3 ms·
Also Mao wasn't trying to kill people with the Great Leap Forward. It's sort of like how everyone gives the British a free pass for the millions of Indians the
by renewiltord 7y ago
Also Mao wasn't trying to kill people with the Great Leap Forward.
It's sort of like how everyone gives the British a free pass for the millions of Indians they starved during the second world war.
Incompetence is bad but malice is worse.
- watwut 7y agoIt was not random incompetence. Human life or suffering had little value, own vision had a lot of value.
- renewiltord 7y agoFor the Bengal Famine or the Great Leap Forward?
- shadowprofile77 7y agoThe Bengal famine was a terrible example of British incompetence and indifference, and one that gets little mention (though it's being recognized more now) but I'd say it's qualitatively different than most active genocides. The British didn't purposely try to kill those people, they just facilitated the kind of stupid mismanagement of food and food production incentives that allowed for it to happen unintentionally, then took their sweet time before finally doing something to fix it. The nearby Japanese occupation of Burma and a year of exceptionally bad natural disasters in the region also had some fault. Furthermore, if they get something of a free pass it might also be because the UK was at the time desperately fighting almost alone in a huge war and barely succeeding at providing for the needs of its own domestic population, let alone diverting shipping to feed millions of people on the other side of the world. One consolation is that the Bengal famine contributed to the disintegration of the British Raj in India after the war. It had been a catastrophic catalyst for tolerance of malignantly, and as it turns out, falsely paternalistic English rule.
- renewiltord 7y agoIndia was a net exporter of food leading up to it. So yes, they sacrificed some British subjects to save others. Mostly incompetence. Just like the Great Leap Forward.