9 ms·
Philosopher Is Challenging All of Evolutionary Psychology
- danaliv 7y agoHere's the paper, no paywall: https://link.springer.com/epdf/10.1007/s13752-019-00336-4?shared_access_token=ZBkIZa1YiuE0LQx8Ahma9fe4RwlQNchNByi7wbcMAY6oc4laM4TmJijVKMoolnjpDhDOnhV8TTTUcQLqNu74B-gNKznqYTlhLGXnnYrIM4MaBSV38YtYwukwnpokq9XnfTUGyB6mvKA-zVrAg-MXHA%3D%3D https://link.springer.com/epdf/10.1007/s13752-019-00336-4?sh...
- Dumblydorr 7y agoHer main premise is the that the matching problem can not possibly be solved. This problem is that we think our brains have matching regions and matching behaviors to our very ancient, hunter gatherer ancestors. Her contention is that we can never study these ancient minds and behaviors, so we can never be certain of any evolutionary psychology. Is that summation adequate? She is not well known, I haven't read her dissertation, just the interview on gizmodo, not exactly the best science website.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> not exactly the best science website The first link in the article goes to another gizmodo article titled "the rise of the evolutionary psychology douchebag", so I'd add "not exactly the least biased website" to that as well.
- Chris2048 7y ago> We at Gizmodo have long rolled our eyes at the often-nonsensical conclusions that some people come to when employing evolutionary psychology theory And what qualifies the thoughts of "We at Gizmodo"? Writers at a pop-tech buzzfeed-a-like that became possessed by the ghost of Gawker?
- commandlinefan 7y agoHer entire premise seems to be "it's impossible to know for sure what happened in the past, so there's no point in speculating about it". This... doesn't seem very academic to me.
- throwanem 7y agoWhat's unscientific about falsifiability?
- jasonpeacock 7y agoThe problem isn't that we're speculating about it, the problem is that we're basing (scientific) assumptions about current behavior on speculations about past behavior which has no evidence to support it.
- commandlinefan 7y agoSo... "it might be wrong, therefore it's definitely wrong"?
- jasonpeacock 7y agoMore like "there's no evidence that supports it, so why are we assuming it's right?" There's no way to test any of their theories, and there's no historical evidence to support them. It's more like religion than science.
- mercer 7y agoThat's pretty rich coming from an anthropogenic climate change denier.
- commandlinefan 7y agoWell... you're right but... how did you know I was an anthropogenic climate change denier (although we prefer the term "skeptic")?
- tgv 7y agoIs this serious? Or is this a "I don't like evolutionary psychology, so I'm going to throw the problems of the entire field at it"? The matching critique doesn't make any sense to me, because it's a fundamental assumption behind evolutionary psychology, from which it derives hypotheses. But this quote: "Now, one of my major charges with evolutionary psychologists is that they go to the ordinary folks, college students, and they ask them questions about such intimate things like their sexual behavior. We know that people are wanting to not be honest about such matters, and, of course, evolutionary psychologists are aware of this. The second issue is that the answers given to these sorts of questions are then generalized to humanity in general." also disqualifies clinical, educational and social psychology. For a much more thorough critique of social sciences, see Tal Yarkoni's upcoming paper "The generalizability crisis" (in BBS, I believe).
- diffrinse 7y ago>The matching critique doesn't make any sense to me, because it's a fundamental assumption behind evolutionary psychology, from which it derives hypotheses. This sounds circular. She has offered a warrant to this argument clearly in the article.
- tannhauser23 7y agoShe's explaining why she doesn't think the "fundamental assumption behind evolutionary psychology" is valid - that is a wholly legitimate critique. After all, "shape of a person's skull informs his mental and emotional characteristics" is a fundamental assumption of phrenology, but we certain argue against it.
- tgv 7y agoBut we only can argue against it, because we can verify it isn't true. Hypotheses generated by the phrenological assumptions simply don't hold. Heck, even astrology can be tested. She's free to attack shoddy papers, of course: the harder, the better, I say. But that doesn't disprove anything.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoIt is amusing to me that you think that psychology is such a solid science. After all, the entire field is based on a remarkable and unfalsifiable assumption: We assume that people have inner experiences above and beyond observable mental states, and further we assume that those inner experiences are independent of culture and language. This is obviously bogus; humans are meatbag computers.
