10 ms·
Dutch spies helped Britain's GCHQ break Argentine crypto during Falklands War
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- polytely 7y agoLink to the actual source: Maximator: European signals intelligence cooperation, from a Dutch perspective https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02684527.2020.1743538 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02684527.2020.1...
- mike_d 7y agoThe Dutch have an absolutely amazing intelligence apparatus. In 2014 AIVD hacked the office network of Russia's APT29, and maintained access at least through the 2016 DNC hack. The best part was they also had access to the security cameras and were able to watch the attacks in real time.
- the-dude 7y agoAs a Dutch citizen, I am very suspicious about this story. Sounds too good to be true? Probably is not true. The timing was also amazingly convenient.
- pocket_titan 7y agoAs another Dutch citizen, it's a true story! Read about it here: https://amp.nos.nl/artikel/2213762-hackteam-aivd-gaf-fbi-cruciale-info-over-russische-inmenging-verkiezingen.html https://amp.nos.nl/artikel/2213762-hackteam-aivd-gaf-fbi-cru...
- the-dude 7y agoI know it has been reported in the news. Does not make it true.
- ciarannolan 7y agoThey were pretty public with the evidence when it came out (including releasing security camera footage and names of Russian agents). Which parts do you think are false?
- coldtea 7y agoAnd those names can't be faked (or belong to true people but not relevant to what they supposedly did) because? I'd be sceptical of any "revelation" from such agencies...
- ciarannolan 7y agoThere's evidence that it's substantially true (ex. security camera footage and confirmation by most worldwide press outlets). Curious if you have evidence that it's fabricated? Other than your distrust of intelligence agencies in general.
- coldtea 7y ago>Curious if you have evidence that it's fabricated? What happened to the burden of proof? Especially from professional liars like intelligence agencies...
- ciarannolan 7y agoSo, no?
- coldtea 6y agoNo, they don't have any proof just a claim we should take at face value.
- ciarannolan 6y agoAre you being intentionally obtuse?
- BozeWolf 7y agoI advice to read this book then: https://www.bol.com/nl/p/het-is-oorlog-maar-niemand-die-het-ziet/9200000107493354/ https://www.bol.com/nl/p/het-is-oorlog-maar-niemand-die-het-... It was in there. Pretty interesting read as well. Lots of stuff on FoxIT and the guy behind it.
- elliekelly 7y agoIt doesn’t seem an English translation of the book has been released yet. I don’t speak Dutch so apologies if this is a silly question but when you mention FoxIT are you referring to the PDF application?
- codnee 7y agoIt's this FoxIT I imagine: https://www.fox-it.com/en/ https://www.fox-it.com/en/
- elliekelly 7y agoAh, that makes much more sense! Thanks!
- rramadass 7y agoAgree with you. Sounds too good to be True. IMO, Probably somebody had a mole inside GRU who was instrumental in getting the info. but in order to provide cover for its source, they invented a success story of the AIVD.
- brnt 7y agoThere isn't much literature on it (Dutch spying activities), but the little there is might convince you. A fun exercise is applying with the AIVD or NFI (involved in spying on home soil). You may meet someone who can tell you some good war stories. Of course, you'll be bound not to speak of it outside company walls ;)
- codr7 7y agoEven more amazing considering that there was no hack, it was an internal leak named Seth Rich [0]. I know, false news, end of discussion. Very convenient label to slap on any information that threatens to rock the boat. What never ceases to amaze me is how otherwise seemingly intelligent people blindly believe what they're told without asking questions as soon as the potential answers get uncomfortable. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Seth_Rich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Seth_Rich
- possiblelion 7y agoSo you're trying to tell us that Russian APT teams could not have hacked into DNC servers because there might have been an internal leak instead? Why not both? Why would Dutch intelligence care about supporting a random political faction in the United States?
- codr7 7y agoNot at all, but judging from the amount of effort put into starting a war with Russia around the same time I find it more likely that the whole thing was made up. US intelligence, Dutch intelligence, UK intelligence, German intelligence, who cares? They're all in the same boat, and it's sinking fast.
