7 ms·
Criticism of paper-and-fax coronavirus infection reports spark change in Japan
- AznHisoka 7y agoJapan has also relied on traditions like using a seal called a hanko to sign contracts. https://www.nippon.com/en/news/fnn2020042836711/ https://www.nippon.com/en/news/fnn2020042836711/ Covid is forcing many of these companies to transition to electronic signatures like Docusign.
- jacquesm 7y agoWhat could possibly go wrong? Let's all use an online service that is perfectly positioned make it seem like someone signed a document when in fact it is about as valid as a 'card not present' credit card transaction. Electronic signatures should have a lower level of trust than those performed in front of notaries and other officials. There is no way to check for coercion and many other ways in which the signature would normally be invalidated.
- acqq 7y ago> Electronic signatures should have a lower level of trust than those performed in front of notaries and other officials. Exactly. The level of trust of the electronic signatures should be as low as it can be, as computer security is really, really hard, especially outside of military settings: it should only be used to prevent the flood of login attempts and to allow to get or submit some less critical information, not to be legally equivalent to notarized signatures. Unfortunately some administrations swallow the propaganda of the companies selling the electronic signatures and promote them as "solving everything" then they are "surprised" that the citizenship is skeptical. And we know how unreliable "Certificate Authorities" are, and how hard it is even for big and very rich companies to maintain their certificates. It's not that the cryptography behind the signature is the problem: it's everything around that is the problem that needs a lot of care.
- jfoster 7y agoWhat are the ways in which a signature would normally be invalidated? (and how do you check for coercion?)
- luckylion 7y agoYou make the person sit in front of a notary, he confirms their identity and reads them the document they are about to sign (to make sure they know what they sign) and then confirms that they personally and voluntarily signed. Of course, you can only check for immediate coercion. You can make sure nobody has a gun to their head, but you can hardly check that nobody has a gun to their children in the car outside, or their brother that lives on a different continent.
- magicsmoke 7y agoIf you're coerced into signing a contract, you can always breach it later and when sued for breach of contract bring up evidence of coercion. Courts will not enforce contracts signed under coercion. At the end of the day, a contract is just a piece of paper and your signature is just some ink. Contracts only have power if courts enforce them. (At least for private entities. International law and sovereign entities are a whole other ballgame)
- jacquesm 7y agoProving coercion or lack thereof is hard. If it wasn't everybody and their brother would weasel out of contracts unfavorable to them. Well, not everybody, but still, plenty of people would.
- eru 7y agoSignatures by hand are not really about security. It's more a signal to really take a contract serious.
- jacquesm 7y agoThe better ones are done in front of notaries and they check your identity pretty thoroughly before you sign. They also countersign and keep copies. So for anything really important use that.
- eru 7y agoTo an extent. They could just have you stand in front of the notary and swear (after the notary checks your identity), for similar effect and security. The signature is only a small part of the whole procedure. In most routine transactions, it really only shows everyone involved that This Is Serious. As a little experiment, I once looked up the legal ramifications of 'faking' your own signature. Ie signing with a signature that's completely unlike your normal signature. Or changing your signature around every day.
- dependenttypes 7y agoWe have just fine ways to perform electronic signatures. GPG and signify come to mind. It is really weird how companies opt in for clearly inferior technologies.
- luckylion 7y agoThey do neither guarantee that the person in question signed (only that someone performed the signature with their private key, which they may have stolen) nor that coercion wasn't in play.
- dependenttypes 7y agoSure, and both are much better than the existing solutions that have the same issues and more (such as some random party forging a signature in a physical paper, or Docusign lying).
- fiblye 7y agoUse of a hanko implies that you're acting on behalf of the owner of that hanko. If someone signs a paper with your name, you can say someone forged your signature and prove that your writing is different. If someone fraudulently uses your info digitally, you can get them to pull up IP records and other various digital fingerprinting info to prove it's not yours. If your name is stamped, you're kind of boned. It's not an uncommon thing for people in Japan to be divorced without even knowing it. Their spouse secretly grabs their hanko for 5 seconds to do a quick stamp, goes to the city office alone, hands in the divorce form with both names stamped, and it's finalized. There's actually a separate form called a fujuri todoke that you can do in advance to block these one-sided divorces, showing that the whole stamping system is flawed if you need to do separate forms to block potential events of it being used without your knowledge. Nearly anything works better than stamps.
