8 ms·
> why should I'm not a huge fan of moralistic takes on business. If you're selling something dangerous then that's wrong, but it's very easy to be blinkered fr
by mhh__ 7y ago
> why should
I'm not a huge fan of moralistic takes on business. If you're selling something dangerous then that's wrong, but it's very easy to be blinkered from a high position.
If people want to buy food in a certain way I can't really blame them - arguably the same with Uber and taxis, Uber has disrupted an industry which was fairly uncompetitive and politically charged (Their prevalence indicates the customers appreciate their presence in the space)
- swiley 7y agoYeah I feel like the “people shouldn’t profit from catastrophe” thing is a big part of why it’s still hard to get PPE (no one can justify extra manufacturing etc.)
- tasty_freeze 7y agoYou misunderstand the difference between profiting and profiteering. Nobody is claiming companies should sell toilet paper at cost, but they are saying toilet paper shouldn't get 5x more expensive.
- Retric 7y agoIMO some price increase is a good idea to discourage hoarding, promote investment, and promote alternatives like a bidet. But, I think you achieve most of that with simply doubling prices, after that it’s generally more harm than good.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> But, I think you achieve most of that with simply doubling prices, after that it’s generally more harm than good. How can one make such a vast claim without knowing things such as cost of input materials, machinery, labor, etc?
- Retric 7y agoThe profit in a competitive market is usually ~5%. Double prices while selling out and profit increases by 21x if not vastly more which is a huge incentive. To the point where doubling the profit again is unlikely result in meaningfully increased production. PS: And yea it’s more complex than that, you can generally skip out in advertising but may be paying significant overtime etc. But that’s rarely particularly important as there are so many inputs involved in ramping up production that you hit multiple different limits.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoHow is that not particularly important? In a shortage scenario, you don’t just crank up a dial to make the factory output more. You might need additional facilities, new factories, new workers, etc at the same time others are trying to secure resources too. People in short supply also don’t just work additional hours for double pay. An hour of my leisure time is worth far more than double.
- sokoloff 7y agoThough I believe you would not work overtime for double time, I also believe that an enormous number of people would do so.
- JamesBarney 7y agoTo argue that every possible choice to both produce and conserve toilet paper is incentivized at $1.68 is an extraordinary claim. Almost all supply and demand curves don't have cliffs. And without extraordinary knowledge of toilet paper manufacturing and consumption how would you know this cliff exists at $1.68 per roll.
- MattGaiser 7y agoBut that constricts the supply because if you want to make a short term investment (the length of the pandemic) to increase the supply of home toilet paper, you can't as that investment can't generate a return. Most production is based on demand being there for 5+ years the current prices. If home toilet paper demand will only be high for 2 years you can't make money. You also want prices to increase to discourage hoarding. Otherwise what happens is that people with disposable income just strip the shelves because there is no possible downside to hoarding toilet paper. They can just not buy it later with no loss to themselves if the price is the same.
- tasty_freeze 7y agoThat is addressing a different point. The comment I was responding to claimed people were upset that companies are making a profit. I countered that profit is OK, profiteering is what has people irate. What is the ideal pricing to achieve long term goals wasn't something I was addressing.
- threatofrain 7y agoAnd MattGaiser's point is that the line between profit and profiteering is vague. The claim is that by saying no to vague "profiteering", we have at least discouraged some of the morally healthy profit that would've encouraged otherwise inefficient production.
- pjc50 7y agoThe short term is too short: the investment won't pay back. Almost all profiteering reduces supply by causing hoarding and waste rather than use. Plus the dead weight loss of people killed by lack of PPE.
- true_religion 7y agoI agree if the disaster is truly short term, but is an 8 month rolling quarantine short enough to count?
- mhh__ 7y agoThat's true but there are quite a few people out there who don't understand/believe in that. Talking about buying your own health insurance is taboo amongst some in the UK, even though it reduces pressure on the (I should "our") NHS, because to them it's immoral to have capitalism in healthcare or something like that
- TuringNYC 7y ago5x more expensive might actually be the correct price. Remember that you cannot compare a price for a good manufactured overseas with lack labor laws vs something manufactured in the US with laws, insurance, regulations, etc. Further, just as the US abandoned domestically made masks after the H1N1 epidemic, and went back to inexpensive overseas versions -- they may do it again with PPE. So you also need to cover the costs for quite-possibly a factory you are building that might stop operating in a year or two.
