4 ms·
Hard to imagine people will accept a return to brown air and constant carnage. Most living people have never seen air this clear, or experienced cities so quiet
by jeffbee 7y ago
Hard to imagine people will accept a return to brown air and constant carnage. Most living people have never seen air this clear, or experienced cities so quiet.
- martopix 7y agoThe city being so quiet also means that a lot of people aren't there to actually see it.
- standardUser 7y agoSort of. People aren't very loud. Cars are very loud, especially their horns and the loud beeps from locking/unlocking with a clicker. Amsterdam is a good example of a bustling city that is relatively quiet.
- andai 7y agoI was being kept awake by loud traffic the other day and suddenly realized, in my lifetime, that sound will probably go away, replaced by quiet electromotors -- along with the smell!
- wffurr 7y agoIt could be replaced today largely by bicycles. $30,000 electric cars and charging infrastructure not required.
- duxup 7y ago> along with the smell! I grew up in rural US. I took a few trips to Europe and to date the smell of car / bus exhaust reminds me of European cities. It's not a pleasant smell but the memories are pleasant. Weird that in the US I just never associated big cities that I visited here with it as much I did with my trips to Europe.
- ben7799 7y agoThis is cause the cars are actually cleaner here... Europe is getting over its experiment with Diesel after the whole VW-gate thing, for years they were driving diesels that were polluting more than gas/petrol cars in the US were allowed to.
- akgerber 7y agoEurope, for decades, promoted diesel cars for the sake of fuel efficiency in the erroneous belief that effective car-scale emissions filtration could be developed. The US didn't, and gasoline car exhaust, while still terrible for human health, is much better than diesel exhaust. This has improved dramatically in recent years with truck/bus filtration systems, electrification, and car bans (or dirty car bans) in European city centers.
- jschwartzi 7y agoNow that the din of the freeway has been reduced here it's been replaced by the sound of everyone's noisy exhaust. I'm debating sitting on the front porch at night with a paintball marker and firing away at anyone with a loud exhaust.
- dmitrygr 7y agoha, if only, but no: https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/16/13651106/electric-car-noise-nhtsa-rule-blind-pedestrian-safety https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/16/13651106/electric-car-no...
- jeffbee 7y agoFor American cities it means that people who live in the suburbs aren't driving all over our city centers all day long. I don't know what it means for London.
- duxup 7y agoI think there is a yang to that yin in that without folks from the burbs coming in, those city centers might not be what they are today after a while... Sometimes I wonder if folks worried about 'those people from the suburbs' coming in would just result in cities being slightly more dense ... suburbs.
- jeffbee 7y agoIf the "yin" is people from Blackhawk drive on elevated freeways to their jobs in San Francisco and the "yang" is that kids from Oakland lose 10 years of life expectancy from asthma, I'm not sure that adds up to harmonious symbiosis.
- duxup 7y agoIt probably isn't, but I suspect the result I describe would be much the same.
- akgerber 7y agoPeople from the suburbs are great to have in the city if they're people. It's just that their cars are deadly and a massive waste of public space. Rail remains the best solution for this, as it will be again when we're on the other side of this pandemic.
- duxup 7y agoYeah I'm all for giving folks as many efficient ways to get into a city. I can't wait for a train to be built near me.
- chosenbreed37 7y ago> Hard to imagine people will accept a return to brown air and constant carnage. Most living people have never seen air this clear, or experienced cities so quiet. It might depend on the city. I imagine that in a many large cities people go there to work or other reasons and don't necessarily live in the places most affected by traffic and pollution. I imagine that these commuters do care about the quality of the air but I suspect they care more about being able to go work or run their businesses.
- jeffbee 7y agoThe continued existence of parasitic suburbs may not be assured.
- chosenbreed37 7y ago> The continued existence of parasitic suburbs may not be assured. What about the folks who've spent a small fortune to live in those "parasitic suburbs" LOL?
- ferzul 7y agosomething can be expensive even after subsidy. most people accept that cars are more expensive than bikes, despite having an incredible subsidy
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThe cities don't have the housing and service capacity for all the people who work there. The cities and suburbs wouldn't exist in anything near their current form without each other. Neither would exist as they are if rural areas didn't provide the resources they do with the (tiny) amount of labor they do. Our entire modern world is interconnected like that. You can try and turn policy knobs in order to have a steep urban to rural transition with minimal suburbs in between but there's always going to be a transition, never a sharp cutoff.
- jeffbee 7y ago
- duxup 7y agoI think first of all people will want to go to work and make a living. You gotta cover that need as much as possible before you change the latter.
- danielbarla 7y agoPeople are very good at accepting things, if not doing so would mean inconveniencing themselves.
- briandear 7y agoCities weren’t meant to be quiet.