5 ms·
Very difficult to understand what's going here, through the snark, personal abuse, name calling, and political bias. Everyone's trying to communicate through in
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Very difficult to understand what's going here, through the snark, personal abuse, name calling, and political bias. Everyone's trying to communicate through increasingly scathing Tweets and declaring each time that the previous Tweet is yet another new low point. Not a useful way for anyone to get a point across. Everyone should be embarrassed.
- Myrmornis 7y agoNo, I don't think that's right. That was my initial impression also, but what's going on is that people are ridiculing the academic advisor who is working at the Council of Economic Advisors at the Whitehouse because his agency (a) released a tweet about Covid with childishly absurd mistakes in it and then (b) he vigorously defended it in a follow-up tweet. The problem they are ridiculing is mainly that an observed time series that is going up and down with no clear trend is "modeled" with a polynomial that necessarily goes down, and that the tweet claims there is some value in the fitted polynomial. Secondarily, the fact that the polynomial is described as cubic, when it appears to be quadratic. Added together it makes it extremely explicitly clear that at the highest levels of American government, even in situations with the involvement of elite academic advisors, the actual technical content is utterly incompetent; childish; totally illiterate from a statistical point of view; bad even at high school.
- kevinskii 7y agoI came to the same realization, but it was unnecessarily difficult to see through all of the snark. If all parties had simply focused on the salient points of disgreement rather than snarking at each other, it could have been cleared up much more quickly. The GP is right; all sides should be embarrassed.
- kthxbye123 7y agoIt would not have "been cleared up", because the CEA didn't make an honest mistake, it was a deliberate attempt to seed disinformation in order to support the President's political agenda.
- arkades 7y agoThere's a subset of people that would prefer to think that the halls of power are manned by morons, rather than the criminally selfish. I don't know what that says about any of us.
- cossatot 7y agoMalice and stupidity are not mutually exclusive.
- ahdeanz 7y agoExactly. It was the epidemiological modeling equivalent of suggesting we all inject disinfectant. Only it was worse because it was politically motivated instead of solely stupid.
- ahdeanz 7y agoSorry but you’re completely wrong. If an analysis is making a reasonable effort to use the best or even some sort of relevant methodology in the field maybe. There is an entire field built around the learnings and failures of previous work that informs how we do things now. In this circumstance the economist came in with no understanding or desire to understand any of that and through some random excel function at the problem to get the answer out they wanted for political expediency. Not to mention the prediction was ridiculously stupid and anyone with common sense let alone an epidemiology degree could see it was going to be wildly incorrect within days. THAT is the model being talked about at the highest levels of government when you have the entire field of the world class epidemiologists at your fingertips. Trying to “both sides” this one because scientists who have spent their whole lives trying working on this got a little snarky is just missing the boat. There are plenty of other places where epi Twitter is having productive cordial discussions.
- kevinskii 7y agoYes, the prediction was clearly stupid. No one is arguing that. But claiming it was the "worst day in the history of the CEA," or words to that effect, amounted to a long and pointless distraction that could have been avoided, and both sides were clearly guilty of it. The whole exchange would have been rightly flagged into oblivion if it appeared on HN.
- throwlaplace 7y ago>Secondarily, the fact that the polynomial is described as cubic, when it appears to be quadratic. wut. a quadratic only has one inflection point. that plotted curve clearly has 2.
- andi999 7y agoYes the curve has 2 inflection points, so if it were a polynomial is would have to be quartic. (Cubic polynomials have 1 inflection point at most). Buz I dont think this is a polynomial.
- Myrmornis 7y agoYep you’re right, I said something daft. It looks pretty much like a Gaussian doesn’t it?
- throwlaplace 7y agosmall tails. maybe. it could be anything though with the right parameters.
- gji 7y agoDefinitely not a cubic function though, you can't get a polynomial to hit 0 that nicely. Any polynomial's leading order term will dominate as x increases. Unless they're using a super high order polynomial and hiding the blowup off the edge of the plot.
- Aperocky 7y agoAs someone who took statistics in college and worked in data science for a period of time, I understood very easily. But I don't blame someone who never fitted a curve to not understand - and that is most of America. The problem of today is not most of America have never fitted a curve and not understand the difference between training accuracy and prediction accuracy. But that they choose to not believe or even hear out those who did.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> But that they choose to not believe or even hear out those who did. Who are they supposed to believe here? There's a right-wing academic stroke political appointee, and a left-wing academic stroke political appointee. Both have genuine academic credentials. Both are saying something that supports their political masters. One appears to have been ousted by the other so is probably bitter about that. If you don't know about statistics, which as you say is most people, this is two equivalent people having an unseemly fight on Twitter. Did you notice neither presented an actual argument? Just abuse.
- Aperocky 7y agoOne of them speak the fact though, and things that are facts tend to draw in scientific consensus sooner or later. Like climate change, but people chose to not to listen to the scientific consensus anyways. p.s. The fact being that comparing training accuracy to prediction accuracy is something that is simply unsound. You can have hundreds of ways to spin a statistic that is backed by academic research, and comparing those two are not. It also happen to be the first thing you're taught to avoid.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> One of them speak the fact though But you said people don't know the facts themselves! So how do you want them to know which of these two people has the facts? I mean they literally say the same thing about each other - 'new low...'. There's no information to action here if you don't know about statistics! Even if you decide to check their authority and motivation there's still nothing to divide them on!
- tqi 7y agoDefinitely agree, this whole affair has a real rashamon vibe to it. it feels like everyone involved (the article, philipson, and furman) are talking past each other. As far as I can tell, everyone agrees forecasting and curve fitting are different things, and that a cubic fit (red line, allegedly) would be a bad representation of what the future will hold. The disagreement seems to be: - furman believes (or claims to believe) the original tweet was being deceitful by presenting a curve fit as a curve fit but leaving enough ambiguity that casual viewers might interpret it as a prediction of future deaths dropping to 0 by mid may - philipson believes (or claims to believe) furman thinks that curve fitting and forecasting are the same thing, does not address whether the original tweet was attempting to be coy or deceitful - article believes (or claims to believe) that philipson believes that a curve fit actually is a good prediction of the future, then goes super wide with it to make some vaguely related point about academia I believe no one is lying or stupid, but everyone is finding the worst possible interpretation of events so they can dunk on each other.
- Gatsky 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashomon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rashomon "Rashomon (羅生門, Rashōmon) is a 1950 Jidaigeki psychological thriller/crime film directed by Akira Kurosawa... The film is known for a plot device that involves various characters providing subjective, alternative, self-serving, and contradictory versions of the same incident." Now that is an esoteric reference!
- tprice7 7y agoIt's one of the most famous Japanese films, top ten perhaps.
- appleflaxen 7y agothank you for this great summary; i couldn't understand it myself, but can with your help. my only regret is that now that I understand it, i realize it's not interesting (to me personally)
- 7y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoI totally disagree, and the "everyone should be embarrassed" is "fine people on both sides" nonsense. The original graph showing the "cubic" curve is just - pathetic and sad. It's the equivalent of using a sharpie to change hurricane trajectories. And then Philipson defending this nonsense by calling someone else an "economist turned political hack"???? How the hell can so many of these people have no shame? I totally agree with a follow-up tweet - doesn't matter what Philipson did in his whole career, he will be remembered for completely abdicating any decent sense of professional ethics.