- otterley 7y ago> 5x more expensive might actually be the correct price. Remember that you cannot compare a price for a good manufactured overseas with lack labor laws vs something manufactured in the US with laws, insurance, regulations, etc. Perhaps so, but if that were the case, the producer wouldn't be fairly accused of profiteering. Usually these accusations arise when the production or acquisition cost for the seller is low and the sale price is very high.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vdnkh 7y ago> (no one can justify extra manufacturing etc. In cases where the free market isn't incentivized to make the supplies we need, it's the job of the government to take over and make them. "Profiting from catastrophe" as you put it will result in price gouging.
- mhh__ 7y agoI think they were arguing that measures intended to stop price gouging can disincentivize an increase in supply, e.g. it's a lot harder to undercut someone selling a pack of toilet paper for £10 than £1. Definitely possible but I'm not sure it's happening specifically at the moment.
- dehrmann 7y agoIn the US, especially at the current federal level, the market is better at making a profit than the government is at governing.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> it's the job of the government to take over and make them And how that usually works is that the government offers to pay a very high price to someone willing to doing so. This isn't all that different as the government then pays 5x for the item.
- jimktrains2 7y agoIt need not be a high unit price, often a sufficiently large order could do the same as well.
- MattGaiser 7y agoDepends on the timeframe. If you want 5 million masks next week and each machine produces 1 million a week, you need 5 machines. If you can wait 5 weeks, then one machine will do. But yes, this certainly could be true.
- backtoyoujim 7y agoSeems like that means of productions being shuttered to protect humans might have a bigger play on that.
- haltingproblem 7y agoYour take itself is a judgement. Does a company indulging in non-coerced commerce (i.e. voluntary) make it virtuous? Why is questioning the efficacy, for society, of the economic models of any company considered immoral? Capitalist enterprises are neither immoral (left) nor moral (right). They just happen to be the most efficient - read easy to cobble together. It does not mean they are the best outcome for society.
- mhh__ 7y agoBest outcome for whom? I trust people to spend their own money in the way that they want rather than some top down dictated manner. I don't like the societal purpose questioning because people forget that not everyone has a lot of money to spend - the trade-off will almost definitely be between "ethics" and the cost to the person on the street. I don't buy my books from Amazon because I love Amazon, I do it because it's the cheapest option and I know it'll work. If you want to spend a bit more and support a local book company that's up to you but Amazon is undoubtedly a better experience than any other company I've seen (Specifically for relatively niche technical books, if it was a fiction book it's basically the same). ^ that isn't to say Amazon should he left to monopolize as they please, just that the nuance is easily missed.
- haltingproblem 7y agoI never ever said anything about top-down choice depriving solutions. That is a straw-man you have dragged into this conversation. This is not a debate about the merits of capitalism vs. socialism (or communism). This is simply saying that some free-market solutions lead to worse outcomes for society. My hoped-for solution was a co-op model app which is completely in the free market realm. You went ahead and made this about the inherent virtue of capitalism and choice. I really dont know what you are saying about Amazon since you seem to be equivocating. Not letting Amazon be a monopoly is depriving their customers of choice!
- kofejnik 7y ago> worse outcomes for society as determined by who?
- matthewdgreen 7y agoI love food delivery apps. It’s incredibly convenient to have a single consistent app that provides me with so many options in one place. I’m also not blind to the fact that this convenience comes at a huge and invisible cost: it’s being used as a cudgel to literally beat the snot out of my local restaurants, quite possibly resulting in many of the best ones going out of business. The power of this small and apparently harmless gatekeeping effect is one of the most unfortunate aspects of capitalism as practiced by real human beings —- and that inefficiency is precisely why so much VC capital is being invested in capturing the customer interface to various industries, rather than in new productive applications.
- bergstromm466 7y agoYes, what you describe sounds similar to what I'm starting to see everywhere too. Join me in moving to Open/Protocol Cooperativism (vs. today's Platform Capitalism), and Commons based peer production. The real matrix over our eyes is mis-judging 'money' as a neutral protocol - when it is in fact a proprietary protocol that steers every part of our lives and is aimed at extracting a rent. [1][2] [] https://www.resilience.org/stories/2017-08-03/book-day-corruption-capitalism-guy-standing/ https://www.resilience.org/stories/2017-08-03/book-day-corru... [] https://www.artbrock.com/2014/11/21/designing-social-flows-chapter-6-on-designing-incentives https://www.artbrock.com/2014/11/21/designing-social-flows-c..., http://eric.harris-braun.com/blog/2012/01/03/id-225 http://eric.harris-braun.com/blog/2012/01/03/id-225
- aloukissas 7y agoBut is there really competition? All platforms seem to charge the same outrageous fees to the businesses, we're not seeing competition driving fees down. It's more like a coordinated oligopoly with price-fixing.
