3 ms·
> Here is this comment applied to the situation in America ~160 years ago No, a proper application would be: If we could spark an earnest discussion about how
by pdonis 7y ago
> Here is this comment applied to the situation in America ~160 years ago
No, a proper application would be:
If we could spark an earnest discussion about how to move towards abolition of slavery peacefully, we could avoid having to fight a war that kills a million people and does not improve the actual material condition of the slaves at all, not to mention leading to another century of Jim Crow laws.
But it was already too late in 1860 to have that kind of discussion. It should have happened in the 1820s or 1830s, when many Southern states were indeed considering abolishing slavery--until the fiery no-compromise rhetoric of abolitionists swung the South the other way. The Virginia state legislature had a bill abolishing slavery in 1831 that was close to passing--until copies of William Lloyd Garrison's pamphlet containing copies of his "no moderation" speech arrived and were read by the members.
- ihm 7y ago> The Virginia state legislature had a bill abolishing slavery in 1831 that was close to passing--until copies of William Lloyd Garrison's pamphlet containing copies of his "no moderation" speech arrived and were read by the members. I'm no expert in this period but from a cursory research I don't see how you could make this claim. This page gives a completely different impression, which is basically that the legislature punted on the issue[0]. Are we have discussions about how to move toward abolition of the wage system and minoritarian control of the economy peacefully? I am all for that. From history, though, it seems that those who have power are not liable to relinquish that power without putting up a fight. [0]: https://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Virginia_Slavery_Debate_of_1831-1832_The https://www.encyclopediavirginia.org/Virginia_Slavery_Debate...
- pdonis 7y agoIIRC the story I referred to is in Beveridge's Life Of John Marshall, Volume IV. Unfortunately I don't have my copy handy to check right now.