3 ms·
>> Using this anonymous ballot system provides identity protection from vote buying or trading since these exchanges cannot be verified by the buyer or trader.
by sandworm101 7y ago
>> Using this anonymous ballot system provides identity protection from vote buying or trading since these exchanges cannot be verified by the buyer or trader.
I'm really split on that one. I'm not sure that anonymity does much to curb vote buying. I think it allows vote buying to fly under the radar. If we know how a politician votes we can then compare that to fundraising and lobbying records. With anonymous voting we are blind.
A modern lobbyist doesn't care about verifying individual votes. They lobby multiple people, entire parties, to shift trends. If they fail on an issue that only means the people they were lobbying don't have control of their party. The lobbyists move to other people for the next round. Eventually they work out where to send their money and start winning regardless. At least with non-anonymous voting outsiders have some hope of tracking what is going on.
- jedberg 7y agoThe author is talking about anonymous votes for citizens. Not representatives.
- mkolodny 7y agoLobbying is very different from vote buying. Vote buying is saying to someone, "I'll buy your vote for $X". If votes are anonymous, then there's no way to verify that you actually got what you paid for.
- cheerlessbog 7y agoPresumably there are reliable votes on either side that are well known : subtract those from the result and you may have a fair idea whther your puppet obeyed his master. It might not be easy to confidently disobey.
- sokoloff 7y agoVotes by people in elections are what’s being contemplated as being bought, not votes by a much smaller group of representatives on specific legislation.