5 ms·
i live in a country with paid parental leave and have heard second-hand stories of employer bias against women in childbearing age precisely because women in ch
by baq 7y ago
i live in a country with paid parental leave and have heard second-hand stories of employer bias against women in childbearing age precisely because women in childbearing age got employed and promptly got pregnant.
for the record i'm for this kind of social assistance because the alternative sounds downright barbaric.
- pasquinelli 7y agoNot surprising that a woman of childbearing age turns up pregnant is it?
- ta1234567890 7y agoYes it happens. But why punish 100% of potential beneficiaries for what maybe 1-5% of them might do. Just include the cost of abuse in the projections and deal with it. That's how every system works. Every system gets abused. One example: credit cards - there's plenty of fraud there, but we somehow manage to deal with it and make the system work regardless.
- mrlala 7y agoExactly.. really hate the attitude of "oh well someone might abuse it so let's just screw everyone instead"
- xyzzyz 7y agoThere is no abuse involved. You employ a young woman, and in a year she gives birth and is out for a year or two. Nothing wrong with that, and many businesses with large employee turnover won’t care, but other businesses, especially small ones, which require significant training for company-specific processes, or which have small pool of candidates, will be very unhappy about the fact that now they have to find and train a temporary replacement.
- learc83 7y agoWe already have a very similar situation with respect to hiring military reservists. It seems like we could use that data to see if there's really a big enough problem to worry about. Anecdotally, I've never met someone in the reserves who had a hard time finding a job.
- xyzzyz 7y agoDo the military reservists have to disclose to potential employers that they are reservists? How often the reservists actually called for service? This is an interesting point, and I'm asking because I have no clue about the realities the military reservists face.
- learc83 7y agoThere's no requirement to disclose during an interview, but most people I know depended on their time in the reserves/active duty pretty heavily on their resume, so I'd guess it was pretty rare for an employer to not know or at least suspect. Also they have have leave to train for 2 weeks per year, so the employer would need to know at some point. As for chances of being deployed, in the last decade it was probably a good bit higher than the chance that a reproductive age woman gets pregnant for a given time period. They can also end up deployed for longer than most countries paid maternity leave lasts.
- bediger4000 7y ago> But why punish 100% of potential beneficiaries for what maybe 1-5% of them might do. Because employers, at least in the USA, believe they have a right to nearly of their employees' time on or off the clock, and a right to exert some control over their employees' personal lives and even political choices. Enjoyment of this control is part of why people become employers or managers.
- mapgrep 7y agoA great example of why not just maternity leave (per the link) but parental leave broadly is a good idea. And why both parents need to take it. Otherwise it will be used by some as an excuse to discriminate against birth parents. Of course there are many other benefits to both parents taking leave, including that studies have shown that non birth parents who take leave tend to be more involved in parenting long term. Also, it’s hugely rewarding emotionally!
- throwaway894345 7y ago> And why both parents need to take it I think this is key to addressing discrimination (simply making discrimination illegal is insufficient because discrimination is so difficult to prove); however, getting both genders to take it in roughly equal proportion is probably nearly as difficult, at least apart from mandatory leave, which would be authoritarian and awful. EDIT: Genuinely curious: why the downvotes? Do people not believe that taking leave in equal proportions is necessary to combat discrimination? Or do they think that it is easy to make people do this ethically? Surely no one thinks we should force people to take leave against their will?
- barry-cotter 7y agoYou don’t support forcing men to take paternity leave. Many people do. That’s why you’re being downvoted.
- gknoy 7y agoPeople support _forcing_ parents to take {ma,pa}ternity leave? I am skeptical, as this is a position I have never ever heard of before. As a parent, I can see why one could advocate for equal (+generous) paid parental leave (disclaimer: I support that idea), but I've never heard (nor would I understand) the idea that one should be forced to _take_ such leave.
- barry-cotter 7y agoIf you’ve just given birth do you want women like Sheryl Sandberg to be allowed, who take three days or a week off and then are back at the office? Or do you want everyone to compete on a more level playing field, where everyone must take three months off? Because those for whom family comes second to work will get promoted faster anyway but if you let them work even more the advantages just compound. For an example of the Harrison Bergeron attitude see https://twitter.com/hoovergreen/status/1258070856745529344?s=21 https://twitter.com/hoovergreen/status/1258070856745529344?s... https://twitter.com/r_rusha/status/1258496895824957440?s=21 https://twitter.com/r_rusha/status/1258496895824957440?s=21 https://twitter.com/extendedhuckel/status/1258065461951918080?s=21 https://twitter.com/extendedhuckel/status/125806546195191808... https://twitter.com/kmpjones/status/1258214473757794305?s=21 https://twitter.com/kmpjones/status/1258214473757794305?s=21
- klipt 7y agoWhich is why maternity leave without similar paternity leave is a bad idea. But apparently whoever wrote this article didn't think things through that far.
- throwaway894345 7y agoI'm all for paid paternity leave, but I've also heard that it does relatively little because men are much less likely to use it, and when they use it they use less of it.
- klipt 7y agoSome countries have had good results from making it mandatory.
- foogazi 7y agoAre there countries that force people to take leave with their children?
- manfredo 7y agoI am not aware of any country that has mandatory paternity leave. Do you have an example of this?
- CJefferson 7y agoI wonder if the grandparent meant "non-transferable" -- some countrirs have a shared pot (and then women often take all the pot), other countries enforce some amount of the pot to each parent. You do not have to take it as the man, but you lose it if you don't.
- jayd16 7y agoA useful equalizer is to give paternal leave as well.
- foogazi 7y agoWhat is the barbaric alternative?
- syshum 7y agoPersonal Responsibility... That is barbaric these days