3 ms·
I'm not a subscriber and only read the intro preview. That's enough to mention a few comments, which perhaps are explained more in-depth later? > "helped persu
by eesmith 7y ago
I'm not a subscriber and only read the intro preview. That's enough to mention a few comments, which perhaps are explained more in-depth later?
> "helped persuade the UK and other countries to bring in draconian lockdowns"
Sure, but other countries too have their own models. If something is one of, say, 20 different models from 20 different organizations, all in reasonable agreement, then isn't "help persuade" ... a good thing?
Even if it's crappy looking code on the surface?
> "could go down in history as the most devastating software mistake of all time, in terms of economic costs and lives lost."
How are "lives lost" measured?
And, wouldn't the Reinhart-Rogoff spreadsheet error also be significant, in how it supported "austerity" policies around the world?
In the 5-whys analysis, a follow-up question might be, why does the UK government depend on academic code for this, rather than having their own full-time/career public health professionals and software developers working on it?
My ill-informed belief is that it's because austerity efforts caused widespread cutbacks in the government's ability to plan for these sorts of contingencies. If so, the Reinhart-Rogoff spreadsheet error is a more devastating software mistake.