3 ms·
Can you back up your assertion for not acting with legislation in response to a tragedy? In pretty much any other aspect of life, from business to personal, pe
by epistasis 7y ago
Can you back up your assertion for not acting with legislation in response to a tragedy?
In pretty much any other aspect of life, from business to personal, people will react then.
Especially since this isn't a one-time tragedy, but one that plays out continually. We need to act now before we let this happen again. I'm going to need to see a citation on your numbers, but 40 since 1980 is once a year! By your criteria of not responding after a tragedy, you are actually arguing that we should never act at all.
- Damorian 7y agoMy brief googling lead me to Wikipedia, which sources most of its statistics from the new York times, but I also read some stuff from the ACLU and other left-leaning news orgs. There's very little good data out there is my biggest takeaway. Which brings me to my point, the reactions are emotional, not logical. If we're creating policy based on feelings that aren't backed by data or actually run counter to data, that's bad policy. Many areas do regular no-knock raid and many areas have banned them entirely. I expect organizations with strong opinions on this subject can investigate the effects and do better than the New York Times throwing 80 links to local news websites into a csv file on GitHub and then linking to it like it's an actual source.
- epistasis 7y agoMy main question is why we should not react speedily. The desire to not act speedily seems be a desire that is an emotional one, not a logical one. There is a clear logical need to act quickly to prevent future abuses of power.
- Damorian 7y agoOh, sorry, I assumed everybody agreed that a carefully planned and measured approach based on facts was better than acting as quickly as possible with only vague ideas of reality. Especially given the context of a few cops and a judge going off incomplete and incorrect data, barging into a house haphazardly and shooting someone to death.