3 ms·
Hacker News is smaller than most major subreddits in terms of usage. 400 upvotes is considered a lot here. The site is extremely simple and something that could
by MattGaiser 7y ago
Hacker News is smaller than most major subreddits in terms of usage. 400 upvotes is considered a lot here. The site is extremely simple and something that could be replicated in a couple of days at most by most engineers. It doesn't process money or really require a lot of content moderation either.
- freddie_mercury 7y agoThat is all true but the real answer is that it is run as a charity project by billionaires. So it doesn't need to be monetized.
- MattGaiser 7y agoThey probably source enough engineers on here to make it more bait rather than charity.
- bigiain 7y agoThere are very few billionaire charity projects that don't have some kind of bait stench associated with them... This site is a lot less brazen that, say the Gates Foundation or Jack Dorseys "all the strings attached" charity "donations", but there's no doubt it's run in the interests of YC and they're doing it for the benefits they get. Not that I begrudge them that. It just needs to be something you bear in mind when wondering about odd looking article rankings or apparent voting/submission patterns that evade the fraud detection... It's their space, they can do that if they want. I (and everyone else) needs to weight up the benefit to themselves against the benefit to the people in control, and determine whether to hang around here, or walk away. For me? They do an OK job of not taking too m much advantage of their ultimate power here. I'm mostly cool with them.
- bcassedy 7y agoEhh there's a really pro ycombinator slant and ever notice how any yc announcement, hiring notice, or article quickly hits the top? They're getting a lot of value out of that stuff that helps with the VC side of things.
- MattGaiser 7y agoWho would hate on YCombinator?
- ashtonkem 7y agoThere are some legitimate arguments about how VC backed startups have behaved as of late, and YC is part of that overall system. I’m not sure where I personally sit, but I think it’s a bit silly to pretend that YC is universally beloved or beyond reproach.
- MattGaiser 7y agoI did not think it was universally beloved, but just never read any negative viewpoint about them so was curious.
- ashtonkem 7y agoKeep in mind that YC is very visible. As a result, complaints about VC behavior in general will accumulate to YC, since they’re often the public face of startups and startup culture. That might not be fair or ever correct, but it’s how people work. Personally, YC’s involvement in AirBnB is my biggest complaint with the company. I’m not sure how it looked from the inside before hand, but in retrospect AirBnB is one of the poster children of VC backed companies extracting profits at the cost of society, and I suspect that they probably should’ve known better.
- alentist 7y ago> AirBnB is one of the poster children of VC backed companies extracting profits at the cost of society Do you have any evidence to back up that claim? Because hard data shows exactly the opposite: https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2018/beyond-bls/how-airbnb-has-affected-the-hotel-industry.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2018/beyond-bls/how-airbnb-has-...
- 7y ago
- code_duck 7y agoI think it lands in a place between 'charity project' and 'neglible expense of time and effort'.
- samatman 7y agoGiven ycombinator's market cap, it might be the most cost-effective loss leader in history.
- lowdose 7y agoI think YC doesn't publish the numbers to prevent a bandwagon effect from happening. Or do you know more about the numbers?
- julianeon 7y ago> The site is extremely simple and something that could be replicated in a couple of days at most by most engineers. I'm a little skeptical of this. Don't get me wrong, I understand that it's not going to win any ACM awards for innovation in web development - it's a simple web app. I know this. But I think it's well beyond the 2-day prototype mark. Because I know what a cheapo off-the-shelf, 2-day-product or PHP forum feels like, and Hacker News doesn't feel like that. It's a little more fine-grained and thoughtful than that. The design, and probably countless little feature improvements that take time to make: I think these have accreted over time, a tiny bit at a time. And for what it's worth, getting comments to nest (stored in DB, parent, child, child of child etc.) and then to show that correctly in the UI isn't quite as easy as people who haven't attempted it might think. And then things like downvoted comments being faded, next page loading at screen bottom, setting up the API... it all adds up.
- ramraj07 7y agoSure, but a mvp that does 75% of it is definitely possible in a weekend for a pair of really good in-the-zone coders. I'd argue that if you actually list out all these minor features fully, it's even possible to flesh it out completely in 4-5 very long days. Even otherwise, this could easily be a site that starts with a full weekend of work for mvp, followed by gradual refininig over the next few months with feedback needing no more than a Saturday afternoon. I wouldn't even consider myself the best coder out there and I have definitely coded something in a similar timeline in the past - a Netflix style book lending website with queues, inventories, user auth, the whole shebang. Im sure it wouldn't work in the same scale as HN, but I doubt it would have been that hard to keep up. As I typed this I realized how unsubstantiated this claim looks, and to be frank the cost of just doing this isn't even that high, so I'm probably just going to do this next weekend for giggles. Let's see!
- stormdennis 7y agoI hope you did better than Netflix. It's horrible to navigate. For example it's really really not obvious how you find previous seasons of a show.
- MaxBarraclough 7y ago> or really require a lot of content moderation I'm not sure about that. HN is moderated very effectively. I couldn't comment on the workload there, not being a moderator.