9 ms·
Betting on that now is insane. We haven’t even felt the main wave of bankruptcies and disruption yet. Credit is locking up (try getting an unsecured loan) and
by Spooky23 7y ago
Betting on that now is insane.
We haven’t even felt the main wave of bankruptcies and disruption yet.
Credit is locking up (try getting an unsecured loan) and people aren’t paying bills. 50% of New York tenants didn’t pay rent. Every seasonal business is dead. Life looks ok for IT people working in their underwear right now, but we are heading into a very challenging time with fundamental changes in consumer behavior.
The next big thing will be underwater mortgages.
- Spivak 7y agoRent I get is going to be weird. But with the plan to just pretend that the last 3 months didn’t happen for mortgages and add the payments at the end I can’t really imagine a huge string of defaults happening. And nothing about the pandemic made the houses themselves more or less valuable so why would home owners be underwater?
- whatshisface 7y ago>pretend that the last 3 months didn’t happen for mortgages and add the payments at the end How are people who can't afford three morgage payments going to afford a triple payment at the end?
- occamrazor 7y agoThey’re gonna pay the mortgage for three extra months, not a lump sum at the end.
- whatshisface 7y agoOh, so then it's nicer than what they're doing with rent.
- cloudartisans 7y agoThat’s a sweet deferral for people: at the end of their mortgage period, their mortgage payment is worth a lot less than it is today.
- omarchowdhury 7y agoIt's not like this for all mortgages. Some lenders are demanding a lump sum of the 3 payments after the 90 days.
- fragmede 7y agoThe traditional reading is "at the end of the mortgage" (ie, at the end of the 30 year period), not "the end of shelter-in-place". If the median age of a 30 year mortgage is 15 years, it doesn't seem unreasonable to think that borrowers will be able to pay for the payments in 15 years. Though to be clear, there are some lenders that implementing it as "at the end of shelter-in-place", but they're in for a hard lesson. There is also the corner case where the mortgage matures ~now, which is unfortunate, but that's not the case for most of them.
- gizmo686 7y ago>(ie, at the end of the 30 year period) My understanding is that the traditional reading was that the mortgages would be extended for N months, so there is no balloon payment ever; just the loan lasting a bit longer than expected.
- ghouse 7y ago> And nothing about the pandemic made the houses themselves more or less valuable Supply and demand. If people are moving out of Manhattan (and they are), then demand went down and the house is less valuable. If people have lost their job and can't afford mortgage and sell their home and move into a rental apartment, supply for homes increased and the house is less valuable.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoManhattan expats are going to boost demand in the commutable tristate suburbs.
- rabidrat 7y agoThat's not how it works, at least not in 2009. If you don't have enough equity, the bank is not interested in letting you short-sell your house and thus won't approve it (they would rather you default on the loan!) People who have more equity in their homes will decide to sit tight so they don't have to take a loss. Even commercial real-estate will let their properties lie fallow rather than lower the rent. "Supply and demand" is a nice platitude and economic theory but it doesn't reflect reality.
- pixl97 7y agoBecause commercial can keep getting loans to because the property price generally goes up. If lending tightens and prices stagnate you might, and I believe will, see a lot of comm defaults soon.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- josephorjoe 7y agoIt isn't just houses. It's commercial real estate. In NYC at least, almost all restaurants, bars, and retail stores absolutely depend on very high volume. That volume is simply not coming back. The tourists are not coming back anytime soon. And the office workers are not all coming back ever. Many will continue to work from home and many more will work only 2-3 days a week in the office rather than 5. And many of those will pack lunch or get lunch delivered rather than go out to restaurants. And a lot of locals are going to be very reluctant to eat in crowded restaurants where tables are 3-4 feet apart and everyone is constantly bumping into each other. I believe there are going to be a lot of vacant stores and shops in nyc once the immediate crisis is over.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> depend on high volume And they’re taxed accordingly. Governments are going to be facing huge revenue shortfalls, too, and they’re going to be coming after already squeezed taxpayers to make up for it.
- wegs 7y agoMaybe. The other possibility -- with people 3-4 feet apart -- is that demand will outstrip supply. You'll have far less capacity for people to eat, perhaps by much more than fewer diners. Two things are sure: (1) Things are gonna get weirder (2) Landlords aren't going to do as well.
- folmar 7y agoLandlords will probably do fine in a currency-printing world.
- ordinaryradical 7y agoAnd the banks themselves are overexposed due to what appears to be systematic cooking of the books on these loans. See this article published yesterday about one whistleblower’s fight to expose this: https://www.propublica.org/article/whistleblower-wall-street-has-engaged-in-widespread-manipulation-of-mortgage-funds https://www.propublica.org/article/whistleblower-wall-street... To pull out just one of several frightening figures from that article, just one of the commercial backed securities they analyzed appeared to have over half its properties fudged to appear more profitable.
