3 ms·
If you like this, you'll probably be interested in STAR[0]. It has a really high voter satisfaction efficiency[1]. Pretty much it is the best if you want to acc
by godelski 7y ago
If you like this, you'll probably be interested in STAR[0]. It has a really high voter satisfaction efficiency[1]. Pretty much it is the best if you want to account for strategic voting[2] (Condorcet methods don't handle these as well, but do have a higher VSE when it isn't accounted for, but we're talking pretty close anyways).
So why Cardinal systems? They are a lot easier than ranked systems. You like two people equally? You hate two people equally? No worries, just give them the same number. You basically have all the advantages in this case (I'll mention that Gibbard's[3] is an extension of Arrow's and it applies here). But why we would want this system is because it makes for the best of both worlds between the "we need parties" and "fuck parties" groups.
Let's take an example: Pick your favorite outside candidate: Bernie, Tulsi, Warren, Yang. If the general election was using STAR it wouldn't matter who the Dems pushed. You could still vote for these candidates and it wouldn't help you're candidate win. So I'd imagine a HN ballot could look something like this
Biden: 5
Gabbard: 7
Sanders: 10
Trump: 3
Warren: 9
Yang: 8
If Bernie, Tulsi, Warren, and Yang did not get enough votes to win, it would still be like the same election where we are choosing Biden v Trump, even though Biden wasn't your first choice. This means you can vote honestly (i.e. which candidate is closest to your opinion and not which candidate you think can win). It entirely removes the "electibility" question.
Why cardinal over ranked? One simple answer is that when cardinal breaks down it turns into approval voting. Approval voting is "I like this candidate" vs "I dislike this candidate". It is essentially the way we pick where to eat with friends. Everyone says "I don't know". So you start listing off places and once enough people say "sure", you pick that. It doesn't get you the best place to eat, but no one is really unhappy either. What STAR does is basically give you the options: "Hate it", "no", "ehhh", "I guess", "fine", "yes", "hell fucking yeah" (that'd be STAR06).
STAR is simple to understand, leads to high voter satisfaction, removes the electibility issue, let's parties exist without parties dominating (i.e. other parties can actually compete), easy to pick a winner, and more qualities we like in voting systems (if you're trying to make a fair system where people get representatives that represent their ideals). Of course, this does not fix the issues of money in politics, people lying, and all that.
This is just one component, but I think an essential component that will have huge effects on any democratically elected system and I think it is something that we really should fight for. It is also easy to sell the idea because everyone wants a more fair voting system.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STAR_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STAR_voting
[1]https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/VSE/ https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/VSE/
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactical_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tactical_voting
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibbard%27s_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibbard%27s_theorem
- naniwaduni 7y agoWhat's the appeal over straight approval voting, which can be explained and justified in about three sentences, and almost self-evidently produces good-enough results?
- godelski 7y agoThere's more finesse in STAR. Because you are better able to specify __how much you approve__ this leads to higher voter satisfaction.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 7y agoIs there any hard evidence for this? I'm sure there would be higher voter satisfaction among the types of folks that study alternative election systems and don't mind reading about every candidate on their ballot, but more convoluted systems generally lead to lower voter satisfaction because they're required to do more work/studying up front to maximize their voting power, and the results are more difficult to interpret. Most voters walk into a polling place with 1 or 2 people they like, 1 or 2 people they don't like, and a bunch of people they don't care about, which is perfectly fine, and it should be taken into account with any proposed voting system.
- godelski 7y agoWhat do you mean hard evidence? In all the sims (which you can find many more and much more detailed ones than what I listed, STAR's website has many itself[0]) it yields better satisfaction than approval. This should be obvious that it is. > the results are more difficult to interpret. Are you concerned about it being complicated? I'm sorry, but I just don't buy this argument. These types of scales are in questionnaires everywhere. I don't buy that people are so stupid that they can't just score a candidate. Even if they just ranked them it wouldn't have a large effect on the outcome. In fact, this can fix accidents with ranked choice where people accidentally rank candidates the same rank. And if a significant amount of people are that dumb, well it still works out. Leaving an entry blank counts as a score of 0. You can score only a single candidate if you want, that's fine. > but more convoluted systems generally lead to lower voter satisfaction because they're required to do more work/studying up front to maximize their voting power You aren't required to do anything. And honestly, a lot of people do look into multiple candidates. Hell, the entire primaries are essentially people doing background research on candidates. But if they don't, sure, that's just called dishonest voting, which STAR handles better than ranked. I honestly don't understand this type of criticism. It hinges on the idea that the average voter is dumber than a rock. > Most voters walk into a polling place with 1 or 2 people they like, 1 or 2 people they don't like, and a bunch of people they don't care about, which is perfectly fine, and it should be taken into account with any proposed voting system. You do realize that STAR accounts for this, right? You don't have to vote for everyone. If you just liked Biden you could just give him any number greater than 0 and your vote would be for him. At WORST STAR is identical approval. [0] https://www.starvoting.us/ https://www.starvoting.us/