3 ms·
> The nasty question in this whole thing would be: what so strangled capitalism that feudalism was able to make a comeback I think you're assuming that the feu
by mindslight 7y ago
> The nasty question in this whole thing would be: what so strangled capitalism that feudalism was able to make a comeback
I think you're assuming that the feudalism is referring to replacing the current system, rather than building a new system on top of it and describing the new structure within.
I don't think the article's neo-feudalism directly predicts that people in the hinterlands will be extracted from physically. But rather just in the scope of their digital activity - they want to communicate with friends, use Facebook, and Facebook grows richer off of their labor. But I do think the article hops around between the narrow digital context and the larger world to lend more gravity to its point.
Talking about the entire real world, and making things easy by assuming some basic income - what keeps people in the hinterlands from just sitting around? The article critiques the lack of a coherent description of work, which I am perpetuating. But the article also leans on Facebook moderators of an example of new-style work, even though it is fundamentally unnecessary.
To the extent that we go down this path, we could also just not have an economy - the people in the hinterlands could very well just end up homesteading, physically and digitally. Food and shelter enabled by cheap technology, setting up DIY servers for themselves and their friends, and scavenging digital devices that are cast off by the more centralized economy for lack of software updates.
I kind of already feel this way running libreboot/me_cleaned coreboot/microg for my main devices, and keeping as much stuff out of the cloud as possible. News about the latest gadgets just doesn't excite me much.