5 ms·
It's simple. However unsuitable we may be for life in outer space, we do need a plan B, any plan B, in case life on this planet gets obliterated by an asteroid,
by airstrike 7y ago
It's simple. However unsuitable we may be for life in outer space, we do need a plan B, any plan B, in case life on this planet gets obliterated by an asteroid, war or runaway climate change.
One would think the frailty of human life on this world would be top of mind right now, what with the once-in-a-century pandemic we're living through.
- coderintherye 7y agoIt's an interesting question though: Is plan B of succeeding in interstellar travel actually easier than a plan in which we figure out how to change our biological construct to survive in harsher climate-change or post-war conditions?
- airstrike 7y agoIt is interesting indeed, and meant to add to my comment that it feels like finding a way to have a permanent settlement in Mars seems more near-term than changes to our biology. I think the consensus is we generally "know" what to do to figure out a way out of this rock (so not necessarily interstellar travel), whereas modifying our biology seems magical in comparison. Living outside of Earth, in a different gravity well, with different doses of radiation and likely in confined spaces is challenging, but at least you can put those things into comprehensible words. I wouldn't even know where to begin describing how we'd modify our biological construct, as you put it.
- cousin_it 7y agoHuman engineering can be put into words. It's just very scary. Genetic modification, cyborgification or mind uploading could give us any bodies we want, but also create new terrifying possibilities of control: imagine you've been genetically modified by a tyrant, or your brain lives in a robot body built by a tyrant, or your uploaded mind is in a computer controlled by a tyrant. Humanity isn't politically ready for human engineering tech - in other words, I wouldn't trust any of today's governments with it - but it's coming one way or another, and probably sooner than starships.
- lnanek2 7y agoThere have already been human babies born with modified genetics to make them less susceptible to HIV. And in the realm of other biology where experimentation is encouraged we've definitely transferred genes for things like frost resistance between organisms. We don't generally make our own genes yet, just break ones we don't want or transfer ones we do want, but if the human race decided to allow it, we could certainly make a good start on improving the body for handling non-Earth conditions.
- eesmith 7y agoShouldn't plan B for most of those scenarios start with the creation of self-sustaining, independent ecosystems here on Earth? Bruce Sterling pointed out that colonizing the Gobi desert should be far easier than colonizing Mars. Set up 100s of these around the world. Worried about a pandemic? Set up testing and quarantine policies for everything and everyone which comes in and out. Seal each site, and stagger any openings to reduce the chance of infection. Once we know how to set those up in the desert, and Antarctica, and underground, we'll be in a much better place for colonizing off-planet. I think it's odd that most of the people who argue the "don't put all your eggs in one basket" point, end up with "make rockets!", not "make self-contained ecosystems!"
- waste_monk 7y ago> Shouldn't plan B for most of those scenarios start with the creation of self-sustaining, independent ecosystems here on Earth? Absolutely not. >I think it's odd that most of the people who argue the "don't put all your eggs in one basket" point, end up with "make rockets!", not "make self-contained ecosystems!" Putting aside classes of events which scour life from the planet (gamma ray burst, being hit by a really huge asteroid, etc. - admittedly having an incrediblby small chance of occuring, but utterly devastating if they do) where the only mitigation is to disperse your eggs amongst a number of stellar baskets, you still have a number of problems. To maintain your isolated ecosystem (and they have to be totally isolated for the argument to work, otherwise it's just a remote community e.g. remote Alaska) you have to be able to maintain your civilisational tech level. If you have to be able to sustain yourself, that means every industrial process your civilisation can achieve must be reproducible inside your isolated community. Not only do you have to be able to acquire raw materials in bulk (or make it yourself at incredible cost of energy [1]), you have to have the industrial machinery to produce it along with all intermediate products. And on top of all that, you have to have people who understand the processes involved at every level. No single person can understand that much or even groups less than thousands or tens of thousands eople, from the low level physics, to metallurgy, wire drawing, PCB construction, architecture, various fields of engineering, electronics specialties, agriculture and farming, etc. No one person alive could make a modern computer from scratch, or even something relatively simple like a (modern) solar cell. You might be able to produce tech up to around WW1 era with some difficulty, or even WW2 if you had a largeish population, but something like building a computer processor using a 14nm fabrication process would be impossible. Even building simple engines for cars would still be useless unless you have the ability to produce engine oil, fuel, lubricants, and so on. People do build wire wrap computers and other curiosities by hand, but that's still relying on civilisation to provide materials and knowledge. And this is just trying to fight off entropy, making no consideration for doing useful research and creating new technologies. Unless you handwave in scifi tech like nanobots that can mine, produce, and repair things for you, the only way to be truly self-sufficient is to occupy a massive footprint of land (continent size or larger depending on raw resource availability), have a massive industrial capacity, and a massive population to not only run all of this but also to educate and perpetuate - so you don't set it all up and then end up losing all your tech in a few generations because no-one understands it. This is getting rather long winded so I'll stop, but my point is that if you're going to go to all the effort of setting up a Redundant Array of Independent Civilisations, you might as well do it properly and send them to another world where they won't be at risk. Nothing else could justify the expenditure. Not to mention not having to worry about borders, mining rights, mineral depletion, raiders who want to take your stuff for themselves, sabotage, etc. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_transmutation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_transmutation