- mylons 7y agothis and there doesn't appear to be an abundance of choice in teh apps? and they're consolidating right now
- nerfhammer 7y agoIs it possible that delivery itself is actually inherently expensive?
- theterriblestid 7y agoOnline ordering companies like ChowNow & qMenu that take <5% commission have existed for ages.
- maxpert 7y agoI personally believe these businesses have lagged seriously in upgrading themselves to what was coming for them. They would have paid a certain percentage to cooks, and staff from the prices they were charging, definitely lower than they deserved (hence tipping). Nobody ever complained about them not paying enough and not buying insurance for them. Now once these delivery companies have forced their hands into paying commissions (BTW same items are expensive 10-30% on Uber/DoorDash and people still order) they have suddenly came to a rude awakening. Not that I don’t sympathize with small business owners going through trouble, but this sound hypocritical when Amazon in retail space has done exact thing and nobody cares, but over here everyone sees opportunity for political point scoring.
- Ozzie_osman 7y ago> Amazon in retail space has done exact thing and nobody cares, but over here everyone sees opportunity for political point scoring. Some people care about both.
- m4rtink 7y agoTiping and how it is used in some countries to basically subsidize staff wages is just so wrong. For example in Japan there is no tipping and trying to do so will be considered very rude. The restaurant and its staff are professionals, they have set a price and you are paying it. They dont expect a tip for doing a good job as they simply strive to do a good job each and every time they serve guests.
- xenocyon 7y ago> prevalence indicates the customers appreciate their presence Focusing solely on consumers ignores negative externalities. There are many situations in which cost benefits from such externalities (slavery, pollution, human rights abuses, animal mistreatment) can lead to a favorable marketplace position vs competitors who do not exploit such externalities. What is more, many of these exploits (slavery, pollution, human rights abuses, animal mistreatment) were or are legal at the time such exploitation occurred. Therefore using legality as sole criterion of propriety is insufficient. A moralistic/ethical take on business is, far from a negative thing, highly necessary.
- randomgoose 7y agoThis is such a beautiful answer. I never thought of that, what we consider today as the absurd was knife the norm, so challenging the quo is so important
- kgantchev 7y agoI don't think the poster used legality as the moral compass, rather, consumer choice was the moral compass. If consumers lack the moral conciousness on their day to day transactions, then how can we expect them to make the right moral choices when they vote?
- xenocyon 7y agoI addressed consumer choice in my first paragraph. Let me expand on that: There have in fact been successful consumer-led movements, but the most successful of these concern cases where the consumers also happened to be the same people being exploited (colonial India's rejection of dumped British textiles, the Montgomery bus boycott, the Boston tea party, etc). Cases where consumers have acted en masse on behalf of another exploited class are a lot fewer and weaker. To some extent, one may point to the current growth of organic animal products as an example of this, but even in this case, this has been boosted by consumers seeing these choices (in some cases rightly, in some wrongly) as also healthier for human end consumers besides the question of animal cruelty. History's guide suggests that while morally-minded consumers can and should vote with their wallets, such personal virtuous choices are largely useless without a larger movement to effect change.
- thatcat 7y agoContinuing with that logic; the prevalence of beggars on street corners indicates that their patrons appreciate their presence in the space.
- throwaway2048 7y agoAlso everyone loves customer service on airlines, the fact that it keeps getting worse is gold plated proof
- cma 7y agoLikewise long wait times on customer service phone lines is proof your time is valued the same as the company's.
- indecisive_user 7y agoNow you're talking about price discrimination, which customers DO prefer. If I wanted premium service and a premium seat, I can pay the premium price for business or first class, or fly on a better airline. Even though people complain about the terribly small seats and lack of service on budget airlines and economy tickets, they still choose the lowest seat price above anything else. And the cost of plane tickets has fallen drastically over the past few decades so it's not like the same product is more expensive, people just want cheap flights.
- paulcole 7y ago> Their prevalence indicates the customers appreciate their presence in the space Appreciated their presence in the space or appreciated that some VC bozos were handing out huge discounts on taxi rides?
- _curious_ 7y agoThe word "should" is a red flag.
- dev_tty01 7y agoFrom a business perspective, it seems the biggest issue is that this price gouging is short term thinking. It may simply be that a sustainable (where no participants are victimized) version of this business model doesn't exist.