9 ms·
Negative News Distorts Our Thinking
- elektor 7y agoI subscribe to a handful of positive newsletters to help counteract the barrage of daily negative news. Some of my recommendations: 1) The Guardian's Upside https://www.theguardian.com/world/series/the-upside-weekly-report https://www.theguardian.com/world/series/the-upside-weekly-r... 2) Future Crunch https://futurecrunch.substack.com/ https://futurecrunch.substack.com/ 3) Positive News https://www.positive.news/ https://www.positive.news/ 4) The Good Newsletter https://www.goodgoodgood.co/goodnewsletter https://www.goodgoodgood.co/goodnewsletter
- freehunter 7y agoPutting this front and center: the constant outpouring of negative news has and is having a negative impact on my worldview and my mental health. Most of this is due to "news", which is not the same as news. Headlines no one needs to hear about but are only printed because 24 hour media needs a constant flow of content. A big problem I've had in seeking explicitly "positive" news is a lot of it is actually negative "news" just spun in a positive light. Articles like "5 year old cancer patient has successful GoFundMe to pay for chemo". That's not positive (nor is it news), it's just highlighting the societal problem that unexpected medical costs in America can bankrupt entire families unless their case is sympathetic enough to get random people to pay the cost. The other kind of positive news I see often is things that sound great but aren't actually real. Like "New breakthrough battery technology means batteries last for 1000 years" but there's never a follow-up (I guess it would be negative news then) that this "breakthrough" only exists in the lab and can't actually be turned into real batteries. After spending a few months going out of my way to read explicitly positive news, I find it worse than ever. Because a lot of explicitly positive news isn't actually news, and a lot of it isn't actually positive either. Edit - I guess this was just a bummer with no positive, and I apologize for that. What I've ended up doing right now is limiting where I get my news from and dramatically slowing down my news consumption. The reason we commonly think the 70s/80s/90s had such better music than today is because we've already let time filter out the bad music so we only remember the good stuff. I treat news the same, if it's something I need to know I will still hear about it tomorrow or the next day. Seeing "news" happen in real time with BREAKING NEWS slathered across the page makes it seem more important than it actually is. Seeing it as a footnote a few days later often doesn't change the store but changes your perception of that story. And it also filters out the unimportant things that aren't worth talking about because they're not going to be talked about tomorrow or the day after. The news app TheSkimm has actually been helpful, it's not explicitly positive news but it's important news slowed down and explained properly, while everything else is just a headline or not even mentioned at all. Finding a slower news source would be my recommendation rather than filtering yourself to explicitly positive news.
- clairity 7y agomaybe this is the secret reason behind the sucess of cat (and dog and any other animal, really) videos--to escape the not-really-positive news for something unequivocally happy and cute and positive.
- freehunter 7y agoI've found I much prefer my downtime be filled with silly nonsense like cats/dogs or videos of people who are incredibly good at something rather than "news" that's actually just outrage in a can.
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoThe idea of scheduled dissemination for entertainment is going out of fashion with all the streaming options available. This works well because you pay the streamer directly and advertisers aren't part of that. I like this, because the service has to answer to me as a consumer directly. I somewhat think that the idea of scheduled dissemination for news and world events needs should go out of fashion in a similar way, as it would be less "corrupted", but don't think it will for a long time at the very least. The idea of news is not purely about information delivery to most people. People really want opinions about news far less than raw reporting of events. Also people find comfort, meaning, and connection in the ritual of scheduled content. For that emotional need to be fulfilled, they seek content aligned with their social and economic bubbles. It's silly, and as a result I keep my consumption of news to an absolute minimum.
- freehunter 7y agoOn the topic of on-demand streaming news, I used to listen to a couple of daily news podcasts. With my new mindset around news consumption, I'm listening to weekly or bi-weekly podcasts instead (and oftentimes not listening to them the day they were released). Even still it's amazing the amount of news content they cover that (if you listen to it the day after it was released) is already "out of date". Things like "Amazon is expected to announce plans to buy AMC theaters" on Thursday and when I listen to it on Friday it's already been announced. Now if only I could just filter HN to only show me tech stories instead of "news".
- nikodunk 7y agoSubscribed to all your suggestions above. I’ve also recently found https://reasonstobecheerful.world https://reasonstobecheerful.world - also excellent and updated regularly.
- growlist 7y agoI'd be extremely careful about trusting anything written in the Grauniad.
- thomk 7y agoConversely, happiness appears to raise IQ: https://www.bbc.com/news/health-19659985 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-19659985
- thesz 7y agoI guess it is a case of self-fulfilling prediction. It is an article about negative things and how they are negative for us. And it distorts our thinking, at the very least, it tried to distort mine's by imprinting "the fact" that negative news distorts our thinking.
- aabeshou 7y agoLook, I am all for self-care and not overexposing yourself to terrible news all day every day. But to act like negative news is making us think the world is worse than it is is just sheltered. The reality is the world has a lot of terrible things happening all day every day and humanity is basically not doing anything to stop it as of now. Here are a few: (1) in the US, a lot of people don't get enough healthcare because they can't afford it, and just go bankrupt when they get cancer (2) black people are still terrorized and murdered by police, who largely get off scot-free (3) the US and its business partners perpetrate crimes against humanity in the middle east on a regular basis (4) the daily gruesome reality of poverty in the US (5) We continue our slow but sure march towards climate apocalypse which will largely affect the most vulnerable among us. This idea that "the standard of living" is higher... well sure, if you have a certain amount of money. But many people don't get healthcare, don't have any leisure time, don't have money to travel. And yeah, there's peace here, but what about in Yemen? What about in Honduras? Iraq? Afghanistan? So what, because we have iPhones we're supposed to think everything's amazing?
- makerofspoons 7y agoWorse yet, what many consider a standard of living increase such as air travel, cheap energy, and an abundance of material goods shipped from all over the planet are actually contributing to the climate crisis.
- Zooper 7y agoI was thinking that this article showed signs of distorted "optimistic" thinking.
- aabeshou 7y agoI hate to use the word "privileged" because it is so loaded but I do think that this shows privileged thinking. "The world is great!" yeah because you have enough money/power to go about your life comfortably, and you're ignoring the plight of those that don't. "You only think the world is bad because of these cognitive biases".... lord take me now
- 7y ago
- slothtrop 7y agoThe issue I have with my relationship to the news is less so the negative slant in and of itself, moreso never being disconnected from it. Most of it is banal or fluff. You can keep track infrequently and be a well informed voter. I follow tech news aggregators more but could use less of that as well. There's just too much time spent on mindless bullshit.
- brokenmachine 7y agoWhat gets me about it is that it's always stories that I can't do anything about. Like, sure, someone got stabbed. That's terrible for them and their family, but I didn't stab them and I don't know the victim, so in what way does being informed of this enrich my life? I was already aware that people got stabbed sometimes. Can I have that five minutes back please? So I don't watch the "news" anymore.
- nzealand 7y agoThere is so much more to happiness than negative news. A friend escaped Bosnia during the war. She chose to live in New Zealand, because the top news story of the day was about a cat that was lost. She figured if that was all New Zealand had to worry about, then New Zealand was the country for her. She found gainful employment, raised a kid, and she went to the beach every weekend during the summer. She hated it. She is back in Europe now.