4 ms·
There ought to be a little-guy version. Like this: Anyone can signup for nominal fee ($100), every member donates all their patents to the pool and gets rights
by DenisM 18y ago
There ought to be a little-guy version. Like this:
Anyone can signup for nominal fee ($100), every member donates all their patents to the pool and gets rights to the pool. Once you have rights to the pool you can force a cross-licensing agreement with any other real company (won't work with patent trolls though). Those who don't want to donate their stuff can pay really big money to get stuff from it, which will go towards maintaining the organization.
This may not work well on small scale, but if it were to reach large scale it will become very attractive to join and will put an end to the patent system, for good.
- hugh 18y agoPatents vary hugely in value. The vast majority turn out to be worth almost nothing, while a few are worth billions. I'm pretty sure if you had this it would just accumulate all the worthless patents, while people and companies who owned the valuable ones would have no interest in joining.
- cwp 18y agoActually, that doesn't matter very much. The point of the pool is not to get access to patented technology that you wouldn't otherwise be able to use. It's to be able to defend yourself against patent lawsuits. If you're sued, you can counter sue for infringing some stupid worthless patent in the pool, because any real implementation of anything infringes on some patent. With enough patents in the pool, counter-suit becomes a viable defense. Not also that this is why it won't work against patent trolls - they don't actually do anything of substance, and therefore aren't vulnerable to counter-suit.
- DenisM 18y agoRight, and as big dogs lose profit in patent system, they will lobby to can the whole thing completely. Thus patent trolls will also lose in the end.