4 ms·
This is an interesting and important result, but framing it in terms of a "repulsive force" is beyond ridiculous. In fact, it's actively harmful. Forces are p
by lisper 7y ago
This is an interesting and important result, but framing it in terms of a "repulsive force" is beyond ridiculous. In fact, it's actively harmful. Forces are physical things and this result has nothing to do with anything physical. It's pure number theory.
- Nasrudith 7y agoYeah - divergence would be a far better term rather than the analogy. They go apart but specifically don't interact. Instead it gets people to overlook it as more new age nonsense woo that abuses appropeiated quantum physics terminology.
- LolWolf 7y ago> that abuses appropeiated quantum physics terminology I would certainly not only specifically not say this is borrowed from quantum physics (perhaps classical EM?), but in fact the whole point of the theorem is to show that such roots do interact in a specific way. From Theorem 1 of the paper: > Let P ∈ Z[X] be a monic integer irreducible polynomial of degree n > 1. If P is not cyclotomic, then [the largest root of P is bounded away from 0 with norm at least 2^(1/4n)]. In particular, it is a statement about a specific root (the largest one) lying outside of the unit disk, whereas the remaining roots could potentially lie within it (and specific examples of this 'tightness' condition are given in applications in section 5).
- pas 7y agoFrom the article: """ Schinzel and Zassenhaus predicted that every non-cyclotomic polynomial must have at least one root that’s outside the unit circle and at least some minimum distance away. Or, to put the Schinzel-Zassenhaus conjecture in terms of repulsion, it predicted that the smallest roots of a non-cyclotomic polynomial — which might fall within the unit circle — effectively push other roots outside the unit circle, like magnets pushing each other away. You can think of the roots of a polynomial as negatively charged particles that repel each other with a force that decays when the distance increases, """ So if they can write a formula for distance between these roots, and it's always positive and has a similar dynamic to Newton's (or Maxwell's, or Ampere's) force, then why not call it repulsive force?
- ordu 7y ago> In fact, it's actively harmful. How is it harmful?
- naringas 7y agoI think they meant to say it can lead to confusion or be misinterpreted ironically, their misuse of the term harmful can also lead to confusion or be misinterpreted all in all, we should use more precise words (and thinking), but this requires more effort from both the writer and the reader
- lisper 7y agoNo, I meant exactly what I said. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23195709 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23195709
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lisper 7y agoBecause people who don't already understand what is going on might think that the words are literally true and come to all manner of false conclusions. Allowing such misconceptions to persist and fester can result in the rise of cults. For example: https://www.ramtha.com/ https://www.ramtha.com/
- Gollapalli 7y agoThis is silly, and I wish I had enough points to downvote you. Mathematicians borrow the terminology that is most helpful for explaining an idea. such a thing cannot be seen as harmful. Readers are not infants, and should not be treated like infants. They are responsible for the conclusions they come to, especially in mathematics.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y ago> especially in mathematics What do you mean?
- Gollapalli 7y agoMathematics is one of those fields where you can actually, really verify the truth or falseness of a statement, if you're willing to do the work involved.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y agoThat does not make sense within the context of the discussion. In any science, engineering, etc. field you are responsible for the conclusions you come in your papers/projects/etc. Even in sub-fields of those with an empirical component (if that is your angle) there are standards you have to reach to claim a discovery/success.
- lisper 7y agoQuanta is targeted at a lay audience so many of the people who read it can reasonably be called "infants" in terms of their mathematical and technical knowledge. Furthermore, Quanta often has articles about quantum mechanics, a field where misinformation is rampant and leads in some cases to actual substantial harm. Also, there is nothing wrong with appropriating terminology -- when it is appropriate (no pun intended). But, to quote Tom Stoppard, "If there is any point to using language at all, it is that a word is taken to stand for a particular fact or idea and not for other facts or ideas." The phrase "measure a repulsive force" has an established meaning in English, and that meaning is intimately bound to the physical world. There is nothing wrong with using that physical phenomenon as a metaphor, but that's not what the headline does. The headline says "Mathematician Measures the Repulsive Force Within Polynomials" and that is simply false under the well-established English semantics of the phrase "measure a ... force." No mathematician has ever measured a force, at least not in the course of conducting the business of being a mathematician.
- throwlaplace 7y ago>Forces are physical things Me thinks thou doth protest too much https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_work#Principle_of_virtual_forces https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_work#Principle_of_vi... Me also thinks you have no clue what you're talking about
- klyrs 7y agoThe Gibbs phenomenon is an example of this intuition being useful. Wanna make a wacky function with weird features? Fine. Wanna make sharp features? Sure... but the more points you specify, the wilder the behavior you'll see! Is there an electric force pushing the unspecified regions into the undulations? Hell no. Is it useful to think about there being an energy level that depends on how close the specified points are? Yes. When you say "actively harmful" -- do you mean that it's doing physical harm to something, or are you using an incomplete metaphor of the kind you're railing against? Because I'm speaking as somebody with some training in number theory and teaching advanced math and I think you're way off-base.
- lisper 7y agoPhysical harm is not the only kind of harm there is. The harm that this causes is to further undermine trust in science and technology. In case you hadn't noticed, the validity of science is being seriously called into question nowadays. The result is, in many cases, serious physical harm. People are dying right now from covid-19 in no small measure because science denialism is having a significant influence on U.S. government policy. Articles like this reinforce the science denialist position because it allows them to validly criticize the advocates of science for advancing claims that are manifestly absurd on their face, like that they have "measured the repulsive force within polynomials."
- juped 7y agoConnecting fields of study by discovering common underlying structures and principles is among the most rewarding methods of inquiry. You may as well say Noether's theorem is actively harmful and causing millions to die of coronavirus every second because physical laws aren't even shapes so how can they be "symmetries"?
- contravariant 7y agoSimilarly it is absolutely unacceptable that framers keep appropriating the term sheaf for something as silly as a bundle of cereal. Sheafs are proper mathematical objects that don't have anything at all to do with agriculture.