4 ms·
> Which needs are we talking about? Why does this society's rulers think it needs them, and not the society next door? And are these so-called needs really abou
by xg15 7y ago
> Which needs are we talking about? Why does this society's rulers think it needs them, and not the society next door? And are these so-called needs really about entrenched powers oppressing someone?
Counter question: Why would Facebook (or any other tech company of your choosing) know any better what a society needs than the society itself?
Tech companies love to paint themselves as the brave protectors of the powerless against the oppressive regimes of the world.
This may be true in certain cases - however, this still doesn't seem to keep them from doing business with the exact same regimes - and it doesn't seem to motivate them to adhere to regulations any better if they are passed by functioning democracies.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoThey wouldn't necessarily. The better question is: Why would Facebook's Users know better what they, as individual human beings, want, rather than whoever is in charge of the society, including their meddlesome neighbors, self-aggrandizing politicians, and repressive religious leaders? (n.b. there are real meaningful answers to this question which respect individual agency instead of simply collectivizing all decisions about who is allowed to send bits to whom; it's just much more work to nail them down.)
- nemothekid 7y ago>Counter question: Why would Facebook (or any other tech company of your choosing) know any better what a society needs than the society itself? This is a strange question. (1) Society isn't a singular being that has perfect information about what it wants. (2) Society has a terrible track record for what it wants. There's a rather large slice of society that believes it's ok to enact vigilante justice on minorities and a president who has routinely parroted conspiracy theories. I'm not convinced "society" knows that it needs either and I'd rather see Facebook destroyed than it's power handed over to "society".