3 ms·
So, for this to work - you need a reasonably large set of decisions to be decided in one big election, - rational agents, even though the topics is emotional.
by tgv 7y ago
So, for this to work
- you need a reasonably large set of decisions to be decided in one big election,
- rational agents, even though the topics is emotional.
And how do they reach the conclusion that "the system will be predisposed to dominance by special interest groups with strong, concentrated interests"? That might be in some limit towards infinity case, but in practice? And why that would be a good thing, is beyond me.
- erentz 7y agoAnd who decides what the issues are that get voted on? This is an important flaw IMO against multi issue voting with this system. If the people making the list of issues are biased they can make one big issue for all the stuff they care about, and a thousand little issues for the stuff other people care about. Every issue needs equal footing to overcome this, meaning each issue needs to be its own independent election, effectively making QV useless.
- tgv 7y agoI too think it's totally possible to rig such elections. E.g., if there's something group A wants, but you don't, you add something group A is totally against, so all their votes will go to the latter issue, and the status quo is kept as far as group A is concerned. Meanwhile, their votes are lost for other issues.