6 ms·
I don't know how long you've been doing Python and Ruby, but when Why wrote that, the relationship between Rubyists and Pythonistas was pretty chilly. As I saw
by chc 16y ago
I don't know how long you've been doing Python and Ruby, but when Why wrote that, the relationship between Rubyists and Pythonistas was pretty chilly.
As I saw it: There was this feeling that, after years of being dismissed as a mere scripting language, it was Python's time to shine — but then Ruby came along and (pushed along by Rails) was about to steal Python's thunder, and they were so similar that people thought there was only room for one such language in the New World Order. So Pythonistas began acting pretty rude toward the upstart Rubyists, and the Rubyists got this idea that Python was an evil, enemy technology.
- robbles 16y agoDo you have an example of this? I've always seen it as the other way round - Rubyists dismissing Python along with PHP and Java as old/irrelevant/less powerful. But the whole thing is pointless anyway. Everyone should learn at least a little of both languages since they're both fantastic.
- Luyt 16y agoI saw a video of a talk of DHH in which he expressed his love for Ruby; he also said that Ruby was/is his first language and he doesn't need any other languages. As a counterexample, he showed a snippet of a Python class and scoffed at the double underscores for special methods, and the need to explicitely use 'self'.
- rbanffy 16y agoI have to agree the Ruby community always seemed to be very... emotional.
- alinajaf 16y agoPerhaps I don't participate in the mailing lists and message boards where these battles were fought, but the only python/ruby users I've met in real life have always been pretty neutral towards the other language, at least acknowledging that it's better than the alternatives (PHP, Java etc).
- yantramanav 16y agoMaybe this should serve as a reminder to all of us: http://jacobian.org/writing/thank-you-rails/ http://jacobian.org/writing/thank-you-rails/
- extension 16y agoThere is a stark ideological contrast between the Ruby and Python communities with regard to code uniformity. Pythonistas believe there should be only one obvious way to do things. Rubyists, on the other hand, are more accepting of personal style in code, probably having gleaned some of the individualism from Perl culture.
- ig1 16y agoI disagree, Rubyist barely exist, Ruby is primarily driven by Rails, and if anything is more opposite to the Perl TMTOWTDI concept it's "The Rails Way". You can follow the Rails design or you can experience a lot of pain trying to do it any other way.
- regularfry 16y agoThat's a regrettably blinkered view of Ruby.
- rbanffy 16y agoI don't remember Python ever having a driving force equivalent to Rails. Ruby was a somewhat obscure language before Rails, regardless of its strenghts. I got into Python because of Zope, but the world would be a much, much better place had it been as popular as Rails.
- FooBarWidget 16y agoWhile it is true that Ruby became popular because of Rails, it is no longer true that Ruby is only popular in the area of Rails nowadays.
- radq 16y ago> the world would be a much, much better place had it been as popular as Rails. Why?
- rbanffy 16y ago
- jonhohle 16y ago> and they were so similar that people thought there was only room for one such language in the New World Order. I hear this said a lot, but where does this idea come from? Their object models are different, their syntax is different, their goals are different. Admittedly, I haven't written much Python (my experience is mostly reading it), but that's primarily because I preferred Ruby and have never seen what Python brings to the table.