10 ms·
I've still never come across a decent answer to this question, so maybe someone can help: why is Basic Income (in the US) preferable to a Great Depression-style
by keiferski 7y ago
I've still never come across a decent answer to this question, so maybe someone can help: why is Basic Income (in the US) preferable to a Great Depression-style Works Progress Administration?
The Works Progress Administration (WPA; renamed in 1939 as the Work Projects Administration) was an American New Deal agency, employing millions of job-seekers (mostly unskilled men) to carry out public works projects, including the construction of public buildings and roads.
Headed by Harry Hopkins, the WPA provided jobs and income to the unemployed during the Great Depression in the United States, while developing infrastructure to support the current and future society.
Above all, the WPA hired workers and craftsmen who were mainly employed in building streets. Thus, under the leadership of the WPA, more than 1 million km of streets and over 10,000 bridges were built, in addition to many airports and much housing.
Much of the infrastructure in the US is crumbling and needs to be replaced or fixed in the coming decades. Wouldn't society benefit more from training and hiring people to clean streets, rebuild infrastructure, beautify urban areas, etc. than simply sending everyone a check?
I know that Basic Income isn't simply to replace jobs lost to automation, but I don't see how paying people to improve aspects of civilization is not obviously better than paying people with no expectations.
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoMaybe we shouldn't be presupposing that governments are better at resource allocation than their citizens. People will still work with UBI, but they are much better positioned to choose the kind of work they personally do best.
- keiferski 7y agoHow does this: > they are much better positioned to choose the kind of work they personally do best. ...lead to any sort of large-scale work getting done? Bridges and roads aren't open-source software and don't build themselves merely through the individual disparate actions of large numbers of people. I.e., thousands of people individually deciding that they want to improve their city's infrastructure doesn't result it in being improved; you still need an overarching leadership structure to organize it.
- rumanator 7y agoSpeaking as a civil engineer, I don't understand what point you're trying to convey. I love what I do and it's very rewarding to look back and see the outcome of your work. It really doesn't matter if there are inspectors or clients or bosses telling you what to do. When that bridge is up, that's your work that will be there for future generations. Perhaps that's hard to understand to software people, but working on something can be and often is rewarding.
- keiferski 7y agoI'm not really sure how you arrived at this interpretation of my comment, as it seems totally unrelated to what I wrote. My point is that large infrastructure projects require top-down organization, unlike open-source software, for example, which can be constructed through the individual, separate actions of large numbers of people. Ergo the disparate actions of individual people will not add up to a bridge.
- rumanator 7y ago> My point is that large infrastructure projects require top-down organization, unlike open-source software, FLOSS still requires top-down organization, just like any engineering process. You may be used to work at projects where a single person can parachute into a code base and rewrite everything from scratch, but there are also contractors who can build an entire house single-handedly. Once you add enough complexity to a project, you start to require hierarchies. > for example, which can be constructed through the individual, separate actions of large numbers of people. It's the exact same thing in civil engineering. You get contracts that are entirely independent of other tasks. The guy putting up utility poles on a bridge deck doesn't care if the drainage has been finished yet.
- keiferski 7y agoI really don't think you're understanding my point. It is not a complex idea. - Some things can be created in sum, by individual people acting according to their own individual desires. - Other things can only be created with larger amounts of resources and organization. No amount of individual action will get them made. To use a different example: the Manhattan Project would not have developed a nuclear bomb if it simply gave every physicist in the country a stipend to live and said "work on nuclear physics." Massive amounts of coordination and resources were necessary.
- supernova87a 7y agoThis opinion is pretty flawed. When will aggregations of individuals making $24k per year get together and build a hydroelectric dam or nuclear power plant, or assemble themselves to form a genomics research institute or space agency? There are things that individuals, left to their own preferences and entrepreneurial habits, will never create.
- itronitron 7y agoBasic income goes back into the local economy, most likely on housing, utilities, and food. So if an area needs a power generation station they won't have less money post UBI.
- sfj 7y ago> So if an area needs a power generation station they won't have less money post UBI. Just less people willing to do the work. Once you get people on the dole, they will continually ask for more while still doing nothing. And because we live in a democracy, they'll vote in whoever will give them more and more money for free. How's that for a bombshell that will totally destroy our GDP, happiness, sense of self worth and ultimately our society?
- devdas 7y agoSo working people will get higher salaries, and that is a bad thing?
