4 ms·
This article is misguided, based on a false premise. Food delivery apps are not thriving, if thriving means making big profits. GrubHub's stock price isn't muc
by crazygringo 7y ago
This article is misguided, based on a false premise. Food delivery apps are not thriving, if thriving means making big profits.
GrubHub's stock price isn't much different from where it was 5 years ago. UberEats isn't expected to turn a profit for another five years as they continue to lose money on every order.
There are no monopolies here taking advantage of restauranteurs. There's an entire ecosystem of food delivery apps competing with each other.
The reality of the situation is that delivering meals is extremely expensive. It doesn't have meaningful economies of scale the way package delivery does. Both restaurants and customers have to pay these huge delivery fees because that's just what delivery costs. (In fact, many are still being subsidized by massive VC.)
Running a restaurant is always a precarious business proposition in the first place. Adding delivery is another precarious choice -- you can massively increase revenue but only at the cost of massively decreasing profit percentage, and if you don't calculate exactly right it'll seem like a big waste-of-time wash in the end, or you'll even lose money. That's just how it works.
I have tons of sympathy for restaurant owners, but just because it's hard -- not because they're being taken advantage of, because they're not.
But laws that restrict the ability of food delivery apps to charge what the market will bear isn't going to solve anything. They don't have these extra profits lying around they can just moderately reduce. The inevitable result will be them dropping the restaurants that are least profitable for delivery entirely, and reducing deliverypeople so your food will take two or three times as long to deliver. That's just Econ 101 -- if your revenue is reduced to where there's no path to profit, you need to cut quality. End of story.
- blancNoir 7y agofrom the article "While neither Uber nor Grubhub turns a profit delivering food, they are nonetheless venture-backed and raking in mountains of cash: Grubhub reported revenue of $362.98 million during the first quarter this year, a year-over-year increase of more than 12%. Uber Eats’ revenue surged 53% from the same quarter a year ago, to $819 million. Restaurants, meanwhile, are facing utter devastation. The restaurant industry lost 5.5 million jobs nationwide in April, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. In L.A., the overall unemployment rate now stands at 24%, an increase from 4.7% in February." edit: additional context from article
- oneplane 7y agoSo they are comparing revenue with job loss? Those aren't the same class or the same measure... This is just pointless. Focusing on jobs in the context of gains and losses is a bad idea in general as the only real measure you'd get regarding jobs is 'how many people can support themselves by working' which is the actual real-world impact. And if you want to take survival in to account or basic living standards you could even go a little more abstract and try to report on 'how many people are stuck in poverty'. It doesn't matter how many jobs you have if people barely get by. Same goes for having less jobs: if people are still doing OK it's not as strong an indicator of anything to report job counts.
- crazygringo 7y agoRight, but "raking in mountains of cash" is skipping the "in the face of even larger mountains of costs". That's why this article feels deceitful -- using words like "raking in" and "surging" as if revenue before costs means anything at all. If you lose money on every order, you're not thriving in any sense. You're hoping to thrive some day in the future. The fact that they're venture-backed is irrelevant. Restaurants are backed by investors and bank loans too.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoMost growth-oriented tech companies are “unprofitable” in the sense they invest their revenues into growth rather than dividends. This does not mean their core products necessarily make less money than it costs to operate them, without those massive growth investments. The real question people are asking here is: what necessary costs do the food delivery apps actually incur in operating their business that causes them to have such high commissions and fees and still lose money per transaction?
- crazygringo 7y ago> This does not mean their core products necessarily make less money than it costs to operate them Generally, yes it does. The up-front costs for building and marketing a platform so that it ultimately becomes profitable are enormous. In today's climate, the idea that a company could just "choose" to be profitable now and in the long-term rather than grow is disingenuous: over the following few years, other companies will eat their lunch and they'll fold. But with delivery apps, answering your question is not hard. First, paying delivery people is expensive. Crazy expensive. That's obviously the main variable cost. Then there are huge fixed costs with creating and maintaining a multi-platform app, customer service to deal with late/missing/wrong orders, sales and support for restaurants, marketing, and all the normal business stuff. That's your answer. Food delivery apps aren't spending half their revenue on frivolous side projects like space rockets or cities of the future, or questionably/fraudulently siphoning revenue to a founder. They're just trying to operate as normal businesses, and there's zero evidence to the contrary.
- haltingproblem 7y agoGrubless charges 20-30% for just ordering and checkout. In addition restaurants have to opt-in to promotions ($10 off $15) which are then passed on to them. Delivery fees are on top of that if the restaurants choose to use Grub-less' delivery network. I dont know the breakdown but most I know use their own. Uber-eats is different.
- crazygringo 7y agoSo? That brings hundreds or thousands of customers a month to a restaurant that wouldn't otherwise go/order. The alternative marketing+order management costs for a restaurant to generate and fulfill that demand on their own is even higher on average, or else restaurants would be using alternatives. And there is a ton of work involved on GrubHub's part of operating/maintaining the sites/apps, handling customer service (frequently), moderating reviews, provide support to restaurants, combating fraud, marketing, and so on. Believe me. If you could create a GrubHub/Seamless clone only charging restaurants 5% to use it and still be profitable, then competitors would have already done so.
- bergstromm466 7y agoThey definitely are thriving. They will survive the lockdown, and it will help their market share. This always leads to monopolizing and later abuse of that monopoly position. We've got a beautiful history of labour movement, let's return to some earlier precedents. In this world, your world, we have somehow become accepting of Amazon workers working in cages and peeing in bottles because they do not get sufficient breaks. A world where single mothers work three jobs to sustain their family.