6 ms·
They came up with the term, and it's extremely widely used that way. And large parts of the software community will assume malice on your part if you present so
by detaro 7y ago
They came up with the term, and it's extremely widely used that way. And large parts of the software community will assume malice on your part if you present something as open source that doesn't fit the definition.
EDIT: IMHO it's in the best interest of everyone working on such licenses to come up with a new positive term and position that, instead of burning goodwill by trying to co-opt the "open source" label. (E.g. if I remember correctly, in the discussions around cloud software, "fair software" was one label used. Nice and positive word, not stepping on existing communities toes). And in reverse I hope people would be accepting of attempts with such new licenses if they keep the messaging straight.
- matz1 7y agoJust because it's widely use doesn't mean anything. No one as monopoly or single authority of open source definition.
- zozbot234 7y agoExcept they kinda do, seeing as OSI holds the literal trademark to open source.
- gpm 7y agoNot only do they not hold a trademark, they tried to acquire a trademark and failed because it was "too descriptive" (and I suspect because it was already in use). See my comment above for links: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23234029 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23234029
- detaro 7y agoNobody has a single authority on what words mean. That doesn't mean terms don't have established meanings, and it'll make things difficult for you if you insist on using them differently.
- SXX 7y agoAs a private person you're free to use words as you wish, but in this case this is false advertising by a company. Go on try to sell some pork dish as "vegan" or "kosher" food and I'll look how fast you'll be brought to a court. This is no different.
- matz1 7y agoYou can always try to brought any one for any reason to a court, doesn't mean you will succeed.
- m0llusk 7y agoYou are being blinded by your political agenda. This source code is readily available and costs nothing, thus it is both open and free. Much of the machinery here is relevant to me, so I can learn about the nature of the system through the code and adapt design lessons to completely unrelated applications. Without this free and open code no such thing would be possible. I understand that you have nothing but loathing and contempt for my approach to software development and you are welcome to promote your philosophy but you will find it impossible to bend simple language to your wishes as long as there are people who see things completely differently.
- vertex-four 7y agoMicrosoft disagrees with you, and has since at least 2001, well before they cared about open source software at all. They use the terms "source-available" or "shared source". So do... all the other big enterprises. They don't want to confuse people; they want the restrictions on licensing to be clear. What words would you like me to use for open source software that you're not going to trample over in 5 years when it becomes convenient for advertising your software?
- gpm 7y ago> What words would you like me to use for open source software that you're not going to trample over in 5 years when it becomes convenient for advertising your software? Option a) Makeup a non-generic not already in use term and trademark it. Option b) Just say "licensed under <well_known_license>". What you're required to do to get the exclusivity you're looking for is well established in the rules we are all required to play by known as "the law".
- vertex-four 7y agoYou're suggesting that language is meaningless - that communicating a shared understanding is not a goal of language.
- matz1 7y agoI'm suggesting language is fluid, never static.
- vertex-four 7y agoSo I can just decide that "Donald Trump is a space alien" actually means that I'm gonna go buy a burger today, and this isn't going to mislead anyone at all? How about that "water" can now be used do describe any clear liquid, including sulfuric acid? Go find your own words. "Shared source" has been used for literally decades to mean Defold's exact situation - why would you not use that?
- matz1 7y ago>So I can just decide that "Donald Trump is a space alien" actually means that I'm gonna go buy a burger today, and this isn't going to mislead anyone at all Yes you can, some people will hate it some people will like it, just like anything else
- vertex-four 7y agoThe moon is made of cheese. Flubber dub. Go drink some water. Language is useless when it can't be used to create shared understanding.
- matz1 7y agoUseless to you maybe, not everyone has the same purpose. Ok so for the purpose of "shared understanding", let use my preferred definition of open source then.
- gpm 7y agoIt's well documented that the term was in use, referring to "source available" software no less, before they claim to have invented it. It might be a case of two groups coming up with the same term, but they were not the first. - The OSI claims to have coined the term in 1988 https://opensource.com/article/18/2/coining-term-open-source.. https://opensource.com/article/18/2/coining-term-open-source.... - Here is a use of the term, 7 times, and as the main object, from 1996 http://www.xent.com/FoRK-archive/fall96/0269.html http://www.xent.com/FoRK-archive/fall96/0269.html - Here is a use of the term, as a proper noun, from 1993 https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/comp.os.ms-windows.programmer.win32/WoBvPB0U9Co/wXfpq5nEJTYJ https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/comp.os.ms-windows.pro... On a separate note the OSI's original mission statement was (https://web.archive.org/web/20000408035603/http://opensource.org/press_releases/osi-launch.html https://web.archive.org/web/20000408035603/http://opensource...) > The Open Source Initiative's mission will be to own and defend the Open Source trademark, to manage the www.opensource.org resources, to develop branding programs attractive to software customers and producers, and to advance the cause of open-source software and serve the hacker community in other appropriate way Which they since abandoned because "there is virtually no chance that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office would register the mark "open source"; the mark is too descriptive" (and one suspects because the mark was already in use in trade of software, see the xent.com link above) https://opensource.org/pressreleases/certified-open-source.php https://opensource.org/pressreleases/certified-open-source.p... They have no special rights to the term open source. I wish people (including the OSI) would stop pretending otherwise. You can think that it's a good idea to use their definition without relying on falsehoods.
- dwheeler 7y agoThe word computer used to refer only to humans who did computation. If today you said I have a powerful computer, and brought out a human, other people would correctly claim that you are misleading them. The phrase open source software has an extremely well-known meaning. Uses like this, which fraudulently claim to be open source software even though they fail to comply with the normal definition as used for over 20 years, is simply an exploitative fraud. If they want to join the open source community, they would be very welcome. But trying to say that they're part of a community they're not is not okay. It's especially dangerous to the people who are not familiar with the law and might make big decisions for themselves based on falsehoods. Today, trying to use that phrase in the way they're using it is deceptive.