5 ms·
Not angering drivers hasn't worked at all, bike infrastructure has become worse over time. On the other hand, angering drivers did work in Netherlands.
by adrianN 7y ago
Not angering drivers hasn't worked at all, bike infrastructure has become worse over time. On the other hand, angering drivers did work in Netherlands.
- btrettel 7y agoTo be clear, I'm not opposed to angering drivers period, just certain activities which accomplish nothing other than angering drivers. For example, I will often briefly take the lane if it is the safest option for me or legally required (e.g., making a turn). Yes, many drivers hate this but the benefits seem clear to me, and their anger really is misplaced here. I don't know much about the history of cycling in the Netherlands. Where can I read about how angering drivers helped there?
- adrianN 7y agoI found this video pretty good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQk0O09gP4g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQk0O09gP4g
- throwawaysea 7y agoI think saying it hasn't worked is misleading. It has worked overall, it just hasn't worked for your preference. Most people prefer driving in the US. That's the preference of the constituency and it must be respected to some extent. Disrupting society because you didn't get your way doesn't seem compatible with accommodating a diversity of perspectives and the Democratic process. Put another way, how would you feel if car drivers rebel and park their cars across all the bike lanes?
- adrianN 7y agoAt some point the majority was in favor of slavery and against women's suffrage. I don't think that's a very good argument. The majority is often wrong, especially if the social system or the infrastructure around them is wrong. Btw, car drivers already park their cars across all the bike lanes, there is no need for a hypothetical.
- throwawaysea 7y ago> At some point the majority was in favor of slavery and against women's suffrage. I don't think that's a very good argument. The majority is often wrong, especially if the social system or the infrastructure around them is wrong. So change opinion based on legal protest and organization. Blocking infrastructure that others rely on is militancy. And let's get real - this is cycling we're talking about, not slavery. To compare the two is to downplay what slavery actually entails (brutal violence, theft of civil liberties). > Btw, car drivers already park their cars across all the bike lanes, there is no need for a hypothetical. A very narrow minority does this, and usually it is out of ignorance, not malice.
- btrettel 7y ago> A very narrow minority does this, and usually it is out of ignorance, not malice. Some of the worst offenders, delivery truck drivers, tend to know that parking in the bike lane is illegal. They tend to not care about cyclists, which is different from ignorance or malice.
- JAlexoid 7y ago> Blocking infrastructure that others rely on is militancy If protesters blocked all the routes - yes. But it's a case of causing inconvenience. Causing inconvenience is militancy only in a very broad definition of militancy. But it's a very typical thing to see - when you're in a privileged position and all convenience is targeted at you, loss of that convenience is often perceived as oppression.(Have you heard how evangelicals in US moan about being the actual oppressed people?) >A very narrow minority does this, and usually it is out of ignorance, not malice. Knowingly breaking rules is malice.
- throwawaysea 7y agoBlocking some routes is the same as blocking all the routes in many cities, since road space is often near capacity. Therefore physically preventing someone from going home is militancy. Such actions cause multi-hour gridlocks. It prevents busy people from getting home to their families. It prevents emergency vehicles from making it to those in dire need. In major cities, such disruptive actions are stealing tens of thousands of hours from people in aggregate. That is not just an inconvenience. You are casually tossing around the word privilege but the real privilege is thinking that your desire for cycling infrastructure is more important than the needs of a much larger number of people that are harmed. > Have you heard how evangelicals in US moan about being the actual oppressed people? I am not religious but there are many ways in which they are correct to make that claim as well. > Knowingly breaking rules is malice. Sounds like you agree that protesters blocking infrastructure is malice.
- trynewideas 7y agoBut that's the point — just because a tactic worked in some societies, does not mean it will work in all of them. In the Netherlands these disruptions effected policy change. In the US disruptive protests result in police brutality, protestors getting run over, and then public support for policies restricting disruptive protests. When policies get implemented in the US, it's through corruption — including policies we'd agree are good, like bike-friendly policies being pushed through municipal governments by major corporations who want them for their employees, so they get implemented where it benefits them and not where it benefits marginalized communities who don't work for them. As long as there's enough money pumped into a policy, no amount of disruption will affect it in the US. Disruptive actions _that don't target who's funding the policies_ won't accomplish anything here, no matter how effective they were there. So that's why people say "disrupting commutes won't work" here. The people commuting aren't funding these policies; they could all be voters and change out the entire city government and the same money will just pump through different people, and policies won't change, and the next time a disruptive protest happens the public turns against them because what did it accomplish last time? Meanwhile, the people who do fund policy are flying over them or riding past them in private or restricted lanes that they pushed through municipal government, looking over at the protests, maybe even cheering them on.
- JAlexoid 7y agoIt definitely works in US. There are countless cases where people have annoyed a group of people to sway the majority. (Do you think that LGBT got it's freedoms by not annoying anyone?) Just like public debates between politicians, these protests don't have to get the people getting annoyed on the side of the protesters. It's about getting attention and convincing others. If I stand and block the road for an ICE worker getting to the parking lot and he tries to drive over me - I'm getting more sympathy and exposure for annoying one ICE employee.