4 ms·
For most of the United States the total lockdown has been overkill. A better way to compare the US to most European countries would be to compare individual sta
by rement 6y ago
For most of the United States the total lockdown has been overkill. A better way to compare the US to most European countries would be to compare individual states and even then some states have rural populations that would have been fine without lockdowns. For example, New York City is one of the hardest hit cities but the rest of the state of New York has had significantly less cases and deaths. Is this because of the lockdowns? Probably, but at the same time our hospitals have not been running at capacity or even close to that (some have even furloughed workers because all elective procedures have been cancelled).
If the goal is to find a cure before we lift lockdowns we better do something to help those economically impacted by them (and giving away free money is not a viable option). If the goal is to not overwhelm our healthcare systems we are doing that great but a country wide lockdown is not viable either. The New York Times has a good map [0] to show how little most of the country has been affected. That is why state governments should be handling the outbreaks in their own state instead of shutting down the country all together.
These lockdowns were implemented because we had no idea how this virus worked or where it was. We have a much better idea now and each state can act accordingly.
[0]: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/coronavirus-us-cases.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/coronavirus-us-c...
- rement 6y agoGeorgia is a good example of a state that has started to open it's economy and is still seeing a decline in new cases. NPR has been tracking state restrictions and Georgia lifted some restrictions April 24[0] more restrictions were lifted May 1 [0]: https://www.npr.org/847415273#georgia https://www.npr.org/847415273#georgia edit: April 24 was earlier than May 1 for some lifted restrictions.
- mkr-hn 6y agoGeorgia's cities and counties mostly put their own measures in place without waiting for the governor to decide to do something. I don't think they're waiting for or depending on the state's call on it.
- rement 6y agoEven better. Atlanta, GA is very different from Savannah, GA and both can act in a way that is best for each city.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tacomonstrous 6y agoIt appears that GA is also engaging in some reporting shenanigans to make things look better than they are: https://twitter.com/GAFollowers/status/1261688916375212037?s=20 https://twitter.com/GAFollowers/status/1261688916375212037?s...
- rement 6y agoBad reporting or not the new cases are declining.