4 ms·
I've quite often seen people claim Russia and/or China had full copies of the Snowden documents, and try to use that to accuse him of being a foreign agent. It'
by boomboomsubban 7y ago
I've quite often seen people claim Russia and/or China had full copies of the Snowden documents, and try to use that to accuse him of being a foreign agent. It's interesting to see a high ranking NSA employee say the journalist were likely the unwitting source.
- mindslight 7y agoIf you're referring to this: > "My take is, whatever you guys had was pretty immediately in the hands of any foreign intelligence service that wanted it," he said, "whether it was Russians, Chinese, French, the Israelis, the Brits. Between you, Poitras, and Greenwald, pretty sure you guys can’t stand up to a full-fledged nation-state attempt to exploit your IT. To include not just remote stuff, but hands-on, sneak-into-your-house-at-night kind of stuff. That’s my guess." It's unsubstantiated chest thumping. "You're acting irresponsibly because you're vulnerable without our protection, which you don't have because you went against us". It completely brushes aside the idea that if these agencies weren't acting as domestic enemies in the first place, whistleblowers and journalists wouldn't be adversaries.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago> It completely brushes aside the idea that if these agencies weren't acting as domestic enemies in the first place, whistleblowers and journalists wouldn't be adversaries Even if the NSA wasn't treating them like domestic enemies, all of those other countries would likely want their own copy of the complete leak. And the rest of the article shows other agencies arw probably capable of such acts.
- mindslight 7y agoThe motive is there, but the evidence is not. For all we know, the mysterious device behavior could have been the NSA itself, if only trying to delete any files that were on insecure devices. It obviously could be foreign actors too, but there is nothing in the empty NSA statement to inform that possibility. The best way to view such a statement is simple misdirection / public relations.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoI'm unsure of what mysterious device behavior you are talking about, and I don't see the point of running such a misdirection years after the fact accomplishes. My only point was that even the Chinese/Russian copy some people claim exist still wouldn't mean Snowden gave it to them.
- ACS_Solver 7y agoIt makes complete sense if other countries got the files from the journalists. Snowden deleted everything before the first articles were published, and he's also a more difficult target than the journalists. The journalists that were initially in contact with Snowden are neither intelligence nor technology experts, and they had never even used PGP email. They had to get an infosec crash course from Snowden, so their systems could probably be breached with relative comfort by intelligence agencies like Russia's or China's.