8 ms·
> Importantly, we detected SARS-CoV-2−reactive CD4+ T cells in ~40-60% of unexposed individuals, suggesting cross-reactive T cell recognition between circulatin
by walterbell 7y ago
> Importantly, we detected SARS-CoV-2−reactive CD4+ T cells in ~40-60% of unexposed individuals, suggesting cross-reactive T cell recognition between circulating ‘common cold’ coronaviruses and SARS-Cov-2
This is saying that 40-60% of existing immune responses (learned over many years of previous coronaviruses) are also protective against the SARS-Cov-2 virus which causes Covid-19 disease.
There is a time-based arms race between virus replication & immune defense. If these subjects are otherwise healthy, their immune system should have a good chance of clearing the Covid-19 virus successfully, because it has a "running start" against the new virus.
After recovery, their adaptive immune system should have developed an additional immune response that is customized to defend against Covid-19.
- dkdk8283 7y ago> If they are otherwise healthy, their immune system should have a good chance of clearing the Covid-19 virus Yet we decimated our economy out of an absolute panic and still continue to push for lockdown even when numbers show it’s time to start things again.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y ago> decimated our economy out of an absolute panic and still continue to push for lockdown 80,000 Americans died, and thousands more will die before this is over.
- CydeWeys 7y agoAnd that's with the lockdowns. The figures could easily be an order of magnitude or more worse be now without them. We successfully managed to not exceed the capacity of our healthcare system, for the most part.
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's not past tense yet...
- jfnixon 7y agoThere is still a piper to pay for the lockdowns, and that is the patients who will die due to untreated heart disease, missed cancer treatments and surgeries, mental health problems, und so weiter. Not to mention all the people who will now find their disease at a later date and suffer a worse prognosis for it. The lockdowns could have created more deaths and suffering than were prevented, but we won't know for some time.
- CydeWeys 7y agoSocial distancing was always going to happen. Restaurants here in NYC were running at one quarter their normal business in the days leading up to the official lockdown. People aren't stupid, and will choose to stay home when a pandemic is ravaging their community regardless of what official guidance might be. There's no world in which the pandemic is running unchecked through society and people are acting like everything is fine and normal and doing all the usual stuff they're accustomed to. This is a conflation of what the virus itself has down, and the response to it.
- jfnixon 7y agoNot at all. Hospitals shut down elective procedures, not because they were running out of room, but because they were ordered to do so. That freed capacity may have been necessary in NYC, and maybe not, but nowhere else was it necessary.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoAt the expense of all other medical procedures that people needed, let us not forget. We did all of this despite a whole bunch of people effectively having already been vaccinated against COVID-19.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y ago> effectively having already been vaccinated against COVID-19 There is no vaccine against COVID-19... unless you consider drinking bleach or dying...
- Fjolsvith 7y ago"Effectively" is the meaning I got from this article.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoNo, they're saying that 40 to 60% of people have antibodies that can make it easier to fight Covid-19... this could be one of the reasons the elderly die more often for example.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoThe reason the elderly died more often is because they didn't quarantine retirement homes, and instead send infected individuals into them.
- antonvs 7y agoThe paper doesn't say that at all. It isn't known whether these antibodies are effective at fighting SARS-CoV-2 or how effective they are. The actual deaths we've seen and the overwhelming of hospitals in multiple countries refute the kind of narrative you're fantasizing about.
- dkdk8283 7y agoMany many people will lose their homes, insurance, and die from other illnesses as a result of shutting down
- purerandomness 7y agoLoss of a home or an insurance can be temporary. The loss of a loved one is never temporary.
- perl4ever 7y agoIt's more like 90K now. However, for perspective, North America (which is mainly the US) has had 1.65M cases and 100K deaths, while Europe has had 1.76M cases and 161K deaths. With all the focus on the US as the single country with by far the most cases, it seems to have not registered with most people that Europe as a whole is of comparable size, has had a comparable number of cases, and has seen a lot more casualties. I wouldn't draw the conclusion that this validates the US health care system, or the decisions of authorities, because of other variables, but it makes me wonder if a narrative about how terrible the US is has been allowed to obscure the facts.
- gameswithgo 7y agoif we had not locked down everywhere would have been like italy or nyc or worse. remember that deaths peaked at 2500 per day in the usa with a lockdown. thats 5x of a bad flu season with no lockdown.
