3 ms·
> here the monopoly leads to more innovation More innovation in what? And as compared to what? The innovations you mention are all addressing issues that only
by pdonis 7y ago
> here the monopoly leads to more innovation
More innovation in what? And as compared to what?
The innovations you mention are all addressing issues that only huge tech giants like Google have anyway. And they are all funded by the ad-supported business model, which IMO is a negative that outweighs those positive contributions.
Plus, the ad supported business model means users only get the benefit of any innovations Google makes when it increases Google's ad income. That incentive is not well aligned with the needs of users. How many times has Google discontinued a popular application because it wasn't making them enough money? A company in Google's position is exactly the company that could figure out how to get a billion users to pay them directly for services those users want, instead of using their eyeballs as commodities, but Google has put zero effort towards that highly desirable innovation.
We also don't see all the innovations that are not happening because the people that would have made them are being paid by Google and other tech giants to look for new ways to capture more eyeballs instead.
> I'm pretty sure this lawsuit is just a political attack. It seems reasonable that other monopolies in healthcare/defense/etc. are much much worse, yet they aren't "liberal"/"blue" companies, so there are no lawsuits.
If this hypothesis were correct, we would have expected to see lawsuits against those other monopolies during, say, the Obama administration. But we didn't.
The lawsuit is specifically stated in the article to be targeted at the ad-supported business model, so the obvious inference is that all the issues with that business model that have come up over the years have finally built up enough political pressure that the government feels it has to do something about it.
- papeda 7y ago> If this hypothesis were correct, we would have expected to see lawsuits against those other monopolies during, say, the Obama administration. But we didn't. This presupposes that the DoJ has always been a political weapon.
- monadic2 7y ago> This presupposes that the DoJ has always been a political weapon. Of course it has. Look at the war on drugs and lack of prosecution when democrats enter power. Both parties use the DoJ to push their own agenda and perception. Frankly the expectation that the DoJ be non-partisan (much like the supreme court!) is naive and the democrats cripple themselves by even articulating this expectation.
- pdonis 7y ago> This presupposes that the DoJ has always been a political weapon. No, it only presupposes that if the DoJ is going to be used as a political weapon, any administration, of either party, is about equally as likely to use it as any other. Given the general track record of the Federal government, this seems like a much more plausible assumption than your implicit assumption that it only started being a political weapon just now.
- joshuamorton 7y ago> A company in Google's position is exactly the company that could figure out how to get a billion users to pay them directly for services those users want, instead of using their eyeballs as commodities, but Google has put zero effort towards that highly desirable innovation. Fwiw Google has tried this more than once. It's just that the value that advertisers get is way higher than the value that consumers get. There are specific search terms that can go for more than $50 ad bids. Individuals can't really pay for that much. Like how much would you be willing to pay for Google search each year? > If this hypothesis were correct, we would have expected to see lawsuits against those other monopolies during, say, the Obama administration. But we didn't. This only follows if you believe the Obama and Trump admins are equally corrupt.