- makomk 7y agoWhich means that the things they're working to produce have to cost more in order to pay those higher salaries, and presumably the endpoint of this is that inflation reduces the value of universal basic income to something more commensurate with what the people on it are actually providing.
- sfj 7y agoWhy not pay everyone $1 million a year, why not $1 billion? The issue is that to have stuff, we need people to make it. If everyone is on the dole, who's going to be making the stuff? The other big problem here is that when people do get money for free, the incentive is to vote more money for yourself. When most of the population is working, this isn't a problem, but once you get over 50% of the population who is expecting the government to pay their way, the country will just be a big free for all, everyone trying to grab as much as they can. I could be wrong, but IMO the risk of it playing out this way and destroying the entire country is not insignificant.
- aww_dang 7y agoHow is UBI not resource allocation by the government ?
- baddox 7y agoThere’s very little the government does that isn’t resource allocation.
- aww_dang 7y agoAgreed. >Maybe we shouldn't be presupposing that governments are better at resource allocation than their citizens A. allocate resources via new deal work programs B. allocate resources via UBI The choice between 1930's work programs and UBI is a false dichotomy. (C.) None of the above The great depression was exacerbated by gov. spending and the new deal. Rarely mentioned is the crisis of 1920 which was resolved relatively quickly by cutting spending.
- lmm 7y agoIt's the most lightweight, nonintrusive form of it. It doesn't require any but the most trivial exercise of judgement on the government's part to administrate.
- aww_dang 7y agoThat's only if you ignore the unseen, i.e. the broken window fallacy. It becomes a tax on everyone else who is holding cash when we assume that the money supply will be inflated, which is the default scenario. Otherwise actual taxes will have to be levied to fund UBI. If we accept that society has witnessed massive increases in productivity over the last hundred years, what happened to the 5 cent hamburgers? How does this price inflation help the impoverished? When we create a monetary spigot and allocate resources via gov. intervention, those who specialize in currying favor with gov. will always benefit disproportionately. Ironically, proponents of further gov. intervention use this wealth inequality to rationalize further gov. allocation of resources.
- 7y ago
- jay_kyburz 7y agoThe government can just make heaps of jobs in a huge variety of areas. People can still choose what they want to do.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoIf you don't have UBI or a decent enough safety net - or even a good enough minimum wage - it isn't a real choice, though. It is always a coerced choice, especially at the bottom rungs.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoYes your right, I think we need a good safety net. UBI for those that don't want to, or can't work. Real jobs with real salaries for those that want them.
- rumanator 7y ago> Maybe we shouldn't be presupposing that governments are better at resource allocation than their citizens. UBI works no differently than unemployment benefits or pensions, with the notable exception that UBI is far simpler and straight-forward to implement. If people are ok with the way the state supervises unemployment benefits or pensions, I see no reason why a simpler and more straight-forward program would pose a problem.
- ximeng 7y agoYou need somebody to decide what “improve civilisation” means, and nobody agrees on this.
- keiferski 7y agoThere's no reason to make your theory of "civilization improvement" too complex or comprehensive. Most people would probably agree that basic repairing of infrastructure, removal of litter and trash, adding parks, etc. improves civilization. This seems relatively uncontroversial.
- carschno 7y agoIt is controversial, as infrastructure is not neutral and largely influences the design of cities and therefore impacts who benefits and who suffers. E.g. build streets for cars or public transportation? Build more airports or research for alternative transportation means?
- keiferski 7y agoThen come to a democratic solution, like literally every other problem in a democracy?
- mamon 7y agoFree markets are pretty close to democracy, except instead of voting with ballots people vote with their money.
- carschno 7y agoAgreed, that was my point. Which infrastructure to build and maintain, and how, can be complex questions that affect different people in different ways. Hence it is not a thing that could just be done uncontroversially.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoWe don't all have to agree, that's why we have democracy. We vote a government in and they make decisions about what "improve civilization means. If they get it wrong we vote new people in and they try again.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoI am far more supportive of this idea than UBI. Employ anybody that wants a job. The world needs to plant billions of trees to capture carbon. Lets start with that! We then need alternate energy sources. We also need heaps more fresh water so that farmers don't have to take it out of the environment. Lets build desalination plants everywhere! So many great infrastructure ideas staring us right in the face, and now we have lots of people sitting at home and need something to do!
- wetpaws 7y agoScott pointed some very good reasons why it might not be a good idea: https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/05/16/basic-income-not-basic-jobs-against-hijacking-utopia/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/05/16/basic-income-not-basic...
