3 ms·
> His backing is why it's "news," he spend/gives millions to the press to ensure it. No, it's news because the FDA is haulting COVID testing over utterly stupi
by loeg 7y ago
> His backing is why it's "news," he spend/gives millions to the press to ensure it.
No, it's news because the FDA is haulting COVID testing over utterly stupid bureaucracy when we need massively ramped up COVID testing and SCAN/Seattle Flu Study are actually providing quality home tests at scale.
This stands in stark contrast to the hundreds of poor quality home antibody tests the FDA has approved with almost no oversight. It seems inconsistent with the need to cut red tape to fight COVID.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>No, it's news because the FDA is haulting COVID testing over utterly stupid bureaucracy It's not utterly stupid, diagnostic testing adds some amount of bias in the results. The quality of these home tests needs to be proven.
- loeg 7y ago> diagnostic testing adds some amount of bias in the results. How does it add bias? Also, this is not the FDA's stated concern. > The quality of these home tests needs to be proven. They have been. That data has been submitted to the FDA a month ago.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoA diagnostic test is often run on a person who suspects they already have the virus. That creates a loaded sample pool, and adds bias to the results.
- loeg 7y agoThat is not how the SCAN study chooses study participants.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoFrom what I can gather, they allowed a free signup for participants. People with flu-like symptoms are more likely to be searching for tests and to go through the hassle of acquiring a test. Source https://www.king5.com/mobile/article/news/health/coronavirus/seattle-flu-study-adapted-for-coronavirus/281-cdce1316-666e-4ec9-a842-c33382d57304 https://www.king5.com/mobile/article/news/health/coronavirus...
- loeg 7y agoThey don't send kits to everyone who uses the website, and they ask "do you have symptoms?" in advance of asking if you want to be tested. Certainly there is some self-selection bias in using the website at all. That would also be true if they did not provide results. Regardless, it has nothing to do with the TFA and the FDA's actions.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>That would also be true if they did not provide results. Both sides would have notably different biases that would need to be accounted for, and would have different guidelines for FDA approval. Pausing the project when you discover there was a miscommunication over what kind of testing was being done makes sense. You need to keep the potentially tricky data separate from further results. >Regardless, it has nothing to do with the TFA and the FDA's actions. It's the actual reason they gave for their actions, and their request for more information on tests done to people not showing symptoms would be one of the main things they need to determine what bias is present.
- SteveJS 7y agoIt is fair to say this group is the reason we didn’t have an even worse outbreak, and it was solely due to defying the Federal officials: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/03/emergent-ventures-prize-winners-for-coronavirus-work.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/03/em... “By Feb. 25, Dr. Chu and her colleagues could not bear to wait any longer. They began performing coronavirus tests, without government approval. What came back confirmed their worst fear. They quickly had a positive test from a local teenager with no recent travel history. The coronavirus had already established itself on American soil without anybody realizing it.”
- taeric 7y agoThis story strikes me as off. It runs counter to every other aspect of the virus we focus on. Specifically, if it was already spreading in schools, then why don't we see scores of critical kids and parents? With how contagious this is, I find it fairly unconvincing that it was just that student. Combined with symptoms taking about a week to present, this was in community spread for a while. Yet, here in WA, the deaths figure is still 92% over sixty years old. I don't know the percent from long term care facilities. (I would love that stat.) Then the question is at what point did it break into long term care facilities? And could we have done something to strengthen their protection? With a further question of what, exactly, causes it to go severe.