3 ms·
> I think what you perceive as "failing to clearly keep the two questions clearly distinguished" may simply be a misinterpration of deep disinterest in the ques
by skissane 7y ago
> I think what you perceive as "failing to clearly keep the two questions clearly distinguished" may simply be a misinterpration of deep disinterest in the question, I think most mathematicians wouldn't perceive the question of "how everyday human thinking works" to be in the realm of math.
Well, how "everyday thinking works" is very much related to the realm of math in my mind. Most commonly classical logic is selected as a foundation for mathematics, although there has been some work done on alternative foundations (most significantly constructivism/intuitionism, although there are less notable projects trying to build out mathematics on yet other foundations.) But, classical logic is commonly criticised by philosophers as being a poor model of everyday human thought, as represented by issues such as the paradoxes of material implication. So, alternative logics get proposed which attempt to answer those criticisms – for example, relevant/relevance logic. The study of these alternative logical formalisms is itself part of mathematics (mathematical logic, proof theory, etc), and the question of whether any of those alternative logical formalisms can be used as a foundation to develop other parts of mathematics (such as analysis) is an interesting mathematical question. And, added to all that, studying alternative logics is also interesting from the viewpoint of their possible practical applications in computer science (in fields such as automated reasoning.)
On the topic of set theory, while most mathematics assumes ZFC, there has been a lot of work on alternative set theories [1]. For each of these alternatives, we can ask (a) the philosophical question of whether it does a better job of modelling naïve human thought than ZFC does; (b) the metamathematical question of how easy it is to build out the rest of mathematics on that foundation; (c) the question of whether the theory has any useful applications in other fields such as computer science. All three questions are interesting, and they are all interconnected.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_set_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_set_theory