4 ms·
"In no case does copyright protection for an original work of authorship extend to any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle
by michaelmrose 6y ago
"In no case does copyright protection for an original work of authorship extend to any idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation, concept, principle, or discovery, regardless of the form in which it is described, explained, illustrated, or embodied in such work."
This seems relatively straightforward and while I understand the law is properly understood by understanding a large body of law and legal opinions on the interactions of same I see no particular reason to disbelieve it.
In particular nobody is obliged to accept an obviously absurd interpretation of the law because it would seem to follow from an exact reading of the law. It's not math nor a computer program interpreted in the minds of judges. Case in point the above argument on the "schematics" of a book.
This doesn't work because judges aren't robots and would laugh it out of a court room. The same way we should laugh new innovative interpretations of copyright out of the world stage.
Lets ask a deeper question. Why WOULD it be a good thing if copyright applied to machines? Copyright for all intents and purposes will probably never be allowed to lapse in reality. As it stands the people that end up owning everything else would end up being the people that own the ability to move forward under each and eventually every industry ad infinitum as they bought up basic rights in a given industry not for a finite amount of time but forever.
In short we are already in what must be nearly the most ridiculous time line possible. Lets not make it worse.
- legulere 6y ago> procedure, process, system, method of operation That very much sounds like code, which is indeed copyrightable.
- michaelmrose 6y agoBecause large amounts of money ride on reaching the questionable conclusion in question. In any case courts have consistently been finding code to be copyrightable and machines not.
- taneq 6y agoWell, the procedure, processes, systems etc. aren't copyrighted. That's what software patents are trying to lock down. The original source code (which is the document / 'artwork'), however, is. I can see a case for the object code not being copyrightable, though, since it fits the above description. I think there's a clause in the copyright laws about 'mechanically derived' things being covered by the same copyright as the original (so, say, a print of a book is covered by the original manuscript's copyright) and that object code fits under this.