- koheripbal 7y agoThat's a fair point, but most of those Mortgage assets have already lost 70-80% of their value. Look at the REM ETF. So are you making the argument that mortgage-centric stocks are going to go to zero? It should be no surprise that Tech/NASDAQ is doing well since both individuals and companies are investing more in tech during this crisis, while industrial/travel/etc are all still down substantially. Maybe the banks will take a larger hit, but the overall market has already priced in what you are saying.
- anoncareer0212 7y agoThe divide here is what you're calling "doing well" is "all time highs" and tech is "cutting edge retail/ads".
- zzzzzzzza 7y agoreits aren't doing well... but you are missing that credit/debt drives the economy not the stock market. And land values are actually the biggest store of wealth... and house prices haven't even registered any effects yet.
- lonelappde 7y agoI know you meant land when you said "house prices", but it helps to keep using the correct term to avoid misleading confusion. Houses are terrible money pits. Land (in an economically active location) is a scarce valuable resource. This is important because people overbuild SFH not understanding the expenses, and people ruin their financial lives buying mobile or fake-mobile homes to put on rented land, not understanding that the land is where all the value is.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> already lost 70-80% of their value And don’t forget, property taxes are based on their value as of Jan. 1 - huge, unpayable tax bills are coming this year, too.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago
- Frost1x 7y ago>Life looks ok for IT people working in their underwear right now, but we are heading into a very challenging time with fundamental changes in consumer behavior. Ah ha! The MUI is being skewed by IT workers expanding their new office wardrobes: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_underwear_index https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_underwear_index Now it all makes sense!
- UncleOxidant 7y ago> Credit is locking up (try getting an unsecured loan) Yep. Wife works for one of the big banks. They stopped taking applications for personal lines of credit this week. Stopped taking HELOC applications a couple of weeks ago.
- selimthegrim 7y agoUSBank was pushing these pretty heavily last week (the offer was only supposed go through end of April but they had extended it)
- tjr225 7y agoI was able to get an unsecured loan with a low interest rate for a classic car within a few hours after I applied.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoWouldn't the parameters for a car loan be wildly different than for a home loan or for a personal line of credit that's unsecured?
- tjr225 7y agoI don’t know, just throwing in my anecdote that it was really easy for me to get unsecured credit last week.
- intopieces 7y agoA classic car is secured by the car, right?
- tjr225 7y agoNo, with an unsecured loan I hold the title- not a lien holder(lender). I would probably be taken to court if I defaulted. I think I am fortunate that my credit is good enough to get the loan, however.
- sosborn 7y agoAt the peak of the last financial crisis in 2008 a stock I had been keeping my eye on dropped nearly 50% in value, so I dumped a bunch of money (for me at the time anyway) into. I told a friend about it and he looked at me like I was crazy. "The system is melting down! What makes you think the stock market is ever going to recover?" Six years later I sold that stock for a pretty massive profit. The stock market will always recover because people are always going to want to make money. Yes, some businesses will fall by the wayside, and yes, we don't know when it will get better, but people like making money and that fundamental truth will always keep the economy moving forward after things like this.
- 3pt14159 7y agoYeah but the stock market isn't 50% off right now. It's bounce back is temporary and most people should hold cash right now until we really start to see blood in the streets.
- klipt 7y agoIt's a game of chicken. Everyone is waiting for other people to sell which will make prices fall so they can buy the dip.
- vkou 7y agoThis would be a sound theory if the fed weren't printing money. The fed, however, is more interested in preventing deflation and/or complete economic collapse, than it is in rewarding prudent investers.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoThe peak (aka trough) was about six months after the start, so if you want to try this strategy it is important to have patience and not rush in too soon.
- josephorjoe 7y ago> The stock market will always recover because people are always going to want to make money. Maybe. SPY closed at ~$145 in June 2000 SPY closed at ~$80 in October 2002 SPY closed at ~$145 in July 2007 SPY closed at ~$75 in March 2009 SPY closed at ~$145 in December 2012 Nothing but dividends for a decade or so unless you did some clever selling high and buying low. It's been mostly up since 2012, but there is no guarantee it is up from here in 2030.
- NDizzle 7y agoWhy is betting on that now insane? Are you saying that you don't think the market will reach, and exceed, the present level in 10 to 20 years? I don't think it's insane... I don't want to put words in the parent poster's mouth, but I bet they will keep buying through any additional dips that happen between now and the "main wave".
- Spooky23 7y agoDisasters don’t always happen in a snap. We’re in the middle of a slow motion disaster, any anything can happen. Literally. POTUS could wake up tomorrow and say anything and do almost anything. That rolling of the dice problem with a very serious economic disaster makes it exponentially more dangerous in this phase. We’re probably closer to a depression that we have been since 1929, and that depression didn’t bottom out until 1932. Also my assumption is that folks in a public forum are middle class people with retirement funds and some home equity. Gambling with your retirement or the kids college savings is dumb. If you’re sitting on a few million liquid bucks or are very young, your situation is different.
- MiroF 7y ago> We’re probably closer to a depression that we have been since 1929, and that depression didn’t bottom out until 1932. And even in the great depression GDP rebounded within 10 years and had grown substantially by 20 years.