3 ms·
>I don't see why the fact that Bill Gates "backs" it has anything to do with the program I doubt the FDA's decision had anything to do with the Gates connectio
by boomboomsubban 7y ago
>I don't see why the fact that Bill Gates "backs" it has anything to do with the program
I doubt the FDA's decision had anything to do with the Gates connection, but most study rejections don't get articles in the NYT. His backing is why it's "news," he spend/gives millions to the press to ensure it.
- anonymouswacker 7y agoYou're right. I wish NY Times were slightly above this practice, of including a polarizing celebrity with no relation to the story as if he is either A. an authority, or B. an actor in the narrative. This attracts both the audience who thinks Bill Gates' work is humanitarian, and those who think he is doing this for selfish (money/power/influence) reasons. It seems his only connection, from what I can tell, is proximity and endorsement, which are irrelevant, and only tangential to the story, which is already scant.
- FireBeyond 7y agoI disagree with that - at least in this instance. Perhaps in other situations, but if you're suggesting that a program between the major state and city health departments in Seattle (which was one of the earliest known COVID-19 cities) _about_ COVID-19 being halted would otherwise "not be news", I'm going to have to disagree. Edit: to say "halted".
- boomboomsubban 7y agoFor a start, it wasn't "canceled," it was halted until proper authorization is obtained. I don't really see the point of most of the stories about various ongoing tests. Until something is shown to be effective, what benefit do we get from learning all these details?
- loeg 7y ago> His backing is why it's "news," he spend/gives millions to the press to ensure it. No, it's news because the FDA is haulting COVID testing over utterly stupid bureaucracy when we need massively ramped up COVID testing and SCAN/Seattle Flu Study are actually providing quality home tests at scale. This stands in stark contrast to the hundreds of poor quality home antibody tests the FDA has approved with almost no oversight. It seems inconsistent with the need to cut red tape to fight COVID.
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>No, it's news because the FDA is haulting COVID testing over utterly stupid bureaucracy It's not utterly stupid, diagnostic testing adds some amount of bias in the results. The quality of these home tests needs to be proven.
- loeg 7y ago> diagnostic testing adds some amount of bias in the results. How does it add bias? Also, this is not the FDA's stated concern. > The quality of these home tests needs to be proven. They have been. That data has been submitted to the FDA a month ago.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoA diagnostic test is often run on a person who suspects they already have the virus. That creates a loaded sample pool, and adds bias to the results.
- loeg 7y agoThat is not how the SCAN study chooses study participants.
- boomboomsubban 7y agoFrom what I can gather, they allowed a free signup for participants. People with flu-like symptoms are more likely to be searching for tests and to go through the hassle of acquiring a test. Source https://www.king5.com/mobile/article/news/health/coronavirus/seattle-flu-study-adapted-for-coronavirus/281-cdce1316-666e-4ec9-a842-c33382d57304 https://www.king5.com/mobile/article/news/health/coronavirus...
- loeg 7y agoThey don't send kits to everyone who uses the website, and they ask "do you have symptoms?" in advance of asking if you want to be tested. Certainly there is some self-selection bias in using the website at all. That would also be true if they did not provide results. Regardless, it has nothing to do with the TFA and the FDA's actions.