- celticninja 7y agodoesn't that put Russian intelligence in the same boat too, if those mentioned could be involved in disinformation then so could russia
- tzarvlad 7y agoReality check: The Russian economy completely depends on gas and middle class salary is 200 euro (said Putin). So who is sinking here? At the same time they colonized Crimea, fought a war with Georgia. Who is starting wars here? You might not like intelligence work, but that's another story.
- 7y ago
- krona 7y agoThey can't be that good if you happen to know this and be writing about it on the internet.
- ashtonkem 7y agoOr this is the least of their exploits, and releasing this info is a psyops thing.
- bergstromm466 7y agoI love how this is downvoted, even though it's lilely a commonly used strategy in many Western power's playbook. Did nobody read Snowden's book?
- ArnoVW 7y agoIn general, in the spyworld you do not talk about your tricks. But if you've already been found out, and your tricks no longer work, there is still political advantage to be had (damage your adversary, obtain credit from partners, obtain funding, easier recrutement). https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/01/dutch-intelligence-hacked-video-cameras-in-office-of-russians-who-hacked-dnc/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/01/dutch...
- coldtea 7y agoOr if you just want to claim it to damage your adversary, whether they have the unit you supposedly hacked and it does what you say it does, or not...
- ciarannolan 7y agoCovert access for over two years to every part of the GRU's election meddling apparatus is very impressive, actually. Once you're caught, too, there's sometimes value in sort of showing it off and embarrassing your adversary.
- jeroenhd 7y agoFrom what I've read, things started going wrong when an (ex?) official of the US released information the Dutch shared with their American allies[1]. Details on when or why access to the Russian networks was lost aren't readily available (secret service and all that) but I do remember reading about the intelligence agencies being not particularly pleased with the way the information was publicly released by their allies. It makes sense that someone gloating about how there's an ally of theirs in your network will make you take a second look at the traffic flowing through your network if you're waging cyber warfare. [1]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/new-details-emerge-about-2014-russian-hack-of-the-state-department-it-was-hand-to-hand-combat/2017/04/03/d89168e0-124c-11e7-833c-503e1f6394c9_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/new-d...
- 0xy 7y agoI know it's probably unintentional considering the false news reports at the time, but the 2016 DNC hack was actually never conclusively pinned on Russia. In fact, according to a recent release the entire basis for the US intelligence appartus' opinion was totally unproven. CrowdStrike never conclusively proved Russia was behind the hack, and in fact didn't even conclusively prove a hack even occurred. https://www.itwire.com/security/crowdstrike-chief-admits-no-proof-that-russia-exfiltrated-dnc-emails.html https://www.itwire.com/security/crowdstrike-chief-admits-no-...
- tzarvlad 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reality_Winner
- blaser-waffle 7y ago4 month old account with like no karma thinks the Russians didn't do it.
- mrmonkeyman 7y agoDutch. It's not amazing, it's OK. The rest of the world is just lagging behind.
- coldtea 7y agoOr they advertise that they have. Including making up claims for specific foreign countries people have no way of substantiating...
- 1MachineElf 7y agoI'm skeptical of that story. I know a Russian on Facebook who disputed it. He said that the Red Square building described in the report doesn't exist, and provided a Google Maps view of Moscow to support his claim. It's also curious to me why the Dutch even would allow APT29 to get away with their activities at the time, if they truly had access as deep as they claimed.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoArgentina did not have air refueling nor night vision equipment. They sent conscripts to fight gurkhas. Their exocet missiles where sabotaged by the military contractors servicing them. Their neighbors monitored them via radar and notified movements the British. Many countries were helping with intelligence. Norway helped by stealing Soviet satellite imagery. And by attacking first they could not invoke the Rio Pact.
- abstractbeliefs 7y agoYou're not wrong, but you're somewhat off. Argentina did have an air to air refuelling capability, and its availability or not was crucial in a number of instances. Likewise, the Gurkhas went out at battalion strength near the end of the war. The exocets weren't so much sabotaged as much as all the French simply returning home leaving the kit unfitted and unconfigured. The stuff that had been set up already was used to great effect. You're right though that they did not set themselves up for success when they did not make the most of their first mover advantage and build up the island with supplies, equipment, and well trained soldiers rather than conscripts. At the time, they hoped that domestic events meant that the UK simply wouldn't care is all. They didn't come for a fight.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIndeed, I think they just assumed that the UK hadn't the strength nor the will to start a war on the other side of the world just to fight over a barren island. Ironically, if they had not attacked the Falklands might be Argentinian or under joint sovereignty now because, indeed, no-one really cared about the Falklands. But their actions ended up guaranteeing that the UK would never even discuss the issue for at least a century...
