28 ms·
STEM people really struggle with the idea that the humanities are not vocational training - because they are vocational training for the political class, who do
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
STEM people really struggle with the idea that the humanities are not vocational training - because they are vocational training for the political class, who don't need to understand STEM because they use rhetoric, persuasion, and political manipulation to get what they want.
For these people, scientists and technologists are the hired help. While you're telling yourself that knowing how to compile Linux from source gives you god-like superpowers, they're running astroturfing and media campaigns that win elections and define national policy.
Some of those people have English degrees. Because - why not? (In the UK they're more likely to have a PPE from Oxford, but if they have the connections English or some other non-technical subject is fine too.)
In the same way that you won't understand what high school math is really for unless you put it in context with a STEM degree, you can't understand what the humanities are really for unless you put them in a political context.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoYou've just described why the most common qualifications held in the Senate and in the House are law degrees first, and MBAs second. The humanities is not the educational background of our political class, it's mostly Law, Business and Medicine.
- SideburnsOfDoom 7y ago> the political class, who don't need to understand STEM because they use rhetoric, persuasion, and political manipulation to get what they want. And right now, we are witnessing this line of thinking crashing and burning up, as you can't persuade a virus. You _have to_ understand the underlying science, and not make this category error. There's no away around it. Unfortunately, persuasive but ignorant leaders have convinced many people otherwise, so it's not until there's a real issue that this lack becomes apparent by example. I'm sure that "rhetoric, persuasion, and political manipulation" have their usages, but to think that they're "all that you need" is what's causing issues in the countries that are handing COVID badly. There will be more examples of this kind of problem before the 21st century is over.