2 ms·
I don’t think there is a conflation before your own comment. There is no reason to discuss legal obligations because that part is covered by licenses. The enti
by dgellow 7y ago
I don’t think there is a conflation before your own comment. There is no reason to discuss legal obligations because that part is covered by licenses.
The entire discussion is at the level of social expectations.
- saagarjha 7y ago> There is no reason to discuss legal obligations because that part is covered by licenses. Correct, I think we agree on that. > The entire discussion is at the level of social expectations. No, this statement: > No, there is no obligation. But there’s a thing called courtesy. Is actually “No, there is no legal obligation. But there’s a thing called courtesy.“ And here the contradiction falls away and the discussion turns to whether there is a social expectation to be courteous. On that point my (and the above commenter, I suspect) would say that yes, of course there is an expectation of social courtesy. There’s one in every other setting too, so why not here?
- franciscop 7y agoYou are not "gingerlime" who said that, I understand the original as "moral/social obligation" and not "legal obligation" but you seem to be putting the word "legal" on the users' mouth by saying what they "actually" mean? As a Spaniard living in Japan, what social rules should I use to apply my social courtesy on Github?
- gingerlime 6y agoI am gingerlime. I simply meant obligation as MUST and social norms / courtesy as SHOULD. So I guess technically you’re correct that it’s not a legal obligation, but I think the GP’s point is valid.