- asah 7y agoYes, and NYC locked down... imagine if NYC hadn't...
- CydeWeys 7y agoI'm in NYC and our biggest problem here is that our dumbass mayor and governor waited at least a week too late to shut everything down. If we'd locked down sooner we'd have had a lot fewer deaths and would be much further along the road of reopening already. One week on the front end is worth many weeks on the back end when you're talking exponential growth.
- jfnixon 7y agoNYC and surroundings are very different than FL are very different than California. I agree NYC was a complete disaster, but it doesn't follow that Dallas would have met the same fate.
- CydeWeys 7y agoClassic conflation of the effects of a pandemic itself with the measures taken to fight it. Things would not be going along swimmingly if governments hadn't stepped in with social distancing measures; instead there'd be a lot more dead and everyone wouldn't be leaving their home anyway out of raw fear.
- elmerfud 7y agoSweden begs to differ with this statement as the as the misleading headline article from the NY times shows that their numbers aren't meaningfully different than other European countries which did lockdown. UK which has a lockdown policy was quite a bit higher. CDC own numbers on this aren't really supporting the panic level either. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/index.htm Pneumonia is still stomping covid19 as far as deaths. Death projections are made from the 2017-2019 data and as of now they're at 101% of their protections. That number moves up and down but has been sticking really close to 100%. With 60+k unexpected covid19 we should be around 105-107% deaths but we're not. Things aren't over yet but all the be data coming out is very much supporting that is has been a massive overreaction. If we're going to overreact for the purpose of saving lives, why don't we don't we do it to solve the 9.1 million deaths from hunger and hunger related issues?
- CydeWeys 7y agoSweden is a lot more locked down than you seem to think it is, and they are experiencing the same bad economic effects: https://www.ft.com/content/93105160-dcb4-4721-9e58-a7b262cd4b6e https://www.ft.com/content/93105160-dcb4-4721-9e58-a7b262cd4... The main difference is that they have a lot more deaths relative to many other countries that handled social distancing better.
- mopsi 7y ago> UK which has a lockdown policy was quite a bit higher. No, the UK was following in Sweden's footsteps until forecasts became untenable, by which time a lot of damage had been already done: https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/03/16/905285/uk-dropping-coronavirus-herd-immunity-strategy-250000-dead/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2020/03/16/905285/uk-droppi... Compared to its neighbours, Sweden is doing remarkably bad: https://twitter.com/MarkkuPeltonen/status/1261138454236352518 https://twitter.com/MarkkuPeltonen/status/126113845423635251... In terms of economy, Sweden's GDP is expected to fall about as much as rest of the EU (~7%).
- hyperbovine 7y ago> even when numbers show it’s time to start things again. Which numbers would those be? Because I'm looking at https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/new-cases https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/data/new-cases, and it does not in any way support your claim.
- zests 7y agoIt seems lazy for that website to not show per-capita numbers or positive test percentage numbers. https://coronavirus.1point3acres.com/en/test https://coronavirus.1point3acres.com/en/test
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Retric 7y agoPositive test percentage numbers depend greatly on the rate of testing. People with the most severe symptoms are generally tested first. A declining number of hospital beds used is an extremely good sign, but there is very limited data for this nationwide.
- cdash 7y agoMaybe, just maybe you shouldn't look at new cases as your measurement when you are constantly ramping up testing. If you test more people of course you will find more people with the virus. You should be looking at hospitalizations and those numbers are pretty much down across the board.
- CydeWeys 7y agoAn alternative way to look at this is that you shouldn't remotely consider reopening if you don't even have enough testing capacity available to identify nearly every case. You can't control outbreaks if you don't have the data needed for contact tracing.
- koheripbal 7y ago
- maxerickson 7y agoThere's plenty of evidence that people not wanting to get sick is a big factor in the economic slowdown, it's not just a top down policy choice.
- JackFr 7y agoWell to a large extent that’s policy driven as well. The media have been pounding the message safer at home unrelentingly for weeks. Make no mistake, the virus is real, it is far more deadly than the flu, and while there’s no natural experiment it’s likely the lockdown saved lives. That being said, the messaging hasn’t been calibrated very well. Everyone talks about the post 9/11 “security theater” of the TSA, but because we’re unable to reasonably assess the threat, today we’ve got equivalent public health theater, but the TSA is us.