- raphar 7y agoThe argentinian public didn't care much about Malvinas before 1982 (as we call the falklands here). Was a desperate last move from the Military Junta to get some approval. The Argentinian attack worked fine for M. Thatcher popularity, but not so good for them.
- fit2rule 7y agoAs a citizen, I am not okay with this degree of intra-sovereign surveillance. If I am to live in, pay taxes, and otherwise contribute to a society, I want to be free of surveillance and subterfuge within that society - my states laws, designed to protect me from thugs and mafia (a very real threat), should not be thwarted by military industrial mafia hell-bent on exerting control over sovereign states, in spite of my desires as a citizen. The trouble is, I see no way forward for citizens of the 5-eyes states to address this issue, other than either a) revolution to uncover and dissolve the control networks that have been covertly put in place, or b) sedition - leaving the state, and not contributing (taxes) to its continued economic development. As we have seen with Wikileaks and Julian Assange, its not enough to just reveal the covert secrets that underpin this inner state-within-a-state - there have to be actual repercussions for those involved, and this isn't happening at any rate near well enough for my needs. So, it appears that sedition is the only option - and indeed, that is what I have done: I no longer participate in the economies of any of the 5-eyes states, directly, and I"m about to give up my citizenship in my birth nation over the issue. But we know this isn't a solution. Do we have to start a brain-drain revolution which moves the economic power of an intelligent class from state to state? Or, do we just let mother nature do its thing, and 'hope' that things will 'change' in the 5-eyes super-state somehow? Too many people I trust and respect in the crypto-anarchist sphere are responding to this appeal with "well, covid-19 will sort it out" for my liking .. but what other options are there, really? Journalism is utterly dead and decrepit in the West, this is not an avenue. Violent revolution makes no sense whatsoever. So, brain-drain it is ...
- stunt 7y agoWe tend to like surveillance as long as it's in our favor and interest. Aren't we? But the moment you hear some surveillance or espionage from another country, then it's time to bash them hard and feel bad about them. But, I'm afraid we don't have a choice because we are living in a zero-sum game. And the irony is that the more we play non-cooperative, the more reasons we give to each other to play non-cooperative.
- fit2rule 7y agoI don't believe anybody's surveillance is good. This is the opposite of free and open society, and is a creeping tyranny. I discourage any such devotion in my peers - its all too easy to just submit to the overwhelming might of the wests' military industrial complex. I guess the best thing to do is to continue to fight covert manipulation at all costs, using any means necessary beyond violence. This seems to not be so much of a zero-sum game as capitulation.
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoI for one am relieved that after the Bitcoin bubble the "crypto" in headings means cryptography again.
- anon234345566 7y ago"a) revolution to uncover and dissolve the control networks that have been covertly put in place, or b) sedition - leaving the state, and not contributing (taxes) to its continued economic development." Many have enough power to leverage a) or b), but very few choose to do so. Why? Because if you somehow manage to disolve the current status quo, you'd need to rebuild a similar status quo, probably with your group deeply plugged into the newest surveillance / society control system. > ultimatelly you would probably have accomplished very few changes, though you could obtain more power / money, but If you're capable / resourceful enough to make happen a) or b), you probably already have lots of power / money. Therefore, the current status quo works quite well for you, and there are easier ways to change some things (not all of them though), than going right to a revolution. That's something you can see in most empires through history: very few were intentionally brough down by internal players. Most players just wanted to get in charge (by any means), but they were not fundamentally changing anything in the current social order. Going against the state was (and it is), almost certainly not the best path of action.
- eternauta3k 7y agoWould it have been possible for Argentina to use public encryption algorithms back then, instead of crypto machines weakened by US intelligence? No idea what was available back in the 80s.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 7y agoTake into account that Ultra (breaking of enigma) was only made public in 1970s (or 1960s if you count information about Polish intelligence breaking enigma before WWII). NSA only stopped using similar rotor-based designs in 1980s.