5 ms·
For anyone who's used this, how does it compare with popular open source engines like Godot, and with the commercial industry standards like Unreal Engine and U
by taneq 6y ago
For anyone who's used this, how does it compare with popular open source engines like Godot, and with the commercial industry standards like Unreal Engine and Unity?
- walkingolof 6y agoLong story short, Defold emphasize 2D (but can do 3D) and is scriptable in Lua with a neat IDE. This gives a good overview https://defold.com/product/ https://defold.com/product/
- vertex-four 6y agoGodot is actually open source, unlike this - you can modify it however you like and still sell your game. Defold allows you to see the internals, but if something doesn't work the way you want, you can't change it and still get to sell your game.
- AGulev 6y agoThe only one restriction: you can't sell the engine itself! You can sell the game made with Defold. You don't understand something or you are misleading people.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoNo, they are correct. 'Open Source' is a term-of-art in the software world. We use the OSI's definition, which is a good deal stricter than just making the source available. The licence used by Defold is not an Open Source licence. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23233336 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23233336 , https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235217 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235217
- vonmoltke 6y agovertex-four is correct that Defold is not Open Source. This statement, however, is absolutely wrong: > Defold allows you to see the internals, but if something doesn't work the way you want, you can't change it and still get to sell your game.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoI think you're right. Their summary says: > You are free to modify Defold and you are not required to share the changes but also: > You can not commercialise original or modified (derivative) versions of the Defold editor and/or engine I think they mean you cannot start a business selling your fork of their game-engine. I don't think they mean you may not use a modified engine in a commercial product. This seems to fit with the full text of the licence, which says: > You do not sell or otherwise commercialise the Work or Derivative Works as a Game Engine Product
- nybble41 6y agoI think it would be pretty hard to distinguish between commercializing a game with a modified Defold engine which can be heavily modded by the player and commercializing a modified Defold game engine. Quite a few games have been modded into entirely different games sharing only the engine. Just something to think about if you were planning on allowing mods in your game. Do they only care about how you advertise the product, or will they be looking at how it's actually being used?
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoInteresting point. That's different from typical moddable commercial game/game engine. Typically, people may buy a game in order to play its free mods, but you can't tweak the engine and then sell that modified engine to other game studios. Whatever happens, the end-user has to have a licence for the original game. This is a little different though, as you can modify the engine, then sell your game, and permit payware mods to use your modified version of the engine, perhaps even insisting on taking a cut. All the while the Defold guys don't get a penny.
- mindcrime 6y agoTheir license, as currently stated, would probably violate both planks 1 and 6 of the OSD[1]. [1]: https://opensource.org/osd-annotated https://opensource.org/osd-annotated
- vonmoltke 6y agoIt violates #1. I see no violation of #6.
- mindcrime 6y agoUpon further review, I believe you are correct.
- nybble41 6y ago#1 is freedom to redistribute the original software, alone or in aggregate. I don't see how it violates that. #6 is freedom from discrimination regarding field of endeavour. Restrictions on commercial use (including exercise of the other freedoms in a commercial context, e.g. sale of modified versions) violate #6, not #1.
- mindcrime 6y agoI think that's closer to the way I was reading it at first, but then I realized that #6 refers to use and not distribution. So I think (although, IANAL) that #6 is not about dealing with the commercial sales aspect. I think this is more for the kind of things like "You can use this software for anything except developing military weapons" or that sort of clause that you sometimes see. #1 OTOH deals with "selling or giving away the software as a component of an aggregate software distribution containing programs from several different sources." This would seem to be the clause that would be violated by a "you can't sell this commercially" clause. Although, looking at it, I just realized that somebody could argue that due to the use of the phrase "component of an aggregate software distribution", that this actually isn't violated by a restriction on selling the software alone! I'm pretty sure that's not the way that was ever intended to be interpreted though, and that an aggregate can include as few as 1 components. Otherwise it would be silly, because you could always then in turn create an "aggregate" by adding some arbitrary files of your own.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gardaani 6y agoI found an article about writing games in Defold and Godot. It's a bit old (it was written a year ago). https://agameamonth.net/defold-vs-godot-my-experiences/ https://agameamonth.net/defold-vs-godot-my-experiences/
- taneq 6y agoThanks, that's exactly what I was hoping for!
- goodgoblin 6y agoFWIW - I started a game on Defold and ended up rewriting and porting it to Unity. It's been a while since I used it - about a year - but Unity just has a lot more bells and whistles. Defold uses message passing, which initially I was very excited about, but it turns out my brain is used to thinking about objects and references and I kind of struggled to do simple things in Defold which is part of the reason I switched to Unity. One thing that did make it over in the port is a cool actor-based AI that I probably wouldn't have thought to use if I started the game in Unity. Defold does give you a ton of control though and it would enable more customization than Unity, especially now that it is open source. I should also say the Defold community is great and the devs behind the game engine are very helpful. And this is my first game so any difficulties with Defold could be due to my initial learning curve.
- keyle 6y agoI would go Godot for 2D and Unreal for 3D. My 2c as a game dev.
- Arech 6y agoCould you please be more elaborate about Godot vs. Defold? I've just actually started to do something with Godot and I'd be very grateful to find out the differences between these two engines.
- keyle 6y agoGodot is far more polished and complete I found. Defold wasn't quite there yet. This was approx 6 months ago. Godot was a pleasure to use, I didn't feel the need to revisit Defold.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoNeither Defold, nor Unreal Engine, nor Unity, is Open Source. As discussed elsewhere in this thread, source-available is not the same thing as Open Source. edit Not sure why I'm being downvoted here. This really isn't up for debate. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23233336 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23233336 , https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235217 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23235217
- tgb 6y agoFYI, you were presumably downvoted since the post you replied to had not claimed that Defold, Unreal, or Unity were Open Source. It claimed that Godot was open source, which is true.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoThanks, I'd misread it :-P
- thecureforzits 6y agoBut it says right there, "free and open"!