspecially since BND (or the predecessor "Operation Gehlen") was established to large parts due to American interest in German spying experience regarding the Soviet Union.
- rsynnott 7y ago> There seems to be a tiny bit of ww2 era resentment there. Well, also, (amply justified by Germany's history) public distrust of mass surveillance. Joining wouldn't really be politically viable.
- squiggleblaz 7y agoIsn't that point of the "6 eyes" comment? Theirs would be be the sixth.
- KarlKemp 7y agoThat.. doesn't make much sense? The whole point is to prevent the outsourcing of illegal surveillance. In any case, the BND suddenly became a lot less attractive for any intelligence-sharing deals.
- fit2rule 6y agoI think its more that the German intelligence services are not liable to the German sovereign, but are rather still 'occupied' by the USA's own military/intelligence agencies.
- theferalrobot 7y agoGermany is already part of the 14 eyes agreement and has been moving to join the current 5 eyes
- k__ 7y agoFunny, considering that the job of the BND is collecting information from foreign countries.
- nwellnhof 7y agoThe headline is misleading. The court only ruled blanket internet surveillance illegal.
- dgellow 7y agoYes, I considered submitting the link with a better title than the article’s one. Though I wasn’t sure if that would be or not against the rules. Maybe dang can update it with something more to the point.
- pyuser583 7y agoIt’s allowed to change misleading titles.
- floatingatoll 7y agoThat's permitted by the rules if you think that the alteration is justified. If you're worried about being censured, you can include a comment on your new post "The original title was XYZ I altered it because reasoning ABC", so that if the mods are looking at it later, they understand your reasoning and can offer you a followup reply.
- Krasnol 7y agoConsider that Deutsche Welle is a media outlet controlled and funded by the Government and therefore not really a good source for such news. They did not forbid the BND to spy on foreigners. They can still do this, however the current regulation does not protect journalists for example. In the current case it would have been possible for a rogue Government to request BND data on journalists from their country and prosecute them. This goes against fundamental German laws and the new BND regulation needs to take this into account. The new BND regulation also needs to clearly outline why they spy or why they share data with foreign agencies. There will also be a new oversight/control body with it's own budget and personal. Up until now, they were able to do pretty much whatever they wanted as long as it didn't concern Germans and even that was not really working since they were collecting bulk data at internet exchange points for example.
- floatingatoll 7y agoThe article title is terrible; or, at least, incomplete without the subheading, but this is still very relevant to privacy: Germany's Constitutional Court ruled on Tuesday that monitoring the internet traffic of foreign nationals abroad by the BND intelligence agency partly breaches the constitution. And this paragraph provides more nuance: The ruling said that non-Germans were also protected by Germany's constitutional rights, and that the current law lacked special protection for the work of lawyers and journalists. This applied both to the collection and processing of data as well as passing on that data to other intelligence agencies. Essentially: The law as written does not sufficiently protect the constitutional rights of all human beings, so the intelligence service is directed to improve the law to provide enforceable protections as were found absent.
- coliveira 7y agoWhat a difference to the USA. The constitution there is not applied whenever some obscure official dims it necessary to spy on anyone (citizen or not) for "supposedly" national security reasons.
- linksnapzz 7y agoThe US Constitution has been described as, and is routinely applied as though it is... "not a suicide pact".
- AndrewKemendo 7y ago"The ruling said that non-Germans were also protected by Germany's constitutional rights" That's a pretty big task if it's not heavily caveated. I'm curious how they manage conflicts around citizenship and constitutional reach then. I'd love to hear a German Constitutional scholar weigh in. If their constitution protects non-citizens does that mean that German police/military are required constitutionally to protect non-Germans from acts by non-German states or individuals? Are there any positive rights in the German constitution (like a right to be provided legal counsel) that a non-German citizen could "charge" the government for so to speak? It seems based on this interpretation that someone from - say Nicaragua - could claim that the Nicaraguan government is in violation of German constitution and the German government would be obliged to provide counsel to the Nicaraguan citizen.
- elchin 7y agoThe article makes it look like Germany shared data with Azerbaijan - was that the case?
- dgellow 7y agoThe quoted person from the article says that they had issues with surveillance from the Azerbaijan services, as a example of a bad state of affairs. There is not implications of data being shared, in fact she says the opposite. Quote: > “I suffered a lot in Azerbaijan from the unlimited power of the government and their abuse of anti-terror legislation, which also allowed them to interfere with my privacy and expose my intimate life," she said in an emailed statement. "I am happy that democratic checks and balances are still operational in Germany and it was possible to revert the abusive laws which could be used as instruments against whistleblowers and journalists."
- KarlKemp 7y agoOne of the plaintiffs was a journalist from Azerbaijan (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khadija_Ismayilov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khadija_Ismayilov). While it's not likely that the BND would share information about them directly with the government of Azerbaijan, the fear was that it would be shared with other services, which might take fewer precautions when passing it on. It could also leak, either accidentally or as a result of other countries' spying efforts.
- KarlKemp 7y agoMy partner works at the NGO and was part of the team that brought, fought, and won this case (https://freiheitsrechte.org/english/ https://freiheitsrechte.org/english/). Happy to (try to) answer any questions.
- FearNotDaniel 7y agoOf course it can. Perhaps it may not. But that doesn't mean it won't.
- LatteLazy 7y agoNice to see a court that cares about a constitution...
- ngcc_hk 7y agoIs this "can't spy" or just a directive to improve and protect foreigner? Also, they are spy. No one like spying but it is a necessity. In fact, sometimes you cannot let other country be told directly you "inform" their spy! Not sure why they are not allowing to do their job by their own constitution? Limits definitely needed internally, but externally?