- inyorgroove 7y agoThe point is find something useful for them to do. The WPA built the all the stonework retaining walls and stairs at my high school (est 1897). The record keeping wasn't great I bet they built more of it actually.
- unishark 7y agoPut an exercise bike in everyone's house hooked up to a generator. Pay people to produce electricity.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoI think a UBI would work well alongside a jobs for all program rather than instead of it. Say 20k a year for UBI for the disabled, carers, parents, pensioners, and people who are unemployable for whatever reason, or 40k a year working on some huge infrastructure project.
- sfj 7y agoAll built by the government by workers who couldn't get any other job! Why not have the government plan everything? We won't even need money anymore! Everyone works to the extent of their ability, for the common good, comrade!
- rumanator 7y ago> Wouldn't society benefit more from training and hiring people to clean streets, rebuild infrastructure, beautify urban areas, etc. than simply sending everyone a check? Society benefits from having cleaned streets, but it does not benefit from forcing people to waste away their life working as street cleaners.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> Society benefits from having cleaned streets, but it does not benefit from forcing people to waste away their life working as street cleaners. Then how do the streets get cleaned?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoQuite a lot of societies decide it's not that much of a priority.
- rumanator 7y agoA couple of centuries ago, cotton-picking was done primarily by slave labour. Just because cotton is nice it doesn't mean slavery benefits society.
- jka 7y agoStreet cleaning could continue to be an employable, paid task - and for people to choose to do it, it would have to be paid competitively (or be enjoyable enough for the person) relative to passive base-level UBI. A community desiring clean streets could allocate some of their UBI funds towards that goal. A community that doesn't could use those funds elsewhere. The goal would be for communities to acquire what they need and desire, rather than to try to employ everyone in society even if their assigned roles would involve useless work.
- rumanator 7y agoMore importantly, UBI creates incentives for soul-sucking jobs to become better or even desirable. Society should not rely on it's ability to coherce the less fortunate to sacrifice their lives performing horrible jobs just because it suits the fancy of a minority.
- jka 7y agoOne possible interpretation: Both could work (and in fact aren't mutually exclusive). The WPA is a little more like a 'stick' - here is the offer of work, if you want employment and remuneration. UBI (if working correctly) would be more like a 'carrot' - here is some remuneration to keep you going; please choose the projects, pastimes and infrastructure that you would like to work on. Both can conceivably lead to improvements in any area. Either way it's about creating the underlying incentives for people to want to do the work.
- anchpop 7y agoOne reason a UBI might be preferable is because it distorts the labor market less. Also a job guarantee program has issues like what to do for people who are generally toxic and negative to any work environment (these people do exist) and people who are disabled or mentally handicapped or otherwise find it hard to participate in infrastructure projects. A UBI also allows people to collect it while doing things like educating themselves, or doing unpaid work like taking care of aging relatives. There is an argument to be made for job guarantee programs on the basis that they're cheaper, since you get some useful labor out of people who might otherwise be unemployed. But in my view that doesn't outweigh the disadvantages.
- radicalbyte 7y agoPeople also get useful skills, a sense of pride, belonging and accomplishment from it. Although I don't see the problem of providing a combination of UBI and a Guaranteed Work program; with the UBI being a thing an GWP would have to offer actual progression and hope beyond just surviving.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoI don't know. Sometimes a job is just things like cleaning the portable toilets at job sites. I'm not sure there is much pride in that. I'm not even sure there are lots of useful skills there. Sometimes work is just work, and not everyone gets pride from "A job well done".
- bjz_ 7y agoThen why not charge people to do those kinds of jobs more? Or encourage companies to make the jobs less unpleasant and more fulfilling? A UBI means that workers have more power to be picky about where they work, which puts pressure on companies to improve conditions.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- radicalbyte 6y ago
- learnstats2 7y agoThese are not mutually exclusive, though. It would be easier to present a WPA to a government of the people, if the people's basic needs are satisfied and they are not having to constantly argue that more resources need to be put towards their basic needs.
- spyckie2 7y agoIn China, they did this. They could do it for a while because they had a lot of infrastructure to build, but eventually they had people pretending to do work because there wasn't enough to do. En masse for the US, it is a bad solution because we don't have that much work to do. We could probably double or triple our funding for infrastructure projects, but 2-3 trillion into it per year would be way overkill. edit: (budget for department of transport is $70b. another $50b could be useful, but its not at the same scale as UBI)
- keiferski 7y agoThen plant trees, construct desalinization plants, build parks in inner cities, repair old water pipes, add more public transit, etc. I have a hard time believing that "things we can do to improve civilization" is a short list. Decide what these things are via a democratic process.
