2 ms·
>"The point of the paper is that if we want economics to be a science, we have to recognize that it is not ok for macroeconomists to hole up in separate camps,
by Barrin92 7y ago
>"The point of the paper is that if we want economics to be a science, we have to recognize that it is not ok for macroeconomists to hole up in separate camps, one that supports its version of the geocentric model of the solar system and another that supports the heliocentric model. As scientists, we have to hold ourselves to a standard that requires us to reach a consensus about which model is right, and then to move on to other questions."
I disagree with this. Convergence on one methodology, model or theory is usually achieved by some process of reductionism, but the complexity of economics makes it hard to ever come to some straight forward conclusion about which form of inquiry is superior, or if there even is such a thing.
Even physics is not safe from this. People have questioned the importance of string theory and its 'mathiness' and difficulty to be empirically verified. Some people believe in grand unified theories, others think they're not worth pursuing.
In general I think what ever helps clarifying issues we have or helps solve problems is worth keeping. I think we ought to science more as a form of discourse than as some sort of 'model' that needs to converge on anything. Mathiness has its place and so has non mathiness. Different models may work in different circumstances.