7 ms·
I think one reason retail and a lot of other businesses in the real world will be killed by Covid is low interest rates. These have fueled several decades of ri
by phkahler 7y ago
I think one reason retail and a lot of other businesses in the real world will be killed by Covid is low interest rates. These have fueled several decades of rising real estate prices and rents. Cue a pandemic where they have to close for a while but still have to service debt or rent and they're done.
They've been cutting rates to stimulate the economy, but that's not sustainable and has led to fragility. We need rates in the 5 to 7 percent range IMHO to prevent this type of thing. In that range, banks may also make loans they can hang on to rather than securities, and people may actually save a bit and have that buffer.
- User23 7y agoThe natural rate of interest is zero[1]. Anything else causes economic distortion and misallocation. [1] http://www.moslereconomics.com/wp-content/graphs/2009/07/natural-rate-is-zero.PDF http://www.moslereconomics.com/wp-content/graphs/2009/07/nat...
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe author of that also thinks the natural speed limit is 30 miles per hour, so take the assertion with a grain of salt. http://moslereconomics.com/2008/05/22/energy-crisis-solution/ http://moslereconomics.com/2008/05/22/energy-crisis-solution... (The claim about interest rates is a bit more complicated than "set it at zero", too. The full claim from the linked article is "the natural, nominal, risk free rate of interest is zero". Most uses of interest in our economy aren't risk free.)
- mrfusion 7y agoI thought the optimum speed was 45 or 50?
- whatshisface 7y agoThe optimum speed can't be higher than 6mph, any faster and I'd ask you to leave my living room.
- thatcat 7y ago~55 mph is the speed where aerodynamic drag starts to exceed mechanical friction, becoming the primary negative force and it exponentially increases at higher speeds.
- newacct583 7y agoDrag increases quadratically with speed.
- mrfusion 7y agoGoing too slow hurts mileage too right? I’m not sure how exactly.
- TylerE 7y agoNo. There is no speed* such that going slower will decrease mileage. * Unless we're talking about some sort of pathological edge case in a vehicle without a properly specced transmission or something, or driving an automatic so slow it's just idling against the torque converter or something.
- mrfusion 7y agoI guess for modern vehicles though you want to be in top gear. Otherwise it’s more revolutions of the engine for a given distance. So the minimum speed to get into top gear.
- mrfusion 7y agoEven it’s truly risk free, why would someone lend money for free?
- JackFr 7y agoIf you can print it, why would you borrow for more than 0?
- zzzzzzzza 7y agoaccording to henry george, the natural rate of interest is equal to the lowest productivity plot of available land. Which I think is an interesting perspective.
- clairity 7y agothe cascade to zero percent is this crazy farce of excessively consolidated capital not knowing what to do with itself. it's the antithesis of efficient allocation. bankers create products for timid capital to pool in safe harbors. risk arbiters, like moody's, have been pressured into rating that risk down. then interest rates drop "rationally" because risk is "lower". except it's not lower and interest rates should rather never dropped at all. we can't arbitrarily raise interest rates until we fix the systemic tilt of the economic system toward the wealthy who are increasingly risk averse because they can afford to be that way and still earn excess returns.
- jseliger 7y agoReal estate and rent prices rise in most American cities because cities restrict supply in the face of rising demand: https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2016/09/30/the-verdict-is-in-land-use-regulations-increase-housing-costs/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2016/09/30/the-verdi.... Interest rates are a sideshow. We can fix this, just like Japan did, anytime we want to, by removing impediments to supply increases. https://www.wsj.com/articles/what-housing-crisis-in-japan-home-prices-stay-flat-11554210002 https://www.wsj.com/articles/what-housing-crisis-in-japan-ho...
- maxsilver 7y ago> cities restrict supply in the face of rising demand This isn't really a meaningful statement about the problem. Real estate and rent prices dramatically rose in the US, even in the cities where supply far outstripped demand, and even in cities that lost population this past decade. While supply and demand are slightly an issue in a few specific metros (like San Francisco), US real estate in most metros is mostly a problem fueled by low interest rates and a ridiculous over-inflation in urban property values, as mentioned above.
- jseliger 7y ago"Real estate and rent prices dramatically rose in the US, even in the cities where supply far outstripped demand" [Citation needed] Prices being set by supply and demand can be seen in Smith, Adam. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776). More on our current predicament can be found here: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/the-rent-really-is-too-damn-high/254718 https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/03/the-ren.... Increase supply and demand will be satiated.
- jonahbenton 7y agoA moment's study of NYC real estate over the last thirty or even 300 years is sufficient to disabuse one of the explanatory power of supply and demand, except in a very broad macro trend sense that ridiculously oversmoothes the actual data. Especially recently, right up to COVID times. There were hundreds of thousands of empty living spaces, even more vacant commercial spaces, and virtually no changes in prices. An important insight is that there are very few markets in the world. Most transactions take place in a context where the players have been playing for a very, very long time, and the game is optimized for the repeat participants. These are mostly cartel games, private contracts among the heavies. Not markets. In particular, real estate in New York is a subsidized game of capital and patience. It has been so since the 1700s. At this late stage there are only benefits and virtually no penalties for holding a property vacant. Property taxes are vanishingly low. Claims of loss from vacancy are used to reduce business taxes. I could go on but you really should do your own research. It astonishes me that people can be so convinced by a model, especially such a facile one, as to disregard actual data. Best wishes to you.
- Aperocky 7y ago> save a bit and have that buffer. This kills the economy. If everyone saves then by definition spend goes down. And spend is what pays everyone, the cycle goes broken and and next year pay decrease. and if you keep saving, it keeps going down, until everybody is on survival mode and nothing else is consumed. A healthy economy is dominated by debt that can be serviced, with a saving that is comparable. The larger them both are, the more healthy the economy. Jacking up the rates to 5-7 percent today will cause the fastest collapse in economic history. It's like communism: Yes there's equality but it means everyone is equal in being dirt poor. You might be able to avoid volatility, but at what cost?
- PakG1 7y ago> A healthy economy is dominated by debt that can be serviced, with a saving that is comparable. Not sure that you and gp are disagreeing. Whereas right now, statistics say that a lot of families don't have any savings. Need to save a bit to have comparable savings.
- clairity 7y ago> "This kills the economy. If everyone saves then by definition spend goes down. And spend is what pays everyone, the cycle goes broken and and next year pay decrease. and if you keep saving, it keeps going down, until everybody is on survival mode and nothing else is consumed." no, it doesn't just break, the economy readjusts. there's a practical lower bound to trade and consumption (we need food, clothes, shelter, energy, water, etc.) and prices for essentials would likely rise relative to non-essentials, as demand shifts around the economy and supply adjusts to match it. labor prices likely dip, as do capital returns, during the transition period. permanent savings would lower monetary throughput, but not necessarily velocity.
- azepoi 7y agoyes the problem is not on the supply side. Drop the rates all you want, it mostly goes to inflate existing assets. If you are to drop billions of newly issued money on asset purchases anyway you better get some in regular people pockets. There was never a better time to experiment with helicopter money and UBI.
- occamrazor 7y agoLow interest rates increase real estate property prices, but at the same time tend to reduce rents. The increase in rent prices is more likely due to an increase in demand for housing in cities, by people who want to move there, which is not balanced by a similar increase in available housing (and on the last point, low interest rates make building new housing more attractive).
- noad 7y agoCutting rates doesn't have much of a stimulating effect on business spending like it used to. Large companies just funnel excess cash or issue debt for more stock buybacks + equity based compensation for the executives. The correlation between rates and increased business spending has been weakening steadily for 20 years because of this.