3 ms·
This is one of those posts I wish I could downvote 1000 times. It's the brogrammer equivalent of fake news: 22-yo kid "makes science" with a sample of 1, some v
by toyg 7y ago
This is one of those posts I wish I could downvote 1000 times. It's the brogrammer equivalent of fake news: 22-yo kid "makes science" with a sample of 1, some videogames, and a few charts.
You are 22 year old. Your body is at peak condition, built to go out and hunt for days on little food and little sleep. Of course it will work more or less fine for a few weeks.
- leonroy 7y agoI think you're doing a disservice to the author's pretty in-depth self-study. The author even states at the beginning of their article: > I believe that this experiment provides strong evidence that I experienced no major cognitive impairment (emphasis mine) > I’m wary of generalizing my results to other people and welcome independent replications of this experiment.
- guzey 7y agoI'm the author of this study. >It's the brogrammer equivalent of fake news: 22-yo kid "makes science" with a sample of 1, some videogames, and a few charts. >You are 22 year old. Your body is at peak condition, built to go out and hunt for days on little food and little sleep. Of course it will work more or less fine for a few weeks. I like this comment because its author can't decide whether my study is the "equivalent of fake news" or whether its results are obviously true.
- toyg 7y agoYou are clearly unfamiliar with the process of mass-producing fake news. It typically takes “common sense” and proceeds to mislead it through bad paths. Which is exactly what you do with this “study”: you over-analyze a situation that is relatively obvious, with a sample of 1, and simply by doing so you effectively suggest to generalize its results - which is wrong. You dropping a caveat mid-page in a single sentence is also the same thing tabloids do: make a big title about something, then state the opposite somewhere in the actual small-print article.
- guzey 7y agoIf I had the opportunity, I would not only downvote you a 1000 times, I would outright ban you from Hacker News. Your comments are uncharitable, careless, and abrasive. >you over-analyze a situation that is relatively obvious, with a sample of 1, and simply by doing so you effectively suggest to generalize its results - which is wrong. >You dropping a caveat mid-page in a single sentence is also the same thing scummy tabloids do: make a big title about something, then state the opposite somewhere in the actual small-print article. The title of my study is: >The Effects on Cognition of Sleeping 4 Hours per Night for 12-14 Days: a Pre-Registered Self-Experiment Which clearly tells the reader that this is a n=1 study. I'm not just dropping a caveat mid-page. If you somehow missed this, it's your problem, not mine.
- cthor 7y agoAll the limitations you mention are already explicit in the text. You have any other studies demonstrating lack of cognitive decline in 22 year olds on 4 hours sleep? Otherwise, you're just poo pooing on someone having actually having done the damn experiment. Yeah, n=1, but it's better than your n=0.
- toyg 7y agoThere are plenty of studies on sleep, all with larger samples and more rigorous approaches.
- guzey 7y agoCan you link to some pre-registered studies of impact of sleep deprivation on cognitive performance?
- pashamur 7y agoFrom two seconds of Googling: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780444537027000075 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B978044453... https://academic.oup.com/sleep/article/19/4/318/2749842 https://academic.oup.com/sleep/article/19/4/318/2749842 https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2008-02717-005 https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2008-02717-005
- guzey 7y agoI asked: >Can you link to some pre-registered studies of impact of sleep deprivation on cognitive performance? None of the studies you linked are pre-registered.
- globular-toast 7y agoIt's not meant to be science. It's a geek experimenting with his body. Hacking your sleeping patterns is a classic that all geeks do at some point in their journey.
- toyg 7y agoI suspect the author would disagree with your assessment, seeing how precisely he laid out the entire piece to appear as science.