- throwaway894345 7y agoThis would have been a more interesting article if they had people from the evo psych camp respond to the claims. It seems like Gizmodo wanted to do a "Boom!" takedown of evo psyche ("We at Gizmodo have long rolled our eyes at evolutionary psychology..."). Anyway, the philosopher purports to address a fundamental flaw in the evo psyche framework/theory, but she seems to be simply taking issue with methodological issues: she alleges that evo psyche draws broad conclusions about all of humanity by interviewing a few college students--effectively she seems to allege that the field lacks rigor (which is odd because she also disclaims that individual evo psychologists are serious thinkers). If her characterization is accurate, this is indeed a real problem, but it's not a flaw in the framework and it hardly feels deserving of the sensational headline or the disparaging, condescending tone of the article (to be clear, only the Gizmodo editorializing comes off as condescending/disparaging; the philosopher is quite a lot more polite/reasonable).
- diffrinse 7y ago>Anyway, the philosopher purports to address a fundamental flaw in the evo psyche framework/theory, but she seems to be simply taking issue with methodological issues: she alleges that evo psyche draws broad conclusions about all of humanity by interviewing a few college students--effectively she seems to allege that the field lacks rigor (which is odd because she also disclaims that individual evo psychologists are serious thinkers). If her characterization is accurate, this is indeed a real problem, but it's not a flaw in the framework This is her secondary critique, her primary critique is that Evo Psycho's pivotal hypothesis has absolutely no warrant.
- jacknews 7y agoI agree, she has a point, but then evolutionary psychologists don't only use 'made up' behaviors from imaginary cavemen in their extrapolations, but actual observed behaviors from other species, such as chimpanzees. I think this is where we enter the twilight zone. We have a story featuring a quite attractive and strong-looking colored woman, apparently challenging the evolutionary narrative, which has all too often been used to justify racial oppression. Good for her. But who is actually pushing this story? Gizmodo is all about clicks and 'engagement' Are they, really, trying to champion, or ridicule, this research, do they even care? IMHO the research seems flawed, but in any case, regardless of where we came from, we should just get on with the fact that we are all going forward, together.
- jacknews 7y agoSometimes I think we live in a hall of mirrors.
- EVdotIO 7y agoIt almost seems deliberate to make things as subjective and opaque as possible. You know who else operate in this way? Grifters Sure, there are tons of over simplifications or extrapolating data which support narratives in evolutionary psychology, especially on the pop psych end of things. The humanities are full of ideology in search of evidence. But this... modules of thought? That has to be some of the dumbest reductionist pigeonholing I've heard in a moment. Let's completely throw out what we know about neurology, endocrinology or biology as a whole, because... it makes me feel uncomfortable? We are getting conned folks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- randallsquared 7y agoSurely the hypothesis about modules as discrete physical structures is not central to the idea that genes influence psychology? If you accept that genes control some aspects of psychology through effects on the brain and the construction thereof, then evolution can select for psychological features. Lack of rigor is an important thing to call out, of course. Also, if I'm wrong and the whole field depends on some specific model of how genes influence the brain, then that would be interesting, but she doesn't seem to be arguing that directly.
- diffrinse 7y agoI gotta say I'm surprised at the shallowness of the interpretations here. Very hasty stuff. Her speech is very humanities academic and this being a casual interview she's not in a rush to lay it all out in one paragraph. She's claiming we haven't eliminated a number of possibilities about how brain structure works and how that transmits over generations. Concretely, (a) we don't know just how plastic the brain is and whether the brain someone has today has identical locations for behavioral responses to someone in the past across the board, (b) we don't know if cultural behavioral selection dictates brain structure transmission over generations; and (c) we don't know if behavioral control locations (what she's calling "modules") don't move over generations regardless of the questions about cultural selection: >We know that ancient humans avoided predation, for instance. What exactly they did is something evolutionary psychologists have to show. Did our ancestors avoid predation because they were good at hiding in bushes or because they were running? Evolutionary psychologists would say that the better explanation is that they were running. But the fact that they ran to avoid predation and the fact that we have the disposition to run when we’re endangered still does not establish that there’s a singular module doing both of those jobs. These are real questions because we know the brain is plastic and it's not a bone, so unlike paleontology they have no physical evidence to base their speculation on the past on.