4 ms·
This would have been a more interesting article if they had people from the evo psych camp respond to the claims. It seems like Gizmodo wanted to do a "Boom!" t
by throwaway894345 7y ago
This would have been a more interesting article if they had people from the evo psych camp respond to the claims. It seems like Gizmodo wanted to do a "Boom!" takedown of evo psyche ("We at Gizmodo have long rolled our eyes at evolutionary psychology..."). Anyway, the philosopher purports to address a fundamental flaw in the evo psyche framework/theory, but she seems to be simply taking issue with methodological issues: she alleges that evo psyche draws broad conclusions about all of humanity by interviewing a few college students--effectively she seems to allege that the field lacks rigor (which is odd because she also disclaims that individual evo psychologists are serious thinkers). If her characterization is accurate, this is indeed a real problem, but it's not a flaw in the framework and it hardly feels deserving of the sensational headline or the disparaging, condescending tone of the article (to be clear, only the Gizmodo editorializing comes off as condescending/disparaging; the philosopher is quite a lot more polite/reasonable).
- diffrinse 7y ago>Anyway, the philosopher purports to address a fundamental flaw in the evo psyche framework/theory, but she seems to be simply taking issue with methodological issues: she alleges that evo psyche draws broad conclusions about all of humanity by interviewing a few college students--effectively she seems to allege that the field lacks rigor (which is odd because she also disclaims that individual evo psychologists are serious thinkers). If her characterization is accurate, this is indeed a real problem, but it's not a flaw in the framework This is her secondary critique, her primary critique is that Evo Psycho's pivotal hypothesis has absolutely no warrant.
- jacknews 7y agoI agree, she has a point, but then evolutionary psychologists don't only use 'made up' behaviors from imaginary cavemen in their extrapolations, but actual observed behaviors from other species, such as chimpanzees. I think this is where we enter the twilight zone. We have a story featuring a quite attractive and strong-looking colored woman, apparently challenging the evolutionary narrative, which has all too often been used to justify racial oppression. Good for her. But who is actually pushing this story? Gizmodo is all about clicks and 'engagement' Are they, really, trying to champion, or ridicule, this research, do they even care? IMHO the research seems flawed, but in any case, regardless of where we came from, we should just get on with the fact that we are all going forward, together.
- throwaway894345 7y ago> But who is actually pushing this story? Gizmodo is all about clicks and 'engagement'. Are they, really, trying to champion, or ridicule, this research, do they even care? I'm not really sure, but it smells fishy. What are lay people supposed to make of this article? We aren't qualified to evaluate the philosopher's critique and there is no counterpoint presented. Why should we trust her position over the other, presumably larger group of experts? Gizmodo was pretty transparent about its own biases in the first couple of paragraphs. Seems like this article could be reduced to the headline, "Publication finds expert to reinforce its own priors".