- alkonaut 7y ago> Yet we decimated our economy out of an absolute panic and still continue to push for lockdown even when numbers show it’s time to start things again. Remember: the correct recation to a situation like this will probably look like an extreme overreaction. There is basically no way of telling the adequate response from a complete overreaction right now. Even if it turns out that in the end the IFR of the disease was just 0.1%, or that 50% had existing immunity... then that will only change after the fact what would have been the correct response. The decision needs to be made without that information.
- user_50123890 7y agoYes, look at Greece, they implemented extreme measures. As a result, they basically had no issues at all with the virus compared to neighbouring Italy and Turkey.
- tripletao 7y agoAnd look at Japan, where they half-assed their response and turned out better (fewer deaths per capita) than Greece. I think most commentary assigns way too much credit/blame to the government's response, while ignoring yet-unknown environmental, pre-existing cultural/behavioral, genetic, or other factors. I'm saying this not to excuse government incompetence, but to counter the persistent suggestion that everyone could have the same good result as e.g. South Korea if only their government had responded in the same way.
- b0sk 7y agoOh yeah, the parachute has slowed my free-fall down considerably, it is certainly time to let go of it.
- rement 7y agoIf your on the ground you can (like many parts of the country). If you are still in the air you shouldn't (like NYC, D.C. area, etc.)
- ianlevesque 7y agoThis opinion would be adorable if it wasn't so dangerous. Every major area in the USA outside NYC and Washington is still growing in cases. It hasn't nearly peaked.
- rement 7y agoMy point still stands. The major areas still growing in cases shouldn't ease up. Anywhere that has peaked and is declining can start to ease up and continue to monitor the situation. We shouldn't require everyone in the country to wear a coat because it's cold in New York City.
- ianlevesque 7y agoIt is cold everywhere https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/us-map https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/us-map
- user_50123890 7y agoWhat do you think would happen to the economy if we let the virus run free through the population, and eventually everyone would be too scared to leave their house and quit showing up to their job?
- potiuper 7y ago>After recovery, their adaptive immune system should have developed an additional immune response that is customized to defend against Covid-19. The extent antibody-dependent enhancement causes mortality is questionable. Ongoing studies (https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04324021 https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04324021) to treat cytokine storm cases will hopefully be able to better estimate it.
- hanklazard 7y ago> This is saying that 40-60% of existing immune responses (learned over many years of previous coronaviruses) are also protective against the SARS-Cov-2 virus which causes Covid-19 disease. Existing cross-reactive adaptive immune cells or antibody != protection from this new virus. It only shows that these viruses are similar so there is some cross-reactivity from immune cells and antibodies designed to detect some viral epitopes (not terribly surprising). The question of whether these CD4+ t-cells that cross react are protective in humans would still need to be determined. (ie, what you’re saying is possible but not at all a foregone conclusion). The possibility of ADE mentioned in the discussion, for example, would actually mean that some cross-reactivity (in this case of antibody) could actually cause very severe disease in those individuals. This, by the way, would also be a good explanation for why more naive individuals to all human coronaviruses (ie children) do not generally get as severe of disease.
- mbrubeck 7y agoYes, as one of the authors said on Twitter, this doesn't prove anything about the effects on SARS-CoV-2 immunity, but it is suggestive: "Whether this immunity is relevant in influencing clinical outcomes is unknown, but it is tempting to speculate that the crossreactive CD4+ T cells may be of value in protective immunity, based on SARS and flu data." https://twitter.com/profshanecrotty/status/1261052353773363200 https://twitter.com/profshanecrotty/status/12610523537733632...
- belltaco 7y agoWhat if we infected people purposefully with common cold coronaviruses to help them get a level of immunity? Common cold isn't fatal or dangerous right? Could this work as a 'vaccine' or prophylactic? You wouldn't even need to test people with this test before doing that because the people with immunity will just not get sick with the cold.
- dogma1138 7y agoIt’s not the “common cold” as in rhinovirus, about 10-30% of cases of cold are caused by corona viruses other than SARS-COV2. Since corona viruses are quite common it will be hard to know which one causes this immune response. The interesting part is that early on tests of MERS and SARS survivors didn’t indicate an adaptive immune response against COVID-19.
- cameldrv 7y agoFrom what I've read, immunity to other coronaviruses typically only lasts a year or so. SARS hasn't infected anyone in over a decade, and it's been a few years since a MERS outbreak.
- pengaru 7y agoEveryone already gets exposed to common colds, hence common.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]