4 ms·
>The landlord provides a usable piece of land They neither made the land nor made it valuable, so they're not "providing" it in any meaningful sense. They're r
by pydry 7y ago
>The landlord provides a usable piece of land
They neither made the land nor made it valuable, so they're not "providing" it in any meaningful sense. They're relinquishing their state provided entitlement to expel users of the land with state-backed violence. In exchange for resources.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAsk an automaker: did they make the iron? No, it was a supernova 1B years ago.
- pydry 7y agoValuable mining rights should, broadly speaking, follow the same rules as land under georgism. rather than, say, "renting" it from some guy who has land deeds that say "i own this mountain". what turns iron ore into a car is labor, which you should pay the laborer for. that is, unless you think you should have a greater share of mineral rights than somebody else for some reason.
- nybble41 7y agoWould you not say that finding the mineral deposit is worth at least some reward, separate from the labor of mining and processing the ore?