- godelski 7y agoAnd what do we do when those jobs are done? Do we need to constantly be upgrading everything? Do we build buildings to house no one, in cities that no one is moving to? Roads to nowhere?
- keiferski 7y agoIn order to finish all of these jobs, it would quite literally take centuries. Again, I have a hard time believing that "things we can pay people to do to improve civilization" is a short list. Green energy, affordable housing, or drinkable water, for example, aren't things that can be solved in five years.
- godelski 7y ago> In order to finish all of these jobs, it would quite literally take centuries. Maybe in country, but not in a local area. That's a big part of this. If the issue is getting people jobs because there's not enough jobs, how are you going to move people around the country to do all these things?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoMuch of the infrastructure in the US is crumbling That's because America built more than it can afford to maintain. No point in repeating that mistake twice.
- mythrwy 7y agoWe can afford to maintain it. We can't afford to maintain it with the corruption that is current public bidding/contracting process in many places.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoSo you can't afford it because there is nothing to indicate the corruption is going away.
- mythrwy 7y agostates with no money for a bit might tighten things up.
- godelski 7y ago> why is Basic Income (in the US) preferable to a Great Depression-style Works Progress Administration? Unemployment peaked in 1933 at about 25%. Currently, it is close to 15%, but if we drop the outlier of a virus -- assuming things will return to normal -- it was just recently around 3.5% and has been dropping drastically since 2010[0]. Yet, I think many will say that things haven't really gotten better since then, right? I think we'd say the problem has been growing. So we have to conclude that a lack of jobs isn't the answer. Conversely, underemployment is fairly high at 12-13%[1]. It is higher for young people and even rising[2]. The lack of good jobs seems to be at least part of the issue. So I don't understand how WPA solves the issue. If people are paid market wages, sure, we can tackle that 3.5%, but is that even what we want? Fed says that the current rate is pretty normal and too low can cause inflation [3]. I'm not saying we don't have a crumbling infrastructure that needs to be fixed. I'm happy to support projects and make this country better. But I'm not sure how a jobs program fixes the problem. Because the problem doesn't seem to be a lack of jobs or unemployment (again, we're ignoring the current crisis on the premise of this being temporary). The problem is that productivity has increased[4] and wages are stagnant for most Americans[5]. I'm not sure UBI is the answer either, but I'm not convinced that WPA is either. Frankly, this isn't the Great Depression. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/205240/us-underemployment-rate/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/205240/us-underemploymen... [1] https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/unemployment-rate [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/payout/2017/07/21/the-underemployment-phenomenon-no-one-is-talking-about/#1506fc8f5a01 https://www.forbes.com/sites/payout/2017/07/21/the-underempl... [3] https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14424.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/economy_14424.html [4] https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/productivity https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/productivity [5] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us-workers-real-wages-have-barely-budged-for-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/08/07/for-most-us...
- lmm 7y ago> The lack of good jobs seems to be at least part of the issue. So I don't understand how WPA solves the issue. A WPA-like programme would presumably offer good jobs - that is, jobs with stable hours and scheduling, decent healthcare, and no fear of arbitrary layoffs. Its mere existence would push aside precarious zero-hours contracts and solve the underemployment problem.
- burroisolator 7y agoThere are a number of tasks like rebuilding infrastructure that most people agree is necessary. There is some set P of people that would be willing to do this in exchange for a $24k salary. There is also a subset S of people (of set P) who would be willing to volunteer to do these tasks (for "free") assuming they receive $24k a year from UBI. If the subset S is almost equal to P, the government should be able to start a large scale volunteer program that would be structured like the WPA. If the subset S is much smaller than P, the government cannot do this. Do we know what the size of S is compared to P?
- zouhair 7y agoWhy not both?
