4 ms·
It's hard for me to judge, despite being quite libertarian, because to me the closure orders were finally in line with what I had already been doing. The closur
by mindslight 7y ago
It's hard for me to judge, despite being quite libertarian, because to me the closure orders were finally in line with what I had already been doing. The closure orders certainly seemed abrupt compared to the past several decades, but not necessarily in the context of previous pandemics.
I get your general point with regards to say the "patriot" act, mass surveillance, etc. But on the other side of that, intelligence agents have complained of there simply being too much data to sift through. So once again it could be a kind of miswielded faux power rather than actual power.
I think you'd have to dig into the historical record to really find out. I'm not a big reader of history, but many things from the past seem more authoritarian. I mean, the draft. Can you even imagine that today?
- 627467 7y agoMany (liberal) countries still hold mandatory military services. I think there was much more resistance to the general consensus around 9/11 and other "man made catastrophes" than this one. "Science" has shut off any debate and human creativity.
- mindslight 7y agoYou say '"science"', I say reality. There isn't much room for creativity, because nobody wants elective exposure when the spread is still fundamentally unmanaged and growing. There is no middleground of prudently half-exposing yourself. Rather you go out only when you have to and mitigate that exposure as much as possible. The political debate is basically driven by people wanting others to ignore the problem, so that they themselves will be less disrupted. For military service, specifically the US has moved away from the draft though. It's much less authoritarian to effortlessly cheerlead for sending employees off to die, versus being so whipped up that the majority of the population is willing to go themselves. Mandatory military service only works when people trust the government. If USG attempted to institute a draft for its next nation building exercise, it would find out how little support its wars actually have.
- kitotik 7y ago> I mean, the draft. Can you even imagine that today? Not in the US, no. 1) Theres not a reason to when there are so many poor people who volunteer for the promise of 3 hots and a cot, healthcare, and an education 2) The workarounds that >=middle class would have to do to keep their children exempt would be harder to keep quiet in the age of social media 3) If >= middle class kids were actually forced into service, it would be much more difficult to garner wide spread support for military actions 4) There’s much more legal flexibility now than there used to be. It’s not really required or useful to formally declare war and open up a draft.