3 ms·
> it would be OK/normal I don't think anyone thinks it's OK or normal. Does the US have no absolutely mechanism at all for restricting travel if there is an e
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> it would be OK/normal
I don't think anyone thinks it's OK or normal.
Does the US have no absolutely mechanism at all for restricting travel if there is an emergency? What would they do if there was an invasion or a pandemic where there was a much higher proportion of people dying?
- 0xffff2 7y ago>Does the US have no absolutely mechanism at all for restricting travel if there is an emergency? What would they do if there was an invasion or a pandemic where there was a much higher proportion of people dying? I'm not a lawyer, but I really don't think it does. As mentioned in a sibling comment, flights might be grounded, but that doesn't stop you from getting in your car and driving. Freedom of movement is enshrined both in the constitution and in the culture to a very high degree.
- leetcrew 7y agoall flights were grounded for two days after 9/11. not sure if there's a strictly legal mechanism or if no one protested at the time.
- gambiting 7y agoI guess not being able to travel and not being allowed to travel are two separate things.
- jdblair 7y agoYes, that's correct. There is no mechanism to restrict all internal travel, no federal power to stop people from traveling between states. The FAA can ground flights and stop trains. The various state police forces can set up road blocks at borders.
- ghaff 7y ago>The various state police forces can set up road blocks at borders. They can (and did to at least some degree early on in the current situation) but it's probably unconstitutional. Of course, in an emergency for a limited time, police and military can go ahead and do things knowing they have the force and it will probably take a while before the courts can tell them to knock it off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_United_States_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_Unit...
- matz1 7y ago>Does the US have no absolutely mechanism at all for restricting travel if there is an emergency? I certainly hope so. I wouldn't support such mechanism. Yes, like anything, I understand there would be trade off.
- jandrewrogers 7y agoThis is correct, there is no legal mechanism to restrict travel as it is a constitutionally protected right, like free speech. In fact, the US Supreme Court has ruled that it is illegal for the government to enact de facto restrictions on common means of travel via regulatory powers e.g. closing all the roads. Restrictions on use of means of travel are allowable for narrow, limited purposes, like when the FAA grounds aircraft due to imminent safety issues pertaining to their operation (e.g. 9/11 or design defects). Like with all fundamentally recognized rights in the US, there are no exceptions for broad emergencies, and the Supreme Court has consistently upheld this view in modern history. Abrogation of fundamental rights can only be done in very narrowly targeted ways and generally comes with a due process requirement.