- qqqwerty 7y agoA tangential point, but I don't think a WPA style program would be feasible today. Most modern infrastructure projects are complex enough that they require experienced contractors. Additionally, job training programs can be problematic. Most industries, including construction, are suffering from high unemployment right now. Training a bunch of people to be construction workers would probably piss off those that are currently struggling to find work. For a modern take on the WPA, take a look at the 2009 Recovery Act[1]. It earmarked money for infrastructure and energy projects. Any new infrastructure/jobs initiative will likely look similar. And to answer your question, UBI and jobs programs are not mutually exclusive. We can have both. But jobs programs don't really cover the same use case as UBI. There are a lot of people who are unable to work. UBI also helps when someone is in between jobs. And on a per-capita basis, job programs are more expensive. Most UBI proposals recommend $1k/month. Paying people $15/hr to clean streets would cost around $2500/month, and that doesn't count any benefits and overhead (managers, equipment, facilities, etc...). And how many people would really benefit from such basic work experience? To have a real impact, we would likely want to train them for more high skilled work, but that would cost a lot more. And as alluded to above, if you train people in high skilled work, you risk flooding the market, making things worse for existing employees. The nice thing about UBI is that it is simple and cheap. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestment_Act_of_2009 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvest...
- lidHanteyk 7y agoThe goal of UBI is not to invest in works, but to invest in people. From this altered framing, putting any conditions on payouts will only disenfranchise people.
- jacoblambda 7y agoOne argument I often make for UBI over other systems is that it never incentivises not working over working while changing the cost benefit equation such that people are more willing to explore creative and entrepreneurial pursuits. Obviously there will be some level of misuse of UBI funds but imagine how many more people would be willing to pursue their "dreams" or interests as more than just a hobby. As for a counter to the WPA style approach, employment in low income jobs can trap individuals in a wealth band more than liberate them from it. Being employed is great but when the choice is work or starve and be homeless, people will choose whatever work is available regardless of the conditions. People may want to move away from a poverty stricken area however are stuck there as they can't afford to move away on top of working all day. With UBI instead, there is much greater social and geographical mobility. You can quit your job and move away from the city into a much more rural region with a lower cost of living. You don't have to fear that your lack of savings will result in starving or being homeless if you can't find a job right away as the UBI should cover the basics to keep you off the street. Another counter to WPA styled approaches is based on how the jobs are distributed. How easy would it be to get retrained if you are already trained in another field and are dissatisfied with it for one reason or another? Additionally, while not inherent to the system there is a risk that corruption could result in certain groups of people getting better selections from the job pool and other forms of preferential treatment. With UBI instead you can accept a temporary loss of productivity as an individual stops working to retool into a different profession depending on the cost of the training. UBI also largely sidesteps the issue of prejudice or other forms of inequality by largely leaving the labour distribution to the market. Note: These are ramblings of a man about to pass out for the night so take my comment with as many grains of salt and sugar as you can spare.
- BosunoB 7y agoOther people have offered practical reasons why they aren't really the same programs with the same goals, but in case you're up for getting utopian, some people see UBI as a necessary step as we enter a later stage of capitalism. UBI + reduction of working hours together are two feasible steps to reevaluate life under capitalism. Rather than sticking people in a 40hr/week job in order to survive, these steps give people more agency over their lives and probably improved treatment as workers. Basically you're paying people to live their best lives and breaking down as many barriers as possible for them to do that.
- keiferski 7y agoSure, and I think that's a noble goal, but it sort of ignores the fact that we have a lot of serious problems which would benefit from more workers and resources. Climate change isn't just going to solve itself and certainly a WPA-style program to build mass transit systems across the country would go a long way toward fighting it.
- BosunoB 7y agoSure, I wasn't trying to argue against a green new deal or anything, just to give a justification for a UBI in a way others haven't. Clearly they aren't mutually exclusive, unless you're the sort of person who thinks a UBI will mean nobody works any more.
- LatteLazy 7y agoYou've gotten like 100 responses with impassioned pleas about blah so I don't expect to you will have the time/inclination to read this but as no one else has said it... One of things I like about UBI is that if you can get cash for not working you are free to do something else. So at least a few % of the people who can now give up work will jack that in and either go back to school or start a business. In a few years, both those groups will be contributing much more (in taxes but also in general utility) than 20 people working in McDonalds ever will. That's part of the trade off here: if 95% of people do nothing, but 5% start businesses or other become 10 times more useful (which isn't hard if your working a skill-less minimum wage job), the program has half paid for itself already. That doesn't happen with a job-guarantee program, people remain too busy\tired.
- chanbam 7y agoBecause we're losing jobs to automation. The simple menial jobs of 1939 are robot jobs in 2020
- voisin 7y agoUBI covers people who could not work in these kinds of roles either for physical reasons, age, or simply geographic reasons. It also replaces most existing social programs and associated distortions.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoIf you need the infrastructure fixed why don't you just buy the service on the open market? Won't that also employ people?