3 ms·
The Gibbs phenomenon is an example of this intuition being useful. Wanna make a wacky function with weird features? Fine. Wanna make sharp features? Sure...
by klyrs 7y ago
The Gibbs phenomenon is an example of this intuition being useful. Wanna make a wacky function with weird features? Fine. Wanna make sharp features? Sure... but the more points you specify, the wilder the behavior you'll see! Is there an electric force pushing the unspecified regions into the undulations? Hell no. Is it useful to think about there being an energy level that depends on how close the specified points are? Yes.
When you say "actively harmful" -- do you mean that it's doing physical harm to something, or are you using an incomplete metaphor of the kind you're railing against? Because I'm speaking as somebody with some training in number theory and teaching advanced math and I think you're way off-base.
- lisper 7y agoPhysical harm is not the only kind of harm there is. The harm that this causes is to further undermine trust in science and technology. In case you hadn't noticed, the validity of science is being seriously called into question nowadays. The result is, in many cases, serious physical harm. People are dying right now from covid-19 in no small measure because science denialism is having a significant influence on U.S. government policy. Articles like this reinforce the science denialist position because it allows them to validly criticize the advocates of science for advancing claims that are manifestly absurd on their face, like that they have "measured the repulsive force within polynomials."