- upofadown 7y agoThen why not just get the notary to sign the transaction after questioning the signer in person? The issue of coercion has nothing to do with the medium used for signing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- flocial 7y agoAs a matter of fact this tradition of hanko is holding back many companies from telecommuting since they rely on getting hanko from the chain of management for critical and frankly some trivial internal decision making.
- mikekchar 7y agoWhile crazy, this shows another example of the ways things change in Japan. Nothing ever changes until one day it changes overnight. April 23rd someone tweets the bleeding obvious. May 17th (apparently), the entire country is using a different system. But for decades before that, there would be absolutely nothing you would have been able to do to incite change. It would have been absolutely impossible. I always find it amazing that change always goes from 0 to 100 in a matter of days.
- JimiofEden 7y agoDo you have other examples of this? I've heard this anecdotally over and over again, but I would be interested in reading actual instances where this is the case
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThe OG example is the Meiji era, when Japan went from a strictly isolationist feudal state to an industrialized and expansionist powerhouse in a few decades. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meiji_(era) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meiji_(era)
- mikekchar 7y agoThe biggest one I've seen with my own eyes is smoking outside in public. When I first came to Japan you would see lots of people smoking while walking, or smoking on outside train platforms. Then one day somebody put up a big billboard all over the place that had a drawing of a person holding a cigarette and a child. It said, "You hold a cigarette at the height of a child's eye" or something to that effect. From that day on, practically everyone stopped smoking and walking. It's really incredibly rare to see it now. It might have been a localised effect around where I lived, but other people I've talked to from around the country remarked on it as well. I've seen other things like it, but this was the most remarkable to me. The government seems to randomly put up signs like that to see if they take hold. It never seems to go gradually -- with early adopters, etc, etc. Either everybody goes with it or nobody does. I'm trying to think of something that is easy to verify, but it's nearly midnight here and I can't think of anything off hand. If I remember I'll try to post back later.
- microcolonel 7y agoGiven the things I've seen exposed to the public internet from Japan, I really don't think it's wise to rush computerizing this system. Even here in Canada, and I'm sure in much of the world, fax is a common tool used by doctors' offices on a daily basis. It has some definite downsides, but at the end of the day when you replace it, you should have to provide an alternative that doesn't compromise workflows, interoperability, or standards. In fax-based systems, anyone who can prepare the paper document can, in principle, participate; because the fax protocol is built on long-expired patents and widely-published standards implemented by many vendors. When it comes to other forms of document filling and transfer, the standards now vary widely; when they say the fax system is outdated, are they imagining the replacement is a straightforward cookie-based html form website backed by a database, or do the want something more "up to date" than that?
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThe article is referring specifically to faxing around handwritten reports of coronavirus deaths and infections. The fax in general will, I'm afraid, still hang around Japan for quite some time. My mother-in-law doesn't have a mobile phone but she does have a fax.
- gspr 7y agoQuestion to the people in fax countries: are your fax machines still connected to a POTS line, or has the word come to mean a glorified "scanner that automatically emails at the push of a button"?
- frosted-flakes 7y agoI believe that in the USA fax is legally considered "secure" and doesn't violate HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) privacy laws, but email does. So yes, I think it's an actual fax machine in those cases.
- microcolonel 7y agoPart of the reasoning behind this is, I think, that there are severe criminal penalties for private persons and organizations snooping on phone lines and exchanges. For similar reasons, USPS is considered secure (there is a high grade federal police service for the postal service, and tampering with mail is a felony).
- brazzy 7y agoGermany's reporting system is also fax based, and while there has now been some talk about it needing to be improved, I'm not aware